Drugstore Beauty – Recent Product Reviews

Beauty

Gosh it has been a while since my last beauty review! I have been pretty busy the past few months, so in general I have been sticking to my makeup “uniform” (Almay Smart Shade foundation, Laura Mercier Secret Camouflage, NARS Orgasm blush, Revlon ColorStay shadow quad in Neutral Khakis, DiorShow mascara). However, I have tried a couple new items, and all the ones below can be found at your neighborhood drugstore.

In my last beauty review, many of you sang the praises of Revlon’s Lip Butters (sorry Disqus issue has the comments missing). So much so, I went out and purchased one (Berry Smoothie). You’re right – it feels amazing on the lips, it hydrates, and it gives a pretty pop of shiny color. It’s hard to explain this product – more like a creamy sheer lipstick than a tinted lip balm – I find you can wear one layer as a soft stain, or build for more pigment so it almost ends up looking like a creamy almost-opaque lip gloss. I like Berry Smoothie which is a neutral mauvey-rose color that is like my lip color but better. I can put it on sans mirror and know it will look great. These aren’t long-wearing lipcolors, but they don’t leave a stain or ring on the lips and keep my lips feeling hydrated and smooth.

Since purchasing Berry Smoothie, I have also added Lollipop, Fig Jam, and Cherry Tart to the collection. Lollipop is a bright, almost neon hot pink that has been my go-to bold lip color this spring. Fig Jam is a bit too brown for my skin and makes me feel like my ‘90s self, but I think it would look gorgeous on someone with more bronze or brown of a skintone (I sometimes mix with other colors to make them more day-friendly). Cherry Tart is by far my favorite – with my fair skin it makes me feel like Snow White, or possibly Blair Waldorf (her makeup has been pretty awesome the end of this past season). Soft, shiny, lush, not sticky and a gorgeous sheer red.

The only issue I have with Revlon Lip Butters is that like real butter, they melt. My Lollipop was in the outside pocket of my bag on a hot day, by time I got from my office through the Metro to my home, it had softened enough that the stick of lipstick had disconnected from the tube and smeared on the inside of the cap (I now wear it with a lip brush). The Berry Smoothie did the same thing, and now is a bit messy to use. Cherry Tart I keep in the deep dark recesses of my purse and will only twist up the bare minimum to apply to help preserve the product. This issue is enough that I hesitate purchasing another during the warmer months.

I succumbed to the hype and bought a BB Cream. While I like my Almay foundation, I prefer a lighter weight product come summer. I was at CVS getting allergy meds for Emerson and grabbed a tube of this on the way to the register. I chose Light/Medium.

At first, I hated this stuff. It felt cheap on the skin, looked greasy, and disappeared within an hour or two. Then I tried it without my Philosophy Vitamin C/L’Oreal Youth Code serum cocktail and it worked far better. It’s a bit heavier than a tinted moisturizer, but not as thick or heavy as a traditional foundation. My best luck was to apply it to very dry skin, while still damp apply my concealer over it, let it set and dry completely before applying any other makeup. By doing this, I like it better and wear it a couple times a week. However, I hate going without my “cocktail” and prefer to be able to use a second sunscreen for the best coverage. So while I learned to like the Garnier BB Cream, I won’t be buying another tube when this one runs out. In fact, as the weather gets warmer and my face gets greasier, I may stop using this product all together.

I have never been a huge fan of tinted moisturizer – I have tried some of the most popular brands and don’t get the hype, finding my skin to look just the way it did prior, just a tad more greasy. Garnier’s BB Cream provides more color and coverage than a tinted moisturizer, but isn’t heavy or as opaque as a foundation. It isn’t the best choice for one with oily skin or is prone to being uber sweaty in the summer, but is a great alternative to foundation for those with dry or normal skin.

I have used Maybelline’s Ultra Liner since college. While many find a brush for liquid liner to be messy, I work better with it than a felt tip. However Ultra Liner is very shiny, very black, and as I have gotten older I find it to be a bit costumey on me unless I am purposely doing a retro-inspired look. I wanted a liquid liner that was easy for me to control, didn’t have a shiny finish, was not black, but not a lighter brown than my eye color. After reading a ton of reviews (and seeing it was on sale at drugstore.com and they had double cash back with Ebates) I chose Maybelline Line Stiletto in Brownish Black.

Fan. Big Fan. This is exactly what I wanted. While it is considered a felt tip, it’s a long and flexible tip that holds a lot of pigment. The formula is thinner than Ultra Liner, but it’s not watery like other brands I have tried. The color is a dark brown with a slight gray tinge which makes it look more natural. It’s a soft matte finish, dries quickly, doesn’t irritate my allergy-prone and contacts-wearing eyes, doesn’t flake, and washes off easily with CeraVe come the end of the day. A very thin line right in the lash line just makes my lashes look fuller, a slightly thicker line provides drama that is still appropriate for the office, the daytime, and a day when I am not wearing a bold red and a smirk. Did I mention I am a big fan of Maybelline Line Stiletto? Because I am. Big fan.

It’s… fine. Very low pigment which is great for a fair-skinned lassie, but makes it hard if you actually want to look bronze or use it as blush or contour. No sparkle, which is something that makes me happy. Top doesn’t screw on, so it’s not something you can pop into your makeup bag. However Rimmel Natural Bronzer doesn’t crumble away like many bronzers; I expect it to stay intact for me to reach pan based off of usage, not disintegration. However, I am not feeling the love for the actual product like I have for higher-end brands like Cargo, Tarte, and Laura Mercier.

Have you tried any new drugstore beauty products?  Any you love and think I should try out?  Let me know in the comments!

Follow Me | Twitter | Facebook

  • This makes me love you even more! Nars Orgasm is the only blush I will wear… I don’t care what anyone says, it’s worth every penny. I have been wearing the Revlon Lip Butter in Raspberry Pie for about a month now- it’s a super bright,deep pink, and I love it. L’Oreal has a similar product Colour Riche Balm, but the colors are much more natural. I like the texture of both and I am pleased with the cheap price (thanks for the heads up about the melting- that’s bad news in these Southern summers).

    I have also been using the BB Cream. However, I actually use it daily in the place of my usual foundation. You are right- your face must be bone dry and you have to let it set. I have terrible skin- uneven skin tone and hormonal acne, so it doesn’t cover everything. If I am feeling especially self-conscious I’ll layer a  mineral foundation powder over the top or my normal foundation.

    Why I just gave you a novel about the stuff you just reviewed is beyond me. I was just excited to see that such a chic lady uses the same products as me 😉

  • This makes me love you even more! Nars Orgasm is the only blush I will wear… I don’t care what anyone says, it’s worth every penny. I have been wearing the Revlon Lip Butter in Raspberry Pie for about a month now- it’s a super bright,deep pink, and I love it. L’Oreal has a similar product Colour Riche Balm, but the colors are much more natural. I like the texture of both and I am pleased with the cheap price (thanks for the heads up about the melting- that’s bad news in these Southern summers).

    I have also been using the BB Cream. However, I actually use it daily in the place of my usual foundation. You are right- your face must be bone dry and you have to let it set. I have terrible skin- uneven skin tone and hormonal acne, so it doesn’t cover everything. If I am feeling especially self-conscious I’ll layer a  mineral foundation powder over the top or my normal foundation.

    Why I just gave you a novel about the stuff you just reviewed is beyond me. I was just excited to see that such a chic lady uses the same products as me 😉

  • Your uniform is almost just like mine! I’ll have to try out the lip butters for sure! And I still think I want to try some kind of BB cream, but love knowing how this one worked for you.

  • Your uniform is almost just like mine! I’ll have to try out the lip butters for sure! And I still think I want to try some kind of BB cream, but love knowing how this one worked for you.

  • Grace Mitchell

    Ooh, the lip butters sound promising! 

  • Grace Mitchell

    Ooh, the lip butters sound promising! 

  • I love Revlon’s Lip Butter! Wish it was a little more moisturizing but the colors are really rich. I haven’t had any issues with it melting (yet)… but had Fresh’s Sugar lip balm melt instantly even though it’s like double the price :/

  • I love Revlon’s Lip Butter! Wish it was a little more moisturizing but the colors are really rich. I haven’t had any issues with it melting (yet)… but had Fresh’s Sugar lip balm melt instantly even though it’s like double the price :/

  • Yep, Fresh has melted on me too. The red one and Fig Jam are still sturdy and strong, maybe I got bad pinks?

  • Yep, Fresh has melted on me too. The red one and Fig Jam are still sturdy and strong, maybe I got bad pinks?

  • I always enjoy your reviews – Unfortuantely my entire face broke out in giant hives and blisters after using the Garnier BB cream for about a week – painful *and* unattractive. If you “Google” the cream, I’m not the first person to experience this. Garnier’s response was to ask me to call them during business hours on the East Coast so the could “ask me questions”; CVS response – they’re immediately refunding my money if I bring in my receipt. No more Garnier for me 🙁

  • My entire face broke out in giant hives and blisters after using the Garnier BB cream for about a week – painful *and* unattractive. If you “Google” the cream, I’m not the first person to experience this. Garnier’s response was to ask me to call them during business hours on the East Coast so the could “ask me questions”; CVS response – they’re immediately refunding my money if I bring in my receipt. No more Garnier for me…

  • Sherry

    I am also a huge fan of Line Stilletto. I can lay it on thick for the stage or light for the office. And I’ve also found it is not irritating at all and easy to remove. Huge fan!

  • Sherry

    I am also a huge fan of Line Stilletto. I can lay it on thick for the stage or light for the office. And I’ve also found it is not irritating at all and easy to remove. Huge fan!