Ask Allie: Wide Width Metallic Shoes

This article may contain affiliate links; if you click on a shopping link and make a purchase I may receive a commission. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

I have wide feet and I am in a wedding this summer. The bride said we can wear any shoes we want as long as they’re metallic. My friend found a great pair at DSW but I can’t find any dressy metallic shoes in a 9 wide! Help!

While I can wear regular width in closed toe shoes, I find I am better off with wide strappy heels or sandals. So I feel your pain, but also know that there ARE options out there. Your best bet is to get out of the stores and get to your computer; web-based shops can have more sizes because they’re not restricted by the size of their stock room. Below are places to find wide-width shoes that have free shipping and returns, so you can try at home without buyer’s remorse.

I’ll admit selection is more limited when looking for wider width shoes. I try to look less for trendy styles and instead focus on classic looks that will be chic now and years from now. Especially as a bridesmaid, you don’t need a statement shoe but one that will be comfortable enough to survive several hours on your feet. Choose smartly, and this shoe will be a popular one in your closet with everything from denim to holiday frocks.  You'll be amazed how versatile a metallic shoe can be!


Nordstrom is my favorite footwear retailer. Not so huge of a selection that you get overwhelmed, but large enough to find something for every personal style. Nordstrom offers free shipping and free returns with no expiration date, and now is price matching if you find an item for less at another retailer.  At Nordstrom from the primary navigation click shoes, then go down to Specialty Sizes. You can then choose your specific need. I went to All Wide Shoes and then used the size navigation to only choose size 9 and then the color navigation to only choose metallic.

wide width metallic heels

1.  Naturalizer ‘Darzy’ (Gold) | 2.  Stuart Weitzman ‘Nudist’ (platinum snakeskin, gold satin, silver satin) | 3.  VANELi ‘Milbie’ (silver) | 4.  Kay Unger ‘Basque’ (gold, iridescent, silver) | 5.  Stuart Weitzman ‘Reversal’ (silver, gold)


Zappos is a great destination for wide width shoes with style. They offer quick and free shipping and free returns within 365 days of purchase. To narrow down their extensive selection, I chose Women’s Shoes, entered 9, then W and WW and then chose the color (I picked all the metallic – silver, gold, bronze, pewter and metallic). After this, I chose the Occasions of Wedding, Dress, Prom & Homecoming, and Evening & Cocktail.

wide width metallic shoes

1.  Touch Ups ‘Dakota’ (silver) | 2. VANELi ‘Marza’ (gunmetal, gold) | 3.  Touch Ups ‘Geri’ (silver)| 4.  VANELi ‘Modesta’ (Platino/gold, silver)| 5.  Touch Ups ‘Taryn’ (silver, gold)| 6.  Touch Ups ‘Melanie’ (gold, silver) is an underrated online store. They have hundreds of brands, free shipping, and free returns within 60 days of purchase. From the main navigation, I went to Women, then Wide Shoes. From there I narrowed down by size and width, then chose Dress, then the colors. As a heads up, the color boxes don’t have words, but if you hover over them the URL will state the color. Also higher up in the sidebar it will show which colors were chosen so if you accidentally choose off-white when you wanted silver, you can click X to easily remove it.

wide width dressy shoes

1.  Dyeables ‘Palace’ (silver) | 2.  Touch Ups ‘Monaco’ (gold, silver) | 3.  Touch Ups ‘Abby’ (gold, silver) | 4.  Touch Ups ‘Dot’ (silver) | 5.  Touch Ups ‘Jazz’ (silver, gold, pewter)

Shop the Post:


A woman with curly hair wearing a plaid blazer holds a green fur coat over her shoulder on a city street.

Did you like what you just read?

Consider tapping here to buy me a coffee in thanks. The best gift you can give a content creator is the gift of sharing. Consider sharing this article on Facebook or Pinterest. Thank you so much for your support!

Similar Posts


  1. My feet are 9.5W and I have a hell of a time finding shoes that fit, then I found You can make custom shoes in pretty much any size you can imagine and there are a bunch of fabric/leather choices including metallics. I just got my pair and they are the bomb dot com; super comfy (for 4 inch heels) and the perfect size. Pricey if you’re just going to wear them for one event (~$200) but a pretty good price for custom shoes that are well made. FYI: it took about 6 weeks from the date of order for them to get to me.

  2. I wore shoes very similar to what you’re posting about for my brother’s wedding and I was miserable. My advice to fellow plus-size ladies, make sure the heel is adequate. Often with these types of shoes the heel can be flimsy.

  3. Don’t forget about, Zappos’s bargain little sister. Selection is limited but you can score some really great deals. Naturalizer is my go-to for wide dress shoes, so I’ll find something on their site and then see if I can get it any cheaper on 6pm.

    1. Oh I love 6pm! They are hard to mention on a blog post though because their selection changes so rapidly. By time the post goes live often the pieces I recommended are out of stock. However I agree, it’s the place to go for great deals, especially if you know how you fit in a certain brand!

  4. Dang it, woman. You just sent me down the rabbit hole of spring shoes. Zappos now has $100 of my money. Thanks for the great suggestions!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *