Rothys Flats Review

This article may contain affiliate links; if you click on a shopping link and make a purchase I may receive a commission. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Rothys Flats: an honest unpaid review of rothy's shoes featured by popular Washington DC fashion blogger, Wardrobe OxygenYou’ve likely seen Rothys flats. They advertise on Facebook, they’re promoted on Pinterest, and if you google you’ll find tons of reviews for Rothys flats. But are those reviews legit? I decided to purchase a pair of Rothy’s shoes with my own money, give them a beating, and report back to you a complete honest review of Rothys flats.

MY HONEST REVIEW OF ROTHYS FLATS

For those who haven’t heard of Rothy’s they’re flats made from low-waste, low-impact materials and hand made into a stylish and comfortable shoe. Created from recycled water bottles 3D-knit into a stretchy yet dense fabric, Rothys flats are machine washable (and line dry), the insoles are removable (and washable), all the packaging is recyclable and Rothy’s even has a program to recycle their shoes when you no longer want them. With their flats, Rothy’s has repurposed almost 6 million water bottles. Sounds pretty awesome, but how do they fit and how do the hold up?

I have wide feet and short toes, and hardly any curve in my Achilles’. Put all of this together and flats are terrible on me. They’re usually too narrow or too wide, and if a pair does fit it will tear up the backs of my ankles and if I wear them too long in a day they stretch out and my pinky toes escape. I didn’t have high hopes for Rothy’s but was willing to take one for the team.

rothy's flat review and tips on how to style them for weekend - Rothys Flats: an honest unpaid review of rothy's shoes featured by popular Washington DC fashion blogger, Wardrobe Oxygen

Styling Rothys Flats for the weekend with ankle-length jeans and a blazer. Consider pattern mixing – the Red Camo is neutral enough to pair beautifully with other prints like leopard and Breton stripes.  A red lip ties the look together.

Shop the look: blazer | striped top | lipstick | flats | clutch | sunglasses | jeans

Rothys flats come in two styles – round toe and pointed. I am of the mindset that pointed-toe flats look better – more structured, elongate the figure, look cute peeking out of trousers as well as styled with shorter pants. The Point has 20 different colors to choose from. I thought I’d do basic black, but it was out of stock and I was glad because some of their prints and colors are unexpected neutrals that may be more versatile. Liking the camo pattern, I decided to get a pair in Red Camo (red IS the color of the season!). I wear an 8 in everything except sandals, when I go with 7.5 super duper wide. I ordered the Rothys flats in 8.

My Rothys Flats arrived in just a couple days. They came in a sturdy cardboard box that had a self-adhesive strip to make returns easy. The box was the type you can unfold into one piece which makes it easy to recycle or reuse. The packaging inside was simple – one sheet of paper wrapped around the shoes, a small card about the brand, and some stuffing inside the shoes all made from paper and recycleable.

The next day I worked from home but I put on the shoes anyway, Super comfortable. They didn’t slip, they didn’t rub, they didn’t dig, they didn’t feel like it feels when you wear fishnets and you take off your shoes and have a pattern embedded into your skin. But the most walking I did was around the house and to the mailbox, so it wasn’t a good test of these flats.

Rothy's Flats Review: an unpaid full review of Rothy's flats plus tips on how to style the shoes for work - Rothys Flats: an honest unpaid review of rothy's shoes featured by popular Washington DC fashion blogger, Wardrobe Oxygen

Styling Rothys flats for the office: Rothy's The Point look great styled with ankle-length trousers. With neutral tones, the shoes and accessories shine.  Adding a silk scarf elevates the look and helps the flats look more office-appropriate.

Shop the look: sweater | scarf | flats | bag | watch | trousers

Last week I had the perfect opportunity to test Rothy’s flats. I woke at 1:30 am and threw on my Rothy’s and caught a train from DC to NYC. I arrived at 7:30 to grey skies that soon opened up sending sheets of rain on the city. It was the kind of day that will destroy a pair of shoes. My friend and I walked all over Soho, we headed to Brooklyn, we walked miles. We got sopping wet, we ate lunch, we shopped, we got a glass of wine, we walked some more. I stepped in puddles that were grey and had things floating in them. I raced to make lights, I stood for long periods of time, I wore my Rothys flats for over 10 hours straight, giving them a straight-up NYC beating.

rothys flat review by wardrobe oxygen - Rothys Flats: an honest unpaid review of rothy's shoes featured by popular Washington DC fashion blogger, Wardrobe Oxygen

In NYC wearing my Rothys flats

When I finally took my shoes off around 5pm they were wet and soggy and stunk. I took out the removable insoles to help them dry faster. An hour later we were to go back out and I had no desire to wear heels so I put back on the Rothy’s which had dried 99% and wore them for a couple more hours walking around Brooklyn.

Rothy's Flats Review and styling tips on how to wear for weekend, work, and with a dress - Rothys Flats: an honest unpaid review of rothy's shoes featured by popular Washington DC fashion blogger, Wardrobe Oxygen

Styling Rothys flats with a dress: The best silhouettes of skirt or dress with flats is a shift style like above, or a below the knee flowy style in a knit like ponte or a heavier jersey.  A t-shirt dress and denim jacket gets a pop of color with a cheerful shoulder bag; add a bandana at the throat to complete the look.

Shop the look: dress | denim jacket | flats | bandana | sunglasses | bag

No hot spots. No blisters. No sore feet from pounding the pavement (a little bit in the arches due to lack of arch support but no wore than most shoes). The Rothys Flats shifted a bit with wear and there was some pinky toe cleavage happening, but never did I fear my toes would slip out. Since the shoes are essentially made out of elastic, the shoes moved with me and didn’t stretch out when they got wet. After taking them off, they shrunk back to the original shape. If you have stinky feet, these aren’t going to stop that. My feet stunk after the day, and the shoes smelled pretty bad, even the next day. However, I think with such a day and no socks any shoe would have been stinky.

When I got home I took out the insoles and put the insoles and the shoes into the washing machine along with old towels and knock around jeans and knits. Normal amount of detergent, cold water. The shoes came out and looked like new. The red color was still vibrant, the knit still tight, the shape back to the original fit. I hung the shoes from clip hangers to air dry and they were completely dry the next day. What impressed me is that all the funk was gone – no smell. Even when I wore them again and heated them up… no smell.

Rothy's flats review with styling tips on how to wear for work, weekend, date night, and with a dress - Rothys Flats: an honest unpaid review of rothy's shoes featured by popular Washington DC fashion blogger, Wardrobe Oxygen

Styling Rothys flats for a night out: with the pointed toe and fun patterns, Rothy's flats can work for a night out with the girls or dinner with your date.  A pair of dark slim jeans with some stretch and a silky blouse with ruffle detail will look chic with leopard-inspired pointed front flats.  Add gold jewelry and a clutch to glam up the ensemble.

Shop the look: clutch | jeans | blouse | earrings | bracelet | flats

Because Rothy’s are made from a knit, these are not dressy shoes. Depending on the color and shape, you may be able to carry these off in a business casual workplace. I've worn mine with ankle pants and a sweater or dark skinny jeans and a blazer to work. I've shared a few ways to style Rothy's flats for the weekend, work, an evening with friends, and with a skirt.  These are great shoes for the weekend, an upscale alternative to sneakers or flip flops. I know these will be my go-to for travel since they’re so easy to slip on and off, super flexible, great for a flight but also for light sight seeing. These shoes are lightweight and flexible, the kind you can toss in the bottom of your tote to change into after a day in heels.

I paid for my Rothys flats. I've never communicated with the brand and they have no idea I wrote this post. However, all links in this post to Rothy’s are affiliate links and I may make a small commission if you click on the link and make a purchase. With Rothy’s, if you make a purchase you will get your own URL to share with friends that will give the friend $20 off and yourself $20 credit towards at future Rothy’s order. Email me if you'd like a code as the code only works once.  Please note one user's Rothy's code only works 15 times within 30 days so my code may not work at the time you receive it. If you have a Rothys code you may share it in the comments as long as it is provided along with a detailed review to benefit readers (what width are your feet, do you wear insoles, any foot issues, where do you wear these shoes, which style did you get).  I am using all referral code credits I earn to buy Rothy's flats for my readers, so I will try to share my credit as often as I can. Thank you!

If you've tried Rothys flats do share your experience in the comments to help others.  And if you have any questions let me know I'm happy to answer them to help you make an informed purchase if Rothys shoes are for you!

A woman with curly hair wearing a plaid blazer holds a green fur coat over her shoulder on a city street.

Did you like what you just read?

Consider tapping here to buy me a coffee in thanks. The best gift you can give a content creator is the gift of sharing. Consider sharing this article on Facebook or Pinterest. Thank you so much for your support!

Similar Posts

Wednesday

Wednesday

Attire:– Banana Republic: Dark red merino shift dress– Express: Red print silk scarf– Silhouettes: Brown suede slouchy tall boots– Silver cuff and hoops Hair:– Second day, brushed with wood-bristle brush but otherwise left alone Beauty Products:– L’Oreal: True Match foundation in C3– Cargo: Matte BeachBlush in Tenerife– Revlon: ColorStay Sheer lipcolor in Sheer Plum– Body… Continue Reading Wednesday

True Fashionista: Interview with Erin Dyan Johnson

True Fashionista: Interview with Erin Dyan Johnson

Sometimes you meet someone through blogging and wish you lived closer to them. You know that if miles didn’t separate the two of you, you’d be spending a lot of time together – maybe some shopping, maybe some drinking, and probably a lot of laughing. That’s how I feel about Erin from the blog Work… Continue Reading True Fashionista: Interview with Erin Dyan Johnson

Ask Allie: Fashionable Conservative Office Attire
|

Ask Allie: Fashionable Conservative Office Attire

Dear Alison, I love reading your blog because you are a working woman in DC like me but you must work in a very relaxed office. My job is very conservative, the woman all wear skirts to their knees, closed toe shoes, hose, and dark colors. I don’t know how to fit in but still… Continue Reading Ask Allie: Fashionable Conservative Office Attire

My Closet Cleanout Left me Without Clothes!
| |

My Closet Cleanout Left me Without Clothes!

“I’m furloughed. I don’t know when I will go back to work so I can’t take a trip or get into a major project. I’m cleaning out my closet and it’s been enlightening to say the least. My concern is if I get rid of everything I don’t like I won’t have any clothes left!… Continue Reading My Closet Cleanout Left me Without Clothes!

Fashion Undressed: Plagiarism as Design Inspiration?

“It’s been done before.” If you’ve watched any of the ubiquitous fashion design shows, you’ve heard coaches, mentors, and judges critique rising courtiers, telling them that their designs aren’t new. “What goes around, comes around.” Not just life advice, those of us who’ve been around tend to roll our eyes at the cyclical versions of… Continue Reading Fashion Undressed: Plagiarism as Design Inspiration?

1,061 Comments

  1. Everyone (including Rothy’s) says size up 1/2 size for points and loafers, but personally I haven’t found that to be true. I generally take my true size in all the Rothy’s styles. With the flats, I might use heel pads since they end up a little loose. This could be due to the fact my feet are somewhat narrow (but not narrow enough to take N width in general).

    I have black flats, black points, flax birdseye points, dark red loafers, and Poseidon blue points. I love them all, and if I’m going on a vacation, generally the black flats & flax points would cover all the bases. The flats are perfect to wear on a plane. I wasn’t too crazy about the sneakers so I returned them (didn’t like how my heels slipped out – thought that may cause chafing), but if you generally wear socks with them, they might work better.

    If you use a discount code and end up returning the shoes, if you contact customer service, they generally reissue your discount code within a day. So they have nice customer service as well.

    Happy shopping! 🙂

  2. Rothy’s are amazing. I have 3 pairs of the flat and wear them all to death. you can also put in your own insoles (make sure they are fairly thin though) for extra cushion, but I find them to be fairly supportive even without.

    The real godsend though is being able to machine wash them. Walked the dog and stepped in mud (or worse!) – in the washer. Wore them through 100 degree heat for a week straight – in the washer. Wore them on the beach and they got sandy – into the washer. And they continue to look great even after washing. Each of my pairs has gone through at least ten times and they look the same as they did out of the box.

    Sizing I would size up about 1/2 size for wide feet and I had to avoid the point altogether.

  3. I ordered my usual size in flats (size 9) in Big Cat even though I ordered the pointed toe flats since I have a narrow heel. Excited to see how they fit!

  4. Great review! It convinced me to try them and I was able to save $20 so I would like to return the favor!

  5. I am in love with all the new embroidered designs! So pretty. I’ve been wearing my Rothy’s for 6 months and I still love them!

  6. This is a great review. I bought the black round toe at my normal size. I really like them sometimes i feel like perhaps I should have sized up, but they are the most comfortable flats I have ever worn for sure.

  8. I love my Rothy’s! Washable, comfortable, and stylish! If your foot is narrow, try your normal size but if it is average to wide, I would recommend sizing up 1/2 size in flats, points, and loafers as the insoles in the newer flats are thicker which makes them fit about 1/2 size smaller. Of course, Rothy’s offer free exchanges and returns so you owe it to your feet to try them!

  9. Rothy’s have quickly become a favorite work shoe for me (it’s cold and rainy outside so not an everyday shoe til Spring). I size up a half size in the flats and loafers and a full size in the points. I prefer them almost too big because I can always add a thicker insole to help them fit. Can’t do much if they’re too tight.

  10. These shoes are amazing. I get an arch support insole to wear with them and they are the comfiest, most stylish shoes I own. That and machine washable and eco friendly? A no brainer. Totally worth the money!

  11. I have a wider foot, and love my Rothys! I have the point in the leopard print. I ordered a full size up because #1 – Wide foot #2 – it’s a pointed shoe. I always order up a half size in a pointed shoe, and Rothys suggests a half size up if you have wide feet. At any rate, the full size up fits beautifully. My feet don’t look squeezed into the shoe, and they certainly don’t feel constricted. The shoe is fashionable and comfy. The bottom feels similar to a Tom or Tieks, but the remainder of the shoe is MUCH more comfy and soft.I’ve also enjoyed my newer “flat” Rothys. I ordered a 9.5, rather than my usual 9Wide. They are just as comfy, if not a bit more so! The pointed version is more dressy. The flat is more casual. If you want the flat to read more upscale, I suggest a print or pop color. The Heather or lighter colors look more casual.

    1. Hey Heather!
      I used your coupon code…thank you!!
      Awaiting my Rothy’s now. …I have a trip next spring where I’ll be walking a LOT and I wanted a cute, comfortable flat that I could dress up, down, and trek in. …hopeful that these are the ones! 🙂
      Cheers,
      Abby

  13. I have larger feet but I find the flats to be true to size, gonna try sizing up on the points, thanks for the tip!

  14. Fantastic and detailed review!! And thank you so much for letting others share their codes here.

    I LOVE flats but they usually tear up my heel horribly. My first pair of black round toe Rothy’s were the first pair of flats I was able to wear straight out of the box! No blisters, no discomfort. Just cute and comfy and so versatile!

    I can’t wait to get more pairs in fun colors.

  16. I done have Tieks shoes but Rothys are fantastic! they are extremely comfortable and pretty. They are expensive, I saved up for it but the 20usd off helped.

  18. I really do love these shoes. So far my favorite is the flat but I’m also still trying to find my correct size in the point. Some things to note:
    -I normally wear an 8.5/9 in shoes.
    -I wear a 9.5 in both the flat and the loafer
    -I wear a 10 in the points (you have to size up or your toes will be squished). If you feel like you have too much toe cleavage with the point, size up! It sounds counter intuitive but trust me, it works.

    If you’d like to use a code and the one in the blog/article does not work, please consider using mine: http://share.rothys.com/x/DFOHgp

    We’d both get $20 towards our next pair which is pretty dang cool. Happy Rothy’ing!!! Also keep an eye out for some fancy holiday pairs coming out soon, rose gold has been rumored!

  20. Up next, crossing loafers off my list! Flats are beyond comfortable compared to others I have tried over the years. Size up a 1/2 size if your foot seems to be wider than average.

    Enjoy $20 off your first pair with my referral link…
    http://share.rothys.com/x/l6FHxJ

  25. Ordered the 7.5 ballet in leopard and they were too snug on my toes. So I’m trying the 8 in the hot pink because the leopard is sold out. They are super comfy otherwise so fingers crossed this works! Here’s a code for $20 off and free shipping. http://share.rothys.com/x/GU1K7X

  26. Thanks for the reviews. I own some Rothys and really like them. They are washable. That to me is so valuable. They travel well—great slip on airport shoes for security. I only have very bought the round toe, but I really like the look of them. If you are interested, here is a $20 coupon code:
    https://www.talkable.com/x/5WLnza

  27. I ordered the loafer and the point to try out. I initially didn’t trust the hype, but they really are as comfortable as the reviews say they are. I returned the point, however since they were much more pointy than I thought they would be. The loafers are a great look, but I’m a bit hesitant about the price of it, and wonder why it’s so much more than the other styles. Help me earn $20 off so they’re more affordable please! http://share.rothys.com/x/Pp2xFT

  33. Thanks for the review! I went ahead and ordered a pair but I am worried I may have to exchange them for a larger size on account of having bunions which make my feet wider. Either way I hope they work out for me.

  34. These shoes are AMAZING! They seriously elevate any outfit- I can wear the points to work or running around with my toddler. Ethically made, eco-friendly, machine washable- totally worth the investment!

  35. I purchased the point after reading this review then wore them on a week-long vacay to Ireland!! Just bought my third pair! In love!!!

  37. Thank you so much for this post. It did help me decide to take the plunge and I ended up buying a second pair since I loved them so much. I normally wear 6.5-7 and ordered 7 since some recommended sizing up for the points. They fit perfectly. I normally have a problem with getting blisters in any flats but didn’t have any wearing the Rothys all day!
    Here is my referral code: https://www.talkable.com/x/d7FqTj

  41. My co-worker and I are about to leave for a 5-day conference in Vegas and are only bringing Rothy’s! Last year our feet got so sore from all the walking we had to but the ugliest slipper/shoes just to make it through. Not this year! I am crazy about these shoes. I have the round toe and loafers, both are true to size. Here’s a fresh code for $20 off, and shipping is free! https://www.talkable.com/x/yXwNLH

  49. I own 3 pair, all “The Flat” style. These are absolutely my favorite flat. They are the most comfortable shoes I own. I’ve decided to order a pair for my girls who are incredibly picky when it comes to finding comfortable shoes.
    Here’s a link for $20 off: https://www.talkable.com/x/C7EtgU

  51. So in love with my Rothy’s! My black flats are worn so much, due to comfort! I washed the inserts for the first time. Also purchased the sneakers, which I sized up a half size. With the sneakers order, I was able to gift a Pink pair with their October campaign. Can’t wait to order more.

    Save yourself $20 on your first purchase with my referral link https://www.talkable.com/x/w0A36S

  52. I’m so happy with my investment. I am definitely getting a high # of wears for my dollar and the shoes hold up so great. I have no doubt that they’ll be a staple in my wardrobe for years. Have a code the check them out for yourself!

    https://www.talkable.com/x/nQGo3z

  53. Here is a link to save $20 on your first pair:

    https://www.talkable.com/x/gPfbhL

    I have literally stopped wearing any of my other flats since purchasing my Rothy’s! I have high arches and my feet measure as a 8.5C for one and a 9B for the other. I find I prefer a 9 in flats and a 9.5 in both points and the loafers. All three are very comfortable especially if you swap the insole of the point for the slightly thicker insole from the flat/loafer. I find the 1/2 size smaller flat insole fits very well in the point. I hope you love them as much as I do!

  55. So glad to see all the codes are still being updated for everyone. I used thee codes to get my first pair more than a year ago and now I’m back because the latest update convinced me to try to loafers. I’m excited for them to come in! Here’s a fresh code to keep things going:

    https://www.talkable.com/x/tfDcMj

  57. Ok so I love my Rothy’s and am now up to 3 pairs of the flats. But I also have a connective tissue disorder (EDS) and it’s been flaring up bad. With shitty joints I wasn’t sure I could keep wearing flats with little arch support. That’s when I found Pedag Viva insoles (I recommend the high arch ones for people with even low/normal arches) fit perfectly in my Rothy’s (available on amazon and insole websites) !!!! Now I can have my cake and eat it too 🙂

    My usual size is a 10.5 wide so I size up to an 11 in the Rothy’s flats (The points just don’t fit, haven’t tried loafers yet). I have put all three pairs through the ringer. I LOVE that they machine wash beautifully and come out looking like new. I’ve probably washed each pair at least 10 times and they look great.

    My only complaint is the sizing isn’t consistent. I ordered my usual 11 in my last pair and they were too snug so I exchanged for another pair of 11s and they fit perfectly. But since Rothys has AMAZING CUSTOMER SERVICE I had the new pair in a day despite being across the country from their headquarters.

    If you want $20 off your first purchase of Rothys here is my code https://www.talkable.com/x/ReYEgr

    1. Can you please include a link to the Pedag insoles you use with your Rothys? So many to choose from on Amazon! Thanks!

  59. I love mine! Have had them about two months and they still look good as new. I typically wear a 9 and the Rothy’s 9 fits perfectly in the round flats. I also use removable insoles from Amazon with them, which are washable as well and I can swap out every day like socks. Totally worth it! Here is my referral code for anyone who wants to try: https://www.talkable.com/x/14BHQ7

  60. You don’t have to be a Royal to wear these shoes! I love these, these are so stylish and comfortable. If you’re thinking of buying a pair click on the link below and get $20 off your first purchase. You will be pleasantly surprised!
    https://www.talkable.com/x/O1ZxjM

  64. $20 Off Coupon Code:

    https://www.talkable.com/x/TWx9mH

    I’m officially obsessed with these shoes! They’re SO comfortable and they go with everything! (Plus, they’re machine washable and made out of recycled water bottles.) AWESOME! If you’re trying to decide if you should order a pair of these shoes, you definitely should!

  68. I think I am one of the only people to try these and not like them. My toes are wide (bunions) and heels are narrow, not much arch. My usual shoe size is 7 (not wide) or if I find cute wide shoes (Cole Haan) I am either a 6.5 or 7. I went up a half size to 7.5 based on advice online for wide feet and ordered one pair of points, one classic/round toe version, both in that size. I tried both on and they were way too long for my foot. I probably had ½ inch or more of space between my heel and the back of the shoe. Plus, although they are well packaged the quality didn’t meet my expectations for the price. I returned them and will be going back to spending even more ($300 a pair) for AGL flats at Nordstrom (truly the most comfortable and high quality flats I’ve ever owned.)

  73. $20 off new metallics release! https://www.talkable.com/x/wGDeVx (and all styles)

    Which do I get? Midnight Metallic Herringbone flat or Twilight Metallic Cap Toe point? You’re right, both!
    Is it true that you need to size up in the flat and point? I love my loafers so much and don’t want to risk squeezing my toes and

  74. $20 OFF your first pair AND FREE shipping + returns.
    https://www.talkable.com/x/hulLIO

    I now have the flats (dove grey), the loafers (jade), and the sneaker (navy). I love them so much! I know the price tag is shocking but I haven’t regretted a single cent. I haven’t had to size up or down and I have wide-is, flat feet and no blisters! Plus, I washed them just to make sure they hold up to the claims and it worked great. Seriously, no regrets here. Take the plunge. You won’t regret it!
    https://www.talkable.com/x/hulLIO

  76. I definitely needed to size up by a half but otherwise these shoes are amazing. Great for walking around when your feet might swell because they’ll adjust to the changes without added rubbing. For $20 off your first pair, check the link below!

    https://www.talkable.com/x/tfDcMj

  77. WOW! If you like your feet to be comfortable but hate how flats always seem to disintegrate by the end of the season, buy a pair of Rothy’s!

    $20 off your first order + free shipping and returns
    https://www.talkable.com/x/AoMq6p

    I have a pair of flats (dove grey), a pair of loafers (jade), and now a pair of sneakers (navy), and I can’t say enough good things about these shoes!! I have flat, wide-ish feet and I always loved how flats looked on other women but could never find a pair that worked well for me. Rothy’s mold to your feet. I didn’t have a single blister AND YOU CAN WASH THEM! No more smelly flats that you’ve worn all summer and now have to throw away. Rothy’s transition perfectly into the fall and don’t have the lingering grossness of hot, sweaty summer days.

    Take a plunge and buy a pair. I was skeptical but love them so much and have convinced two of my friends to purchase some as well! Happy shopping! https://www.talkable.com/x/AoMq6p

  78. $20 Off Coupon:

    https://www.talkable.com/x/mc4Nbf

    These shoes are awesome! If you’re not sure whether you should break down and buy a pair or not, you definitely should. These shoes are so comfortable, but they’re still cute machine washable, and they go with everything! These shoes are totally worth the money!

  87. Save yourself $20 off your FIRST purchase and save me $20 as well with my referral link…
    https://www.talkable.com/x/isxjyq

    These shoes will not disappoint! Comfortable, easy clean, perfect for every day wear! My wish list for these shoes are a mile long!

  88. $20 off first pair! https://www.talkable.com/x/1GlNYT

    I find my pair to be slightly warm, because they’re not very breathable, which is nice in SF where it can be pretty chilly and usually has me grabbing for shoes that I can wear socks with. And if your feet get hot, well then, throw them in the wash! Win-win.

  90. I am crazy about these shoes! They are totally worth the hype, so comfortable and so stylish. I’ve already turned all the ladies in my office into believers! Here’s a fresh code for $29 off you first pair (and shipping is free!): https://www.talkable.com/x/xuA84t

  92. Sneakers are back in stock and just ordered a Steel Grey pair!

    Also was asked to gift a pink pair to a breast cancer survivor or fighter that I know for Breats Cancer Awareness month! How amazing!

    Save yourself $20 on your first pair, which also saves me $20 on my next pair by using my referral link…
    https://www.talkable.com/x/6SFrhy

  93. Here’s a new link that’ll save $20 off your first pair:

    https://www.talkable.com/x/8LGkw2

    As a true 8 1/2, I find the flats are true to size but I do prefer a size 9 in the points. They are comfortable and the best part, they are machine washable — just make sure to use cold water! I love that I can play with my kids and not worry about ruining my shoes without sacrificing style nor comfort! I just throw them in the wash and they come out looking great!

  95. $20 off coupon: https://www.talkable.com/x/WxpoY0

    Do you have a hard time finding shoes that are comfortable on your feet? I do. It seems like shoes always hurt my feet. But not anymore! These shoes are snug, but not tight. They have thin soles, but they’re squishy and absorb shock. (Which is really important for a hard stepper like me.) They’re comfy, but cute. They’re machine washable, but they still hold their color and shape. In short, these are the best shoes ever!! If you’re trying to decide if you should should buy a pair or not….you definitely should. These shoes are so comfy, you’ll be ordering another pair in no time! 🙂

  96. I was skeptical at first, due to the high price tag but I have learned over the years that investing in a good pair of shoes is much better than dumping a bunch of money on cheaper alternatives that just cause pain. These are so comfortable, easy to pack, easy to wash…I have to force myself to switch up my footwear so I’m not wearing my Rothy’s every single day! I plan outfits around my shoes! I think I just need more!

    Save yourself $20 and get me closer to my next pair! https://www.talkable.com/x/FIvwTn

  100. Love my Rothy’s! And they wash super well — from badly stained to brand new.

    Looking for a $20 off code?
    1. Click this link https://www.talkable.com/x/WrQnlj
    2. Copy the code from the pop up that opens over top of the Rothy’s site.
    3. Paste the code at check-out.

  103. Save us both $20 when you use my referral like on your first pair!
    https://www.talkable.com/x/IgrE2i

    Ordered another pair of flats since when I went to order the Steel Grey sneaker, they were out of my size! Eventually I will get the sneaker as well! Order a half size bigger if your foot is a little wide, to ensure proper comfort!

  105. Sharing the love for $20 off: https://www.talkable.com/x/M9T8kj
    I got my code from this site, so returning the favor. I’m hooked on my new loafers and don’t know which to get next! I like the sneaker but I think I would like it better in a pattern. Hope they come out with some soon!

  110. $20 referral code: https://www.talkable.com/x/3FixzG

    Pro tip: I noticed some “pokiness”/rubbing on one of my heels and if you bring them into a store they have special tools to smooth it down. No more worry about a blister if I wear them all day ‘urban hiking’

  111. $20 Off Coupon Code: https://www.talkable.com/x/96dxZv

    Have you been wondering if you should try a pair of Rothy’s? You should. These will become your favorite pair of shoes! Not only are they super cute, they’re SUPER COMFY too! I have a hard time finding shoes that are comfortable on my feet. These shoes don’t rub or hurt like other shoes do on me. They’re form fitting, but not tight. They’re flexible, machine washable, and come in a slew of great colors that go with everything. If you’re on the fence about placing your first order, just go ahead and do it. You’ll be so glad you did! (I would recommend ordering a 1/2 size up though.)

  114. Just received my first pair today and I’m hooked! I got the loafers in my true size (8.5) and they fit great. At the store they told me to size up a half size with the flats, but the 8.5 was perfect in those as well.

    Use this link to get $20 off your first pair!
    https://www.talkable.com/x/dQzUev

  115. Great review! It’s what sold me on my first pair! Now, if purchasing your first pair, please use my link to save $20:

    https://www.talkable.com/x/37NonF

    I find the flats true to size (average width) but need to size up 1/2 size for the points. They should be comfortable right out of the box!

  122. Since reading this review have I purchased the point and now the slip on sneaker!! Love Love Love!! Heres my code for $20 off your first order.

  125. $20 for me, $20 for you, let’s get comfy in our Rothy’s shoes!
    https://www.talkable.com/x/nKe0Hf

    Tried them on in the store today and the flat and loafer are my favs for the wider toe box. They said to size up a half size with the loafer and point because they run small, but I was my true size in both the flat and loafer. Went with the loafers and can’t wait til they arrive! (Didn’t have the color/size I wanted in the store)

  128. Save yourself $20 on your first purchase and also save me $20 on my next purchase by using my referral link…https://www.talkable.com/x/mFNMLq

    There are so many wonderful choices for flats, loafers, and sneakers. I cannot wait to expand my collection and maybe break away from my normal comfort zone. For my first pair, I ordered the Flax Birdseye flats. Now I just need to decide if I want points or loafers next! If you have a wider foot, I would recommend sizing up a half size.

    Enjoy!

  130. I have the flats…now it’s time to add the newly released sneaker to my collection! I am soo excited!
    I plan to size up a half size in the sneakers, just like the flats…due to a wider foot.
    Save yourself $20 on your FIRST order, it saves me $20 on my next order as well!
    https://www.talkable.com/x/RvZs0V

  132. Such wonderful flats…can’t wait to keep expanding my collection!

    Save yourself $20 on your FIRST pair…which also saves me $20 on my next pair!
    https://www.talkable.com/x/eI8x4w

    I would recommend sizing up a half size if you believe your foot is wider than average. You should NOT have any discomfort with the shoe. If you do, you need to exchange for a different size!

  134. Save yourself $20 on your FIRST pair and earn me $20 as well by using my referral link…
    https://www.talkable.com/x/MlzmLB

    All I have to say is comfortable! And now I cannot wait to snag myself a pair of sneakers! I would recommend sizing up a half size for a wider foot! You will not be disappointed!

  135. I love my rothys!! They are so comfortable and I had no issues breaking them in. I would say they run true to size a bit on the small side, but they mold to your feet well. If you go too big they won’t stay on your feet – at least thr point ones.

    I have a code to share:

    49PX3KW

    https://www.talkable.com/x/WiKJgr

  138. Before I found this website, I was very hesitant to buy a pair of Rothy’s. After I read many reviews, I decided to splurge and buy a pair. Now, I’m obsessed! They are the most comfortable pair of flats I have worn to this day. With having a wider than average foot, I always had issues with where other flats cut into my foot. With Rothy’s, I have no issues. I sized up a half size due to the wider foot and they fit perfectly. If your Rothy’s hurt at all when you get them, send them back and size up a half size!

    Save yourself $20 by using my referral link for your FIRST purchase (it’ll save me $20 as well)!
    https://www.talkable.com/x/SJsVPk

    Enjoy!!

  139. Thanks to the lovely lady who’s like I just used. I’m paying the savings forward – save $20 on your first pair! For rounds, I’m true to my normal 6.5 size. For points/loafers, I size up to a 7. I love having washable flats, and you will too! <3

    https://www.talkable.com/x/M47oeJ

  140. Save us both $20 on your first order, by using my referral link! https://www.talkable.com/x/u3cBWC

    Received my black flats in the mail! Was so excited to get them and try them out. They fit perfectly! I took the advice of sizing up a half size for a wider foot. I was afraid because only one of my feet is wider, but both shoes were perfect!

  145. Just received notification that my Rothy’s were delivered! I cannot wait to get home from work and try them on…hoping they are the perfect fit. I’m not worried though, as I heard nothing but great things about the Customer Service!

    If you’re shopping Rothy’s for the first time…save us both $20 by using my referral link…
    https://www.talkable.com/x/tcpvGy

    Enjoy!!!

  148. FYI I have experienced dye bleeding on all 3 pairs of my rothys flats (even the grey birdseye), but it stopped as soon as I washed them once. So don’t fret if your feet look a little blue 😉 just pop them in the wash and they will be good as new.

    Also – I have experienced some size inconsistencies so if your usual size doesn’t work, try exchanging for another pair in the same size and that might work (it did for me!). Customer service is AMAZING and I got my exchanged pair in the mail before I even shipped out the first pair!

    My coupon code for $20 off: https://www.talkable.com/x/ReYEgr

  152. I’m officially hooked, obsessed, excited…whatever you want to call it for all the Rothy’s making their way to my closet/wardrobe!

    I have stuck with the flat and haven’t branches out yet on the other styles. But I’m just to happy with what I’ve been getting! Make sure to size up if you have a wider than average foot for the most comfort.

    Become as into these shoes as I am…save us both $20 on your first purchase by using my referral link!
    https://www.talkable.com/x/ANgq4d

  153. I love my Rothys! I have 3 pairs (2 points and 1 loafer). I sized up a half size in the points and found the loafers true to size. I love that they hold up ok if you get caught in the rain and that they can go in wash. We can both save $20 on our next pair if you use this link: https://www.talkable.com/x/F4sZnT

  154. Save us both $20 on your first purchase by using my referral link for checkout! https://www.talkable.com/x/zC0SlK

    Just ordered the black regular flats…I will be taking these to a wedding I will be attending for the time that me feet start needing to get out of heels!

    I sized up to a 9.5 as suggested due to having one wider foot. I am hoping this allows more comfort in the shoe when I wear it!

  155. I have a wider foot, and love my Rothys! I have the point in the leopard print. I ordered a full size up because #1 – Wide foot #2 – it’s a pointed shoe. I always order up a half size in a pointed shoe, and Rothys suggests a half size up if you have wide feet. At any rate, the full size up fits beautifully. My feet don’t look squeezed into the shoe, and they certainly don’t feel constricted. The shoe is fashionable and comfy. The bottom feels similar to a Tom or Tieks, but the remainder of the shoe is MUCH more comfy and soft.I’ve also enjoyed my newer “flat” Rothys. I ordered a 9.5, rather than my usual 9Wide. They are just as comfy, if not a bit more so! The pointed version is more dressy. The flat is more casual. If you want the flat to read more upscale, I suggest a print or pop color. The Heather or lighter colors look more casual.If you would like to try a pair for yourself, I offer my $20 discount code to you with hopes that you will be as pleased with them as I am! https://www.talkable.com/x/Edebr4

  156. Let’s both save $20! Use my referral link when ordering your first pair! https://www.talkable.com/x/9y7Nci

    You will not be disappointed. Customer service is also pretty wonderful! I am thinking about coming out of my comfort zone and maybe trying a pointed toe. With my one wide foot, I have always been nervous about that!

  159. Hey Ya’ll. This review, the one by Wardrobe Oxygen was exactly the review I needed to finally decide to purchase. I haven’t worn a different pair of shoes since I got them! I have found some variety amongst sizes by color in the point style. My only qualm with these shoes is that they get wet very easily. Living in the NE that’s not ideal, but they’re so comfy I’ve figured out how to let them dry using the car vents after taking my pup to potty on a dewy morning! This doesn’t stop me from wearing them and it shouldn’t stop you from getting your first pair! You’ll love them!
    https://www.talkable.com/x/5UEjiQ

  160. I love these shoes. I have three pairs. I have a wider foot. I need to size up a half size for the points but the flats fit me in my normal size perfectly. They are flexible and comfortable for a long day at the office. I have washed them in the machine many times and they still look like new. Amazing shoes! Give them a try! If you would like $20 off your first pair here is my code. Use it. You won’t regret it!

    https://www.talkable.com/x/8qJ7wB

  161. So I officially have 3 pairs, all in the flat style (berry colorblock, grey birdseye, and emerald). I have tried to make the points happen, but they just won’t 🙁

    I have a very, very wide foot that is usually around a size 10.5/11. In the flat style I have found the size 11 works best. I did have some issues with my emerald pair which I ordered in my usual size 11 and found to be too small. I decided to exchange them with another pair of size 11s and those worked beautifully. Just to say that if a size doesn’t work for you, try exchanging for another pair. I also have tried fitting some insoles in and none have worked so far 🙁 Definitely need to find a thin insole that is the full length of the shoe in order to fit properly.

    If you would like $20 off your first pair here is my code! https://www.talkable.com/x/ReYEgr

  163. $20 off coupon:

    https://www.talkable.com/x/eXGsMA

    Personally, I have a really hard time finding shoes that are comfortable on my feet. These shoes have become my go-to shoes for just about every occasion. These shoes are pretty true to size, but I would recommend ordering a 1/2 size up…especially if you like to wear the invisible socks. I’ve washed my shoes several times and they have kept their shape, kept their color, and there are no funky smells left behind. If you’re on the fence about ordering your first pair, just break down and do it. Your feet will be so glad you did!! 🙂

  167. Fresh code for $20 off your first pair: https://www.talkable.com/x/bQqyUx

    If you are on the fence, I highly recommend trying them! I have a slightly wide foot (not enough for wide shoes typically) with slight tailor’s bunions (pinky toe side). Because of Rothy’s super soft and flexible knit, these shoes accommodate my feet perfectly! From your normal flats size I’d start with 0.5 up for points and loafers. Round toes are generally true to size.

    Happy shopping 🙂

  171. Here’s a fresh code for $20 off your first pair of Rothy’s -> https://www.talkable.com/x/8wHNhA

    I highly recommend these shoes! I’ve posted here before, but here’s an update. I wear my Rothy’s black point flats every. single. day. and never before have I had a pair of flats that didn’t bite my ankles for at least the first few months of wearing them. I also was about to do laundry the other night and I realized – I can just throw the insoles in the wash as often as I want! I know this isn’t really a big deal, but I’ve never had shoes before that are designed to be machine washable, so it’s a bit of a revelation for me to know that I can have clean shoes all the time. I didn’t clean the outsides because it was really just the insoles that needed to be freshened up. They air dried in no time. I am obsessed with these shoes.

  172. I have a wider foot, and love my Rothys! I have the point in the leopard print. I ordered a full size up because #1 – Wide foot #2 – it’s a pointed shoe. I always order up a half size in a pointed shoe, and Rothys suggests a half size up if you have wide feet. At any rate, the full size up fits beautifully. My feet do not look squeezed into the shoe, and they certainly don’t feel constricted. The shoe is fashionable and comfy. The bottom feels similar to a Tom or Tieks, but the remainder of the shoe is MUCH more comfy and soft.I’ve also enjoyed my newer “flat” Rothys. I ordered a 9.5, rather than my usual 9Wide. They are just as comfy, if not a bit more so! The pointed version is more dressy. The flat is more casual. If you want the flat to read more upscale, I suggest a print or pop color. The Heather or lighter colors look more casual.If you would like to try a pair for yourself, I offer my $20 discount code to you with hopes that you will be as pleased with them as I am! https://www.talkable.com/x/Edebr4

  173. $20 off coupon code:

    https://www.talkable.com/x/iosMmK

    Are you reading reviews trying to decide if you want to buy a pair of Rothy’s? These shoes are an investment in your comfort and will become your go-to shoes for just about any occasion. I have a hard time finding shoes that don’t hurt my feet. These shoes have a great cushiony feel, they conform to your feet, and they still feel good on your feet even after a long day of walking. I’ve washed mine several times and they continue to keep their shape and color. They seem to run a little small and I would recommend ordering a 1/2 size up with any of the different styles. Order yourself a pair and find out what all of the buzz is all about. These shoes are so worth it and you’ll be telling all of your friends how great and comfy these are!

  177. I have always had a hard time finding flats that are comfortable. I have a bit of a bunion on one foot so most flats are too tight and too painful to wear all day. I do not have that problem with my Rothy’s at all! They are stretchy so they form to fit my foot without causing extra pressure and pain. I am a veterinarian so I am on my feet all day. With most other flats I can’t make it through the day without severe pain but I can comfortably wear these all day with no problems. AND I can wash them!!

    They did give me blisters on my heels the first time I wore them, but I just put a bandaid on the back of my heel for the first week to break them in. Now they give me no problems at all.

    I was on the fence for a while about purchasing these because of the price, but I finally caved and it was so worth it. I can’t wait to get a second pair.

    Here is a code for $20 off:
    https://www.talkable.com/x/XKR3iI

  180. Finally tried a pair of Rothy’s based on this and other reviews. Went with the gray points and am very happy overall!! Only regret is that I wish I had read more recommendations about sizing because mine are a bit tight. Of course, I was so excited about them that I wore them straight out the door the morning they arrived so couldn’t return. They are stretching a little and fit a lot better without the insoles. But I will definitely size up in the future. Overall, love these shoes and already trying to justify another pair!

    I used a code off this site, so want to pay it forward to others. If you are considering your first pair, use this code for $20 off: https://www.talkable.com/x/4mvDVJ

    Hope you enjoy them as much as me!

    1. After having to size up on my first pair (flats), I am loving these shoes. I could have made the original size work, but with summer heat (still) I would rather have a little bit of space then have cramped feet. Code below for anyone who wants to try a pair!

      https://www.talkable.com/x/eKLSxT

  181. (Alison, I didn’t know how to edit my comment below, so I add the update here. If it’s too redundant, please delete my original comment!)

    Update:
    After posting the comment below, I tried on my Rothy’s again later that night around 11p. The fit was now more snug, and more like my other (uncomfortable) flats. I was rather worried, so I did some googling and came across the Rothy’s FAQ page that said, “The knit structure is designed to hug the contour of your foot with a slight amount of give. If they are a little snug but not painful, wear them around the house (not outside!) for a day or so to see how they will give. After a day, if your shoes still feel too snug, we recommend going up a half size.” That is great advice, which I did not follow… The next morning I wore them to work, and 10 hours later, if I wasn’t convinced before, I was now totally sold. The shoes stretched (without stretching *out*), and only twice during the entire day did I think “Oh yea, I’m wearing shoes.” (Please bear in mind that I wear microsuede flip flops all day, everyday, so I never have to think about the comfort level of my feet.) I did end up putting Dr. Scholl’s heel cushions under the insoles to lift my heels and prevent the top of the heel cups from digging in. Although the back of my right shoe did still rub my heel a little, there were no hotspots or blisters. I wore them again today, and I didn’t feel any rubbing or digging whatsoever! These are now my go-to shoes for days when flip flops are just too casual, which is 5 out of 7 days, and I still have happy feet 🙂

    If you’d like to try out a pair, the link to a $20 off code (posted below) should be good up to ~9/26.

    ========================

    8/26/18
    Thanks so much for your honest and detailed review – it’s what ultimately convinced me to take the plunge on these rather expensive flats! I had been searching for comfortable flats for years, but failing miserably, had resorted to wearing flip flops (Flojos) almost 24/7.

    For starters, I have a slightly-wider-than-normal size 6.5-7 foot; that is, I wear a 6.5 in heels, and a 7 in flats (and a 7.5 in running shoes). I can fit most standard width shoes, but if there’s a wide option, I usually take it. For my recent order (which I just received), I ordered a size 7.5 in the captoe black round flats, and it’s the perfect size for my feet. There is just a tiny bit of space at the top so that my toes aren’t squished. For reference, I have short, tapered “Egyptian” toes, and a size 7 would have been much too small. I tried them on with and without the insoles (as well as with two insoles stacked) for sizing purposes, and they are most comfortable with just one insole; without any insoles makes the shoes feel like I’m walking almost directly on the ground, although they are roomier, and with two insoles (in one shoe), my feet feel very squished (although they stilll fit). I have also noticed that the base of the heel cup is a bit loose for me – I can push in either side of the air pocket by a few millimeters, but I can’t tell when I’m standing, and the rest of the heel feels pretty secure. The top of the heel cup (lined with royal blue) is a little high, though, and it does dig in if I rock back on my heels. I have yet to street-test them, but so far so good!

    I purchased these on 8/22, and received them on 8/24. Thanks to Laura for my $20 off, and here is a link to a $20 off code for the next person to use (this code is applied near the very end of the purchasing process at the bottom of the page, just before you press the order confirm/submit button):
    https://www.talkable.com/x/KcXjxV

  182. I bought a pair based on the reviews here and I LOVE THEM! I had to send them back for a 1/2 size larger due to the pointy toe so they wouldn’t be too stretched looking and they fit great in the larger size. The return process was so easy. I normally hate pointy flats because they are so uncomfortable but the stretch in the fabric keeps them from rubbing or cutting anywhere. I wear them to work with my slacks several times a week and they look great with business casual. I haven’t washed them yet but I’m excited about the ability to do so because all other flats start to stink eventually and there just isn’t much you can do about it. I’m definitely getting at least one other pair. I want to try the rounded toe style. Thanks to everyone who left a review here for convincing me to make the purchase.

    Here’s my link if you’d like to try a discounted pair too!

    https://www.talkable.com/x/wRB1ZE

  186. Code for $20 discount for new customers: https://www.talkable.com/x/OVqP1E

    I got my first pair of Rothy’s yesterday. They arrived in the mail, and I changed outfits just so I could wear them. I got The Point style in Flax Birdseye. I typically wear between a 6.5 and 7, and I chose size 7 in my Rothy’s. I’m glad I did. They are snug, but comfortable. I have a normal width foot, and I can imagine choosing to size up for a wide foot. Honestly a size 7 1/2 probably would have worked for me too and given me a little more wiggle room.

    I ended up walking about 2.5 miles in the shoes, and I was impressed! I did get some rubbing and irritation on the lateral aspect of my heel (I don’t think this is common…this happens to me frequently with flats.) Otherwise, they are incredibly comfortable. I look forward to wearing them and buying more! I may try their new loafers next!

  188. Thanks so much for your honest and detailed review – it’s what ultimately convinced me to take the plunge on these rather expensive flats! I had been searching for comfortable flats for years, but failing miserably, had resorted to wearing flip flops (Flojos) almost 24/7.

    For starters, I have a slightly-wider-than-normal size 6.5-7 foot; that is, I wear a 6.5 in heels, and a 7 in flats (and a 7.5 in running shoes). I can fit most standard width shoes, but if there’s a wide option, I usually take it. For my recent order (which I just received), I ordered a size 7.5 in the captoe black round flats, and it’s the perfect size for my feet. There is just a tiny bit of space at the top so that my toes aren’t squished. For reference, I have short, tapered “Egyptian” toes, and a size 7 would have been much too small. I tried them on with and without the insoles (as well as with two insoles stacked) for sizing purposes, and they are most comfortable with just one insole; without any insoles makes the shoes feel like I’m walking almost directly on the ground, although they are roomier, and with two insoles (in one shoe), my feet feel very squished (although they stilll fit). I have also noticed that the base of the heel cup is a bit loose for me – I can push in either side of the air pocket by a few millimeters, but I can’t tell when I’m standing, and the rest of the heel feels pretty secure. The top of the heel cup (lined with royal blue) is a little high, though, and it does dig in if I rock back on my heels. I have yet to street-test them, but so far so good!

    I purchased these on 8/22, and received them on 8/24. Thanks to Laura for my $20 off, and here is a link to a $20 off code for the next person to use (this code is applied near the very end of the purchasing process at the bottom of the page, just before you press the order confirm/submit button):
    https://www.talkable.com/x/KcXjxV

  189. Brand new referral code: https://www.talkable.com/x/dLQxVk

    Just bought my second pair (black flats)! I was worried that the black might not look formal enough for work, but after trying it on I don’t think it looks too casual at all! If anyone is a half-size, I recommend you size up. It really makes a difference for my wide feet.

  190. I have a wider foot, and love my Rothys! I have the point in the leopard print. I ordered a full size up because #1 – Wide foot #2 – it’s a pointed shoe. I always order up a half size in a pointed shoe, and Rothys suggests a half size up if you have wide feet. At any rate, the full size up fits beautifully. My feet don’t look squeezed into the shoe, and they certainly don’t feel constricted. The shoe is fashionable and comfy. The bottom feels similar to a Tom or Tieks, but the remainder of the shoe is MUCH more comfy and soft.I’ve also enjoyed my newer “flat” Rothys. I ordered a 9.5, rather than my usual 9Wide. They are just as comfy, if not a bit more so! The pointed version is more dressy. The flat is more casual. If you want the flat to read more upscale, I suggest a print or pop color. The Heather or lighter colors look more casual.If you would like to try a pair for yourself, I offer my $20 discount code to you with hopes that you will be as pleased with them as I am! https://www.talkable.com/x/Edebr4

  192. Brand new referral code: https://www.talkable.com/x/dLQxVk

    Just bought my second pair (mink color)! If anyone is a half-size, I recommend you size up. I found that it makes a difference for those of us with wide feet. My only nit-picky complaint is that the shoes could offer a bit more structure–I’m tempted to try the loafers at some point to see if they’re a little more reinforced. I love these flats though. It’s really hot where I live and my feet usually feel really sweaty in other flats, but I have zero issues with these!

  193. I used this review to help me purchase my first pair and then fell in love. I have three pairs now! I will say that if you have wide feet, size up! I wear a size 10 normally, and I have to get a half size up at least. As long as you size up, they will fit wonderfully and are super comfy. The shoes do was well, but if they are a lighter color (like lemon drop) they do stain easily and the stains don’t always come out.

    Here is the code to get 20 off your order! https://www.talkable.com/x/O4vD7B

  194. These flats are a great addition to my wardrobe. I have points and loafers. I found that going an entire size up was the most comfortable for me. It also helps the look of the shoe on my feet. At a smaller size, I was able to see the outline of my toes in the loafer.

    I love how versatile these shoes are! Would recommend to anyone looking for a cute flat. Here’s a code for $20 off, if you’re buying: https://www.talkable.com/x/li9xje

  197. I bought the Rothy’s Point flats and absolutely agree about getting a half size up. I’m a 7.5 in everything with narrow feet but I just received the size 8 and they fit really well, and are not too long. I love the fabric so much I just ordered my second pair! Trying the round toe flats next. Here’s my code for $20 off your first pair: https://www.talkable.com/x/VLZavT

  198. Just a quick note that customer service is really spectacular. These shipped so quickly and if you’re at all concerned about sizing I ordered the wrong size initially, was able to start my return and the replacement in different size arrived before I even had a chance to send off the first pair. This meant I was able to do a quick side by side comparison of which size I liked better before mailing back the pair I wanted to return. So fast and easy! I probably had the size I needed within 4 or 5 days.

    Hope this helps! Here’s my $20 discount code: https://www.talkable.com/x/wYaRkN

  204. These are basically the only flats I wear now… I ride my bike to work, and I love that I can just throw them in the wash and have them come out looking BRAND NEW!!! No more commuter dust, yayyyy! Seriously, being able to wash my flats? Total game changer. I’m so tired of smelly flats!

    Sizing info! I typically wear a 6.5 or 7 in shoes. I wear a 6.5 in the flat/rounds and a 7 in both the points and the loafer. If you like lots of wiggy room for your toes, you can even size up an extra 0.5 size. For example, my “extra wiggle room size” is 7 in rounds, and 7.5 in points… the loafer I keep at a 7, because they already have lots of wiggle room due to the nature of it being a loafer.

    Happy shopping! Please feel free to use my code for $20 for us both if this comment was helpful. https://www.talkable.com/x/uALbUy

  205. $20 off plus Free Shipping and Free Returns!
    https://www.talkable.com/x/YQFKvt

    So, I purchased my first pair of Rothy’s in May, so I think it’s been enough time for me to be honest. I’ve put these shoes through the ringer! I bought a pair of flats in Dove Grey 8.5. I have flat, wideish feet and I have always had an issue wearing flats, they never fit right, they hurt in random places, or I got blisters on my heels. Not so with Rothy’s. Right out of the box they were amazing. I’ve worn them when I was caught in an unexpected rain storm and they held up no problem. I’ve washed them a few times and still, they’re amazing.

    I know many of you reading this are concerned about the price tag of the shoes and I’d say they are worth every penny. I’ve purchased 2 other pairs and I couldn’t be happier. If you’re scared about the price, take the plunge and enjoy the $20 off. If you really don’t like them, you can return them no questions asked, but I really don’t think you’ll need to return them.

    https://www.talkable.com/x/YQFKvt

    Happy Shopping!

  210. I have severa pairs of Rothys and just bought the jelly bean green ones from their fall collection. So cute and fun I color. So comfy that I wear them all day. Would recommend going up a 1/2 size as I think they run small. I’ve taken them on business trips and they pack well. Here is a $20 coupon code for those who want to try them out:

    https://www.talkable.com/x/PcbVG5

  211. Brand new referral code! https://www.talkable.com/x/7VYcyl

    Purchased a 9 and they fit great (emerald flats)! I agree with other commenters about sizing up, though! I’ve got really wide feet and can usually wear an 8.5, but I needed the 9. Have walked a mile to work in mine for several days now with no problems

  215. Brand new referral code! https://www.talkable.com/x/7VYcyl

    I just got in my second pair and these shoes are great. I agree with other commenters about sizing up, though! I’ve got really wide feet and can usually wear an 8.5, but for Rothy’s a 9 was the way to go. I’ve only tried the flats, pointed toes rarely fit me. I’ve seen mine commenters day they blister, but I walk a mile to work each morning in mine with no problems!

  217. I have been on the fence for so long! After seeing the reviews and seeing that there was a $20 off referral code I had to give it a shot, so I am paying it forward! Thank you the random person I selected in these comments for $20, I hope you enjoy your $20!

    https://www.talkable.com/x/BwCPnl

  218. My thoughtful review… – I have a wider foot, & love my Rothys! I have the point in the leopard print. I ordered a full size up because #1 – Wide foot #2 – it’s a pointed shoe. I always order up a half size in a pointed shoe, and Rothys suggests a half size up if you have wide feet. At any rate, the full size up fits beautifully. My feet don’t look squeezed into the shoe, and they certainly don’t feel constricted. The shoe is fashionable and comfy. The bottom feels similar to a Tom or Tieks, but the remainder of the shoe is MUCH more comfy and soft.I’ve also enjoyed my newer “flat” Rothys. I ordered a 9.5, rather than my usual 9 Wide. They are just as comfy, if not a bit more so! The pointed version is more dressy. The flat is more casual. If you want the flat to read more upscale, I suggest a print or pop color. The Heather or lighter colors look more casual.If you would like to try a pair for yourself, I offer my $20 discount code to you with hopes that you will be as pleased with them as I am! https://www.talkable.com/x/1yar3S

  219. I have a wider foot, & love my Rothys! I have the point in the leopard print. I ordered a full size up because #1 – Wide foot #2 – it’s a pointed shoe. I always order up a half size in a pointed shoe, and Rothys suggests a half size up if you have wide feet. At any rate, the full size up fits beautifully. My feet don’t look squeezed into the shoe, and they certainly don’t feel constricted. The shoe is fashionable and comfy. The bottom feels similar to a Tom or Tieks, but the remainder of the shoe is MUCH more comfy and soft.I’ve also enjoyed my newer “flat” Rothys. I ordered a 9.5, rather than my usual 9Wide. They are just as comfy, if not a bit more so! The pointed version is more dressy. The flat is more casual. If you want the flat to read more upscale, I suggest a print or pop color. The Heather or lighter colors look more casual.If you would like to try a pair for yourself, I offer my $20 discount code to you with hopes that you will be as pleased with them as I am! https://www.talkable.com/x/1yar3S

  226. I’ve worn both the ballet and pointed toe styles. Definitely order a half size up for both! The pointed toes still feel somewhat cramped but maybe that’s the nature of the beast. The ballets do feel roomy. I may get some insoles. If this was helpful, here’s a code for $20 off your 1st order: https://www.talkable.com/x/2p8w9z

  228. Here’s my referral code for anyone looking (Thank you!), followed by advice! https://www.talkable.com/x/MbQlky
    Hi! So I’ve tried the points, flats, and loafers, and the loafers are my favorite. I could not get the fit right with the points; I sized up a half, then a full size, and they were still tight on me. The flats fit well at my usual size, but I ultimately don’t think they’re THAT different than other (less expensive) flats out there (also I got terrible blisters on my ankles when I first wore them). The loafers, however, were comfortable and cute from day one. Especially the patterned ones!

  229. Brand new $20 referral code: https://www.talkable.com/x/7VYcyl

    Just ordered my second pair! These shoes are great. One of the shoes pinched just a smidge, but not enough for me to send it back. I have very wide feet so this is not unusual. I’m ordering a slight bigger size (9) this time.

  231. Thank you all for your reviews and codes!!

    I don’t have much to say yet except that I LOVE how the rothy’s look on and they feel super comfy 6 hours right out the box but I hope to have more to say very soon and in meantime, here’s another code to pay forward my $20 off discount!

    https://www.talkable.com/x/QerF62

  234. $20 off coupon code:
    https://www.talkable.com/x/y0tEmB

    If you’ve been on here reading reviews to decide whether or not to buy your first pair, you definitely should. These shoes are worth it. I always have a hard time finding shoes that are comfortable on my feet AND that don’t look or feel like “old lady shoes.” These shoes look great and feel great too! I would definitely order a 1/2 size up from your normal size, especially if you’re going to wear the no show type socks. I now have both the round for and point style of flats and I feel like the 1/2 size rule would apply to them both. I hope this review helps someone out there decide to try a pair. Everyone should be this comfy in their shoes!

  237. Brand new $20 referral code: https://www.talkable.com/x/7VYcyl

    I just bought my second pair! I loved the first pair(got the shale flats in a size 8.5). The only downside was that the right shoe bothered my big toe a little bit. Turns out I had a bad ingrown toenail, so I don’t blame the shoe for aggravating it. I am going to try to order one size up though, just to see if that gives my feet a little more room to prevent future toe issues.

  238. My Rothy’s have become my go to shoe. The sizing varies. It only by point be flat, but also among colors. These shoes also get wet quickly — for example just walking through dewy grass. They dry quickly though hasn’t been too much of an issue. Here’s $20 off your first pair!

    https://www.talkable.com/x/Qwrqas

  239. NEW CODE: https://www.talkable.com/x/9sDe0b (please use my code and we each get $20 off! Thank you!)

    I’m on my 4th pair of Rothy’s. I have a marigold pair of points, a heather pair of loafers and 2 pairs of flats (navy and my newest flax). After wearing them all for months now, I have came to the conclusion that as someone with wide feet that my favorite and most comfortable style is the round toe flat. Where I absolutely love the look of my points, and I did size up a 1/2 size, they still are not the most comfortable shoes after hours on my feet walking. Now they ARE more comfortable than any other flats I have, but still not nearly as comfortable as my round toe flats. And I think the round toe, although a bit less dressy looking, can still pair just fine with skirts and dresses. Especially the darker colors. I find my Rothy’s are my go to shoes now, even before sneakers because they elevate an outfit to a more put together look, even when wearing jeans. https://www.talkable.com/x/9sDe0b

  249. https://www.talkable.com/x/6fuz07

    Click above for $20 off!

    Just ordered my first pair of Rothy’s in animal print, size 6.5. I almost always buy shoes that are only leather(uppers), because of the stretch factor….my feet are a little on the wide side. I love the animal print! Looking forward to trying these out!

    1. Have you tried the flats? I would like to try them but not sure of the size and I will be in the US only for a few days, so I’d like to get the size right 😛

      I also sized up a half size on my loafers ;), my own number seemed to fit ok, but it was slightly tight on the sides and I am happy I changed for a slightly larger size since I’ve been wearing them to walk all day long under the sun!!

      Here’s my code for $20 off if you wanna try them too https://www.talkable.com/x/O8IkUT

  253. I got my first pair of Rothy’s (loafers) just over a month ago and have worn them nearly every day! They are so comfy and I have wide feet with a narrow heel and have had no issues with my heal slipping. I usually wear a 9.5 so I sized up to a 10 and they fit perfectly. In fact, I just ordered two more pairs– another pair of loafers and a pair of the point which I can’t wait to try. I just washed them for the first time and they came out beautifully. I’ve been a Tieks fan for years, but this last month has made me a true Rothy’s convert.

    I used a discount from this site for my first pair, so paying it forward, here’s a code for $20 off: https://www.talkable.com/x/fboVU3

  255. Every time you wash these shoes it’s like you’re putting on a brand new shoe. I find that if you have a little extra space in your shoe, you can slide around just a bit. It isn’t anything that would dissuade me from not buying again. I’ve worn leopard points every day since May! I need a new pair! https://www.talkable.com/x/hB9VPx

  257. Rothy’s are the best travel shoes because they are light, washable, comfortable, work appropriate, and take up very little space in a carry-on bag. My Rothy’s flats were the only two pairs of shoes that I took with me for 3-week work trip in Europe this summer, and they are still look brand new after having walked at least 10,000 steps per day, mostly on cobblestoned streets. Here is a new code for $20 off your first pair of Rothy’s: https://www.talkable.com/x/mt7FI8

  258. I have to say these were a definite splurge for me but also so worth it! I’ve realized more in recent years the importance of high quality items especially for those that I use regularly. I got them in the black point and plan to get at least one other color as I wear these most days to my office. You will not be disappointed with this purchase.

    If you’d like to get yourself a pair and need a little help with the cost use this link to save $20: https://www.talkable.com/x/EL1vl7

  260. I got my Rothy’s in the mail yesterday. the 1/2 size up for the point was definitely the right choice, but for me, I think I also need it for the regular flat. I have a collapsing arch, so my foot tends to be on the wider size when standing. If you have this issue or just wide feet, I would recommend going for your larger size.

    Enjoy ! https://www.talkable.com/x/WHynfG

  262. I’ve been using my Rothy’s in my trip Rome (with temperatures reaching the 90’s during the day — ~35C) and they’ve been incredibly comfortable: my feet get swollen after some hours of walking and pretty much every other shoe seems a little unbearable to wear, but my rothy’s adjust to my feet all day long and they look stylish with basically anything I wear — which turns out to be important in Rome, even the lonely planet guide says so!

    Here’s my code for $20 off if you wanna try them too!
    https://www.talkable.com/x/O8IkUT

  263. $20 off coupon:

    https://www.talkable.com/x/6yEDfv

    I have such a hard time finding shoes that are comfortable on my feet and I am thrilled to have found Rothy’s! These shoes are super comfy, they come in so many colors that go with everything, and they’re machine washable! I’ve washed mine a few times now, and they’ve kept their shape, color, and still smell nice and fresh. If you’ve been on the fence about ordering a pair, don’t wait any longer. Your feet will thank you! 🙂

    1. Love washing my Rothy’s! I’m not afraid to buy light colored shoes anymore, because if I get dust or dirt on them from commuting I can just run them through a wash cycle! I use a laundromat, and I’ve been fine washing my shoes and insoles on cold in a garment bag.

      https://www.talkable.com/x/YxDE7t Here’s $20 off for us both if you want shoes you can wash too!

      1. Totally agree!! I used to have only black and navy shoes, but now I got a pair of Flax Birdseye and just wash them every time they get dirty or wet from the rain and they look perfect!!

        Here’s my code for $20 off: https://www.talkable.com/x/O8IkUT

  265. I ordered my second pair just a few weeks after my first. I love them! I do recommend sizing 1/2 a size up for the pointed toe shoe (I can’t attest to the rounded toe). My first pair was the flax color and the second navy. I love the flax!! Here is another referral code for $20 off:
    https://www.talkable.com/x/lqjVZb

  266. Rothy’s have become my go to shoes for work and travel. I can’t believe how much better I feel since giving up heels. Not just my feet, but everything. With the points I feel stylish and cute, but comfortable at the same time. Here is a new code for 20 dollars off your first pair:

    https://www.talkable.com/x/TFXnp6

  268. This review persuaded me to make my first purchase of Rothy’s back in April and I haven’t taken these shoes off my feet since. They’re seriously better than sliced bread in my books. I ordered up a size in the points and I have a little room to slide around a bit in the shoe. Also one other thing to note. I might just have curly toes, but sometimes the insole gets under my toes and annoys me, this is a rare but something to be aware of! If you decide to buy, I’d love for you to use my referral code so I can get a 2nd pair! https://www.talkable.com/x/W1fAdF

  269. Just ordered a pair for my daughter…yup, that’s right–they make little girl Rothys. Excited for her to have these. I love mine–easy to put on and take off, washable, made from recycled materials. All win win win.

    If you need a $20 referral, here is one:

    https://www.talkable.com/x/DxXf1i

  270. Just ordered a pair of the flat and the point. Got an 8 (my usual size for most shoes) for the flat and did a 1/2 size up for the point, as per recommendations in this post. I’ll let you know how it goes!!

    Enjoy ! https://www.talkable.com/x/WHynfG

  271. Use this link for a discount! https://www.talkable.com/x/YxDE7t

    I feel like I buy new flats every six months because they get super smelly. LOVE that you can wash these. I’m a convert, slowly getting rid of all my other flats!

    Love that they are out with girl’s sizes too. <3

  275. I recently got my first pair of Rothy’s and I’m in love.. Stretchy, comfy, and washable. Sign me up.
    I have a fairly narrow foot, but noticed that these were still a LOT more narrow than other pointy toed flats that I own. (once they came in I measured them, and they were almost 1cm narrower than my other fave pointy toe flats)… So I’m glad I went up 1/2 size because I fear the smaller ones would have been too tight! I purchased the leopard print and am totally in love with them. Can’t see the toe shape through the stretchy material (if that bugs you) because of the pattern, and they match virtually everything.
    10/10 will buy more and definitely recommend.

    This code is good for $20 off your first order.

    https://www.talkable.com/x/A38cgq

    AND they have a teaser out on social media that tomorrow they will be dropping Rothy’s for little girls. SO CUTE!

  277. 5 STARS! Love my Rothys. I have 4 pairs and just ordered my 5th pair. I order the round toe and have always ordered a 1/2 size up as they run a tad small. I have never ordered the pointy toe ones but have heard from friends that you should go up a 1/2 to full size on those. I have washed mine several times, and they look great. I take the insoles out and throw both the shoes and insoles in with my darks. Air dry afterwards. If you need a code for $20 off, here is mine:

    https://www.talkable.com/x/DxXf1i

  278. Quick updated review:
    I brought my flats with me on a beach vacation and found that they are actually FANTASTIC to wear on the sand. It’s basically like being barefoot but with the protection of the rubber sole. Also I didn’t care if they got wet because they already go in the wash. Sand just wipes of but I threw them in the wash just to get them super clean. I actually preferred wearing them on the beach to flip flops. We also have had a number of thunderstorms and I have opted for rothys those days because they are waterproof. They continue to be my most comfortable shoe and I think I may need to try ordering the point again in a full size up (11.5 – never even seen that size before btw AMAZING) (already have 2 pairs of the round toe flats). Also have washed my first pair about five times and they continue to look perfect.

    HIGHLY RECOMMEND!

    If you need a code for your first purchase, here’s mine: https://www.talkable.com/x/76HCul

  279. I have a wider foot, and adore my Rothys! I have the point in the leopard print. I ordered a full size up because #1 – Wide foot #2 – it’s a pointed shoe. I always order up a half size in a pointed shoe, and Rothys suggests a half size up if you have wide feet. At any rate, the full size up fits beautifully. My feet do not look squeezed into the shoe, and they certainly don’t feel constricted. The shoe is fashionable and comfy. The bottom feels similar to a Tom or Tieks, but the remainder of the shoe is MUCH more comfy and soft. I’ve also enjoyed my newer “flat” Rothys. I ordered a 9.5, rather than my usual 9Wide. They are just as comfy, if not a bit more so! The pointed version is more dressy. The flat is more casual. If you want the flat to read more upscale, I suggest a print or pop color. The Heather or lighter colors look more casual.If you would like to try a pair for yourself, I offer my $20 discount code to you with hopes that you will be as pleased with them as I am! https://www.talkable.com/x/1yar3S

  283. Hi all! These reviews were SO helpful. I have been going back and forth about whether or not to order, because of the price. I am sold after looking through these comments. Typically wear a 5.5 and have somewhat wide feet. Ordered a 5.5 and will add comment about fit after they arrive. Feel free to use my code for $20 off. https://www.talkable.com/x/7y3jtQ

  285. Thank you, everyone, for the reviews. They were extremely helpful. I ordered my first pair! Here’s my code: https://www.talkable.com/x/avJC9o
    I am an educator and on my feet a lot. I have an arsenal of flats that I’ve purchased in an effort to try to find something cute and comfy. My feet are average but I have narrow heels; so, flats tend to flop or pinch and leave blisters. I am so hoping these shoes are the answer to my prayers.

  287. I bought a pair of Flax Birdseye flats! I am very comfortable with the shoes, but I must say I thought the color was slightly closer to beige. Instead, it is really pale gray (here’s my code if you wanna try them too! https://www.talkable.com/x/dB75pi).

    In pictures, it seems to go very well with beige/white colors, so I hope that’s the case! For now, I am enjoying the comfort and the beautiful shape of the shoes!

    Note: I ordered half a size up since I have wide feet (thanks for the advice!) but, as it turns out, in the flats model, half a size up makes it feel loose. I do see how with the loafers, you’d want to size up a bit: the fabric kind of wraps up around your feet :).

    I’ll be reporting back on the look of this color with beiges/whites! (https://www.talkable.com/x/dB75pi)

  288. Thanks for the honest review. I’m always looking for a comfortable shoe for wide feet. My foot is short, wide and swells, so sometimes I feel like shoe boxes would fit me better than the shoes! I normally order a 5 or 5.5 wide, so I ordered a 5.5.

    Here is a new code for $20 off your first pair.

    https://www.talkable.com/x/FQYjis

  291. I adore my Rothys too! Washable is the best. I have the point and I first received an 8 but even though my foot was narrow I decided to exchange for an 8.5 without any hassles. Super easy process. Via their website. Took about 30 seconds to finalize the exchange. And here’s a link for $20 off: https://www.talkable.com/x/e62WEK

  295. I have a wider foot, and adore my Rothys! I have the point in the leopard print. I ordered a full size up because #1 – Wide foot #2 – it’s a pointed shoe. I always order up a half size in a pointed shoe, and Rothys suggests a half size up if you have wide feet. At any rate, the full size up fits beautifully. My feet don’t look squeezed into the shoe, and they certainly don’t feel constricted. The shoe is fashionable and comfy. The bottom feels similar to a Tom or Tieks, but the remainder of the shoe is MUCH more comfy and soft. I’ve also enjoyed my newer “flat” Rothys. I ordered a 9.5, rather than my usual 9Wide. They are just as comfy, if not a bit more so! The pointed version is more dressy. The flat is more casual. If you want the flat to read more upscale, I suggest a print or pop color. The Heather or lighter colors look more casual.If you would like to try a pair for yourself, I offer my $20 discount code to you with hopes that you will be as pleased with them as I am! https://www.talkable.com/x/1yar3S

  298. I have 4 pairs so far—dove grey with orange sole, black captoe, pink and blue stripe, and black and grey stripe. My favorite flat. Can be worn with dresses, pants, or jeans. Dressed up or down. Great for travel. Wash up really easily in the washer and hold up well afterwards. Lack some arch support but that’s probably the only con to this shoe. Went up a half size in the round toe and glad I did because I think they run a tad small.

    Here’s my referral code for those who need it:

    https://www.talkable.com/x/DxXf1i

  300. So first, I thank you Allie for the the detailed review and very helpful information about these shoes! They cost a small fortune, so I did a ton of research before asking for them as a mother’s day gift in May. I asked for the cobalt blue pair, and despite being knit, the color and style means that I have worn them to the bouncy house place on a Saturday with my daughter, but also with a nice skirt and blouse during the work week. I loved the blue so much, that I asked for the marigold color for an anniversary gift, and these pairs have carried me through so many Spring and Summer hours of walking here in NYC in comfort and style. I really hope they keep the fun summer colors (purple, hot pink, turquoise, ahhhh!) in stock through August since I hope to ask the family to all chip in for a fun bright color as my birthday gift! Then I plan to chuck all my other tight, uncomfortable old pairs of ballet flats right in the donation bin at church!

    I told a friend that Rothys feel almost like slippers because the stretch to the fabric does not rub like the leather pairs I have had. No breaking them in at all! If another lady out there would like to try them, feel free to use my code friends!

    https://www.talkable.com/x/7u0eHv

    1. Sorry, forgot to say that I usually wear a size 10 in shoes. I have very flat arches that provide no support, so I sometimes have to wear orthotic inserts. Because I figured the pointed toe Rothys would have smaller toe space, and in case I wanted to put in my arch supports at some point, I went with a size 10.5 and that was the right thing to do! I have not tried to put in my orthotics yet since they are pretty comfortable, but going up a half size was the right thing to do.

  302. I have a wider foot, and love my Rothys! I have the point in the leopard print. I ordered a full size up because #1 – Wide foot #2 – it’s a pointed shoe. I always order up a half size in a pointed shoe, and Rothys suggests a half size up if you have wide feet. At any rate, the full size up fits beautifully. My feet don’t look squeezed into the shoe, and they certainly don’t feel constricted. The shoe is fashionable and comfy. The bottom feels similar to a Tom or Tieks, but the remainder of the shoe is MUCH more comfy and soft.I’ve also enjoyed my newer “flat” Rothys. I ordered a 9.5, rather than my usual 9Wide. They are just as comfy, if not a bit more so! The pointed version is more dressy. The flat is more casual. If you want the flat to read more upscale, I suggest a print or pop color. The Heather or lighter colors look more casual.If you would like to try a pair for yourself, I offer my $20 discount code to you with hopes that you will be as pleased with them as I am! https://www.talkable.com/x/1yar3S

  305. I got the same red camo pointed pair. I usually wear 7.5 and that’s the size I ordered. They arrived the very next day, even though I went with the free shipping option. When I tried them on, I could feel the whole shoe expanding and enveloping my feet. The color is vibrant but not gaudy. The pointed toe does give the shoe an added dressy feel. I have neuromas in my toes, but these did not cause them to act up. I love that they are made of recycled water bottles and can be machine washed. I will probably get a rounded toe in black, for that classic ballet flat look. Here’s a link for $20 off of your pair! https://www.talkable.com/x/r9oHxd

  307. So I got my rothy’s and wanted to test them right off the box for a full day to see whether they were really blister-free – I have very sensitive feet, – and they were great!! no discomfort anywhere
    I am excited to make these shoes my everyday-shoes since they are 100% washable!!

    Here’s my link if you wanna try them too!! https://www.talkable.com/x/O8IkUT

    2. I’m on the fence- I can’t decide between Rothy’s and Tieks. Which would you recommend? My feet run a bit narrow.

  311. Code for $20 off your first pair: https://www.talkable.com/x/UlvOik

    If you are on the fence, I highly recommend trying them!

    I absolutely love my Rothy’s and they have replaced all but one pair of heels! The points work for me as both a dressy shoe and to elevate more casual looks (my work is on the casual end of business casual). Loafers are super comfortable for casual outfits!

    Re: sizing – round toe tend to run true to size, but size up 1/2 – full size in points and loafers. Some colors run smaller than others.

  312. I have a wider foot, and love my Rothys! I have the point in the leopard print. I ordered a full size up because #1 – Wide foot #2 – it’s a pointed shoe. I always order up a half size in a pointed shoe, and Rothys suggests a half size up if you have wide feet. At any rate, the full size up fits beautifully. My feet don’t look squeezed into the shoe, and they certainly don’t feel constricted. The shoe is fashionable and comfy. The bottom feels similar to a Tom or Tieks, but the remainder of the shoe is MUCH more comfy and soft.I’ve also enjoyed my newer “flat” Rothys. I ordered a 9.5, rather than my usual 9Wide. They are just as comfy, if not a bit more so! The pointed version is more dressy. The flat is more casual. If you want the flat to read more upscale, I suggest a print or pop color. The Heather or lighter colors look more casual.If you would like to try a pair for yourself, I offer my $20 discount code to you with hopes that you will be as pleased with them as I am! https://www.talkable.com/x/1yar3S

  313. I love these shoes. They look great and have no break-in time at all. The only issue I have is that the retire styles too quickly. Violet just came out and I think I missed out. 🙁 New $20 code for your first pair: https://www.talkable.com/x/p91bIK

  319. Just put in an order for a second pair!

    I posted a review before, but wanted to update since I exchanged for a different style.

    I have VERY wide feet (10.5 E width) and hyperhydrosis (i.e. super sweaty feet….ewww). The first pair I ordered were the points and while I loved the color (leopard print), they just weren’t quite wide enough for me. So I exchanged them for a pair of the flats. I ordered in both 10.5 and 11 and while I could have made the 10.5s work the 11s fit much better especially width wise.

    I have worn them a bunch and they are super comfy for the most part. My biggest issue is that the insole is a little narrower than the outsole so I need to buy some inserts that will support my whole fit a bit better. But even without changing out the insoles they are still comfortable enough to wear around most of the day. I do feel like my foot sweats a bit more than usual when I wear these, but because you can wash them it’s nbd.

    The other thing I wanted people to be aware of – If you have sweaty feet like me….the color may bleed onto your foot! I bought the Berry Colorblock (looks like it’s not available anymore) which is mostly red and magenta. The bleeding issue might be mostly due to that color combo and the fact that I haven’t washed them yet. Will try to report back after washing.

    Next pair is the grey birdseye and I can’t wait until they arrive!

    My referral code if you would like $20 off – https://www.talkable.com/x/76HCul

    1. Just adding on to my previous review.

      I have washed the berry colorblock pair twice now and they still look/feel amazing. Also the issue of the dye bleeding on to the skin appears to have stopped after washing.

  320. Just ordered my third pair! I absolutely love them for work, and especially love that I can wash them. I sized up a half size in the Point and they fit great. I haven’t noticed any size different in the two colors that I have, and I’m hoping the new teal ones I just ordered fit the same.

    Here’s another $20 off code: https://www.talkable.com/x/pas5gi

  324. This review helped me decide to buy. Thanks for posting. I haven’t taken them off since I bought them! These are the most comfortable shoes I’ve worn in a very long time. The only thing I can add to the reviews is that they get wet really easily. They do dry quickly, but dewy grass gets them soaking’ wet. Another thing to be aware of, because the insoles are removable, they slide around a little. Now that I’ve got them “broken in” they don’t squish around as much. Also, my sizing might be a little big, but if you you’re trying to jump out of an uber or taxi, my foot slides around and pops out of the shoe sometimes. I might just lack grace at doing that though, its not something I do every day! If interested, I’d love for you to use my code! https://www.talkable.com/x/PzY6QN

  327. $20 off coupon:

    https://www.talkable.com/x/qODu7Y

    These shoes are great! They are super comfy, come in a variety of colors that go with evrything from shorts to jeans to business attire, AND they’re machine washable! I have washed mine and they’ve kept their shape and there are no lingering funky smells. These shoes are worth the money! 🙂

  329. I love everyone helping each other out here! I also used a code below to get my savings, so here is mine to pay it forward. Help yourself to it! https://www.talkable.com/x/H6UTbQ

    Also, I’ve been LOVING the shoes so far, this is a great investment.

  332. I just got my Rothy’s. They are very comfy! I did order half a size up like I’ve seen suggested and I’m glad I did because my feet are on the wider side. Thanks for the review! I got my discount here so I will leave mine too for someone else to use:
    https://www.talkable.com/x/NgEbQj

  333. Rothys are the best! They completely give you a new wardrobe. I gave away my shoe collection when I started buying these. They are wearable everywhere. The price makes these shoes more inexpensive than my previous shoe collection because I had to buy so many different pair based on activity. I wear these anywhere and everywhere.
    https://www.talkable.com/x/TeEY7I

  340. Ordered my first pair last week and they just arrived! I got the Lollipop Loafer in size 7 (I’m usually a 7.5, but they said that color ran big). It fits true to size and is so comfy it feels like I’m wearing socks. Perfect for wearing to work, but also out and about. I wear them with the standard insole. If you want to try them, here’s a fresh code: https://www.talkable.com/x/0BWFsQ and free returns!

    1. I’d been considering rothy’s for a while and am so glad I finally bought them! They are super comfortable, and I’m wearing them just as much as I hoped I would 🙂

      I’m usually a 6.5-7 and went up to a 7 in the point.

      Here’s a fresh code for $20! https://www.talkable.com/x/vE5ZfF

  343. I had to buy a whole size up (of the loafers) because I have wide feet and I am incredibly pleased:
    1) the exchange was much easier than with any other product – I simply put the whole box in the mailbox
    2) even though my rothy’s are clearly longer than I’d need them, they are by far the most comfortable shoes I’ve had AND they don’t fall down even when I bike 🙂

    Try them with this code to get $20 off! https://www.talkable.com/x/RIASjC

  344. OK…I’m trying to decide on my next pair! I really love the flat fit on my foot. The most comfortable of my 3 pairs which include a point and loafer also. I have ordered an 8 in all 3. I”m normally a 7.5 W so sized up to 8. The flats are more comfortable to me than even the loafers. They seem to just be perfect for my foot. So many colors to choose from! If you haven’t tried Rothy’s yet, you have nothing to lose. Free shipping both ways. And here is $20 off your first pair (I get $20 on my next too! So thank you for using my link). https://www.talkable.com/x/Ghv9dC

  347. Fresh code for anyone that needs it: https://www.talkable.com/x/NVTY8f

    A heads up if this will be your first pair – there are some QC issues with sizing lately. So you may need to exchange for the same size to get your perfect pair (free returns/exchanges).

    The round toe I can usually fit my regular ballet flat size. From there size up 1/2 size – full size for points and loafers (for me usually 1/2 for points and full for loafers).

    Once you get the pair that fits just right you will be addicted as they are incredibly comfortable and I can’t stress enough how much I love having washable insoles!

    Enjoy!

  351. Super happy with my rothy’s! I had to exchange them for a half size larger coz I have wide feet and it was super duper easy, so I think getting them is a no brainer: if you don’t love them, you can return them super easy and for free!

    Here’s a code for $20 off: https://www.talkable.com/x/od9gue

  352. Had never had favorite shoes until I tried Rothy’s. I got the black loafers and haven’t found an outfit they go wrong with 🙂

    Thanks everyone for sharing your codes!! Here’s another one to pay the discount forward:
    https://www.talkable.com/x/sfCPWg

  363. I’m super about these flats. I cycle to work, and I love that I can just throw them in the wash and have them come out looking BRAND NEW!!! Seriously, being able to wash my flats? Total game changer.

    https://www.talkable.com/x/ZYB5Px Use my code for $20 off your first pair. I typically wear a 7 in flats, and I size up to a 7.5 in both the rounds and the points cause I like lots of wiggle room for my toes. ^_^

  364. I just changed jobs and am now on my feet literally the entire day (I’m standing as I type this!) My Rothy’s (especially the new colors with the thicker insoles) get me through the day. Here is a fresh code for anyone looking to fall in love! https://www.talkable.com/x/rw8IZK

  366. Wide, Flat Feet Alert! $20 off plus Free Shipping: https://www.talkable.com/x/ZcUl98

    So, I have wide feet and I HATE the way my feet look in flats usually. Oh, and did I mention my feet are also quite flat? I did but it’s a recipe for shoe disaster. Not with Rothy’s though. I love them! I can’t wait to buy another pair. I didn’t have any issues with soreness and I wore them ALL day.

    I want to pass along my good fortune and give people $20 off plus Free Shipping. Best of all you can return them if you don’t like them. https://www.talkable.com/x/ZcUl98

  368. Size up half size in all sizes if you have wide feet like me! One tip – if they are too large when you get them, but width is good then you can add a Odor Eaters Slim sole under the Rothy’s sole…just makes them a little smaller.

    Here is a fresh $20 off link :https://www.talkable.com/x/GsuRji

  370. I love my Rothys. No bliters from day 1. They also wash amazing so you don’t have to be afraid to wear them regardles fo the weather or other conditions. Here is my refferal code if you would like $20 off your first pair. https://www.talkable.com/x/peKRvx

  371. I’ve never been a pointy shoe gal, so I was nervous to order my first ever pair of pointy shoes (also because I have wide feet). Based on other reviews, I ordered half a size up. (I’m normally a 7 but ordered a 7.5)
    I was pleasantly surprised to find Rothy’s very soft and comfortable. I was expecting something much more plastic feeling and less fabric-like.

    The half size up was good, the shoes don’t dig into my feet but aren’t so loose that they would ever fall off. Sometimes I get blisters from new shoes but these were fine. I went a whole day with no problems.
    I have a few pairs of Tieks and while I like my Tieks, I feel like Rothy’s are more breathable (my feet get unfortunately sweaty) and being able to throw them in the wash is a huge bonus.

    All in all, I would recommend Rothy’s. If you choose to order a pair, feel free to use the following code for $20 off: https://www.talkable.com/x/7h9s4N

  375. Take the plunge and buy a pair. $20 off and Free Shipping!
    Oh and they will totally take them back if they don’t fit or you don’t like them (spoiler alert, you’ll love them)
    Here’s the freshest code on the block to get you started: https://www.talkable.com/x/vR12H0
    Click, Buy, Enjoy. That’s what I did 🙂

    Happy Shopping!

  377. Purchased point toe in leopard. First wear no problem. Second wear some heel rubbing. I have bunions and wide forefoot. Went up 1/2 size from 8 to 8.5. 8 was too tight on toes. 8.5 feels loose but heels don’t slip off. Definitely getting more supportive inserts. Here’s my coupon code to share. https://www.talkable.com/x/uSTrpc

  379. UPDATE…I just received my 3rd pair of Rothy’s. My first pair was a Marigold point. My 2nd was a heather loafer. And now my 3rd is a Navy Flat. My other two reviews are here somewhere if you want to read them, but this review will be of the FLAT.

    I have to say of all three pairs, this is my favorite! I love the look of the point more…but it just isn’t as comfortable for me having a wide foot. It’s still more comfortable than other pointed toe shoes, and it’s great for wearing to church or to meeting etc. But for a day of walking…I’m grabbing for the Flats I just bought!

    I was really surprised I liked the comfort of these more than even the loafer. For some reason the rounded toe just feels more roomy tom me. I also love the fact that they can still be dressed up more than the loafer. I can still get away with wearing these to work or church with a skirt or cute sun dress. They will also be great with shorts or skinny jeans. Based on the fact that this is the least expensive of the three, at $125, my next pair of Rothy’s will definitely be the Flats! If you haven’t tried them yet…here is $20 off your first pair (and $20 towards my next pair of Flats too! So thank you for using my link). https://www.talkable.com/x/T7Z5FI

  381. I wear my Rothy’s literally all the time. This review and all the comments are so helpful! Here’s a fresh $20 off code for anyone looking to try them out! I suggest sizing up for the points, tts for the loafers. https://www.talkable.com/x/LYPQ6G

  382. I decided to take the plunge after reading this review and got a pair of the chili red point Rothy’s. I love them, but I do highly recommend moving up a half size (I wear a standard 8.5 and needed a 9, but the customer service made it really painless for me to order a second pair, send back the first, and keep my $20 off new customer offer. I used a stranger’s code from this blog, so I’m paying it forward to someone else who might want to try them out!

    https://www,talkable.com/x/d8ED4Z

  387. I used a code from here so now I’m sharing my own! https://www.talkable.com/x/cGbhFR

    Just got my flats (round toe) and am very happy with them! I got worried that they would be too small – there was a lot of advice to go up at least a half size for the points but there wasn’t much said about the round toe flats. I normally wear a 5 in all “normal” shoes but a 5 1/2 in running shoes. Ordered these flats in a 5 and they are perfect. I’ve only had a chance to try them on and walk around the apartment, though, (and they were very comfortable for that, at least) but don’t yet have any comments on long term comfort and durability. But I think I may love these! (Shared my code with the hopes of buying more colors!)

  389. I get asked about my Rothy’s nearly every time I wear them. Every time, I say that I did not instantly fall in love, but that after about a week I found that they were the only shoes I was wearing. I do have 3/4 inserts that I wear in “The Point” and full length inserts that I wear in “The Flat” and that makes them even more comfortable.

    I guess my biggest complaint is that my feet do get wet when it rains. Wear on sunny days 🙂 (However, I throw them in the wash and they are back to new.)

    Use my link and code for $20 off and I get it too! https://www.talkable.com/x/FZgrwy

  391. So I’m loving my Rothy’s but I had a little issue with fit at first. My foot is wide so my normal size dug into my heel. I went up a half size and they slipped. I purchase a T-shaped heel protector from Amazon and they are now AMAZING! Thank you for the great review.
    There are so many great colors that have just been added! Here’s my code for $20 off your first pair https://www.talkable.com/x/k1JcrM

  394. Have been wearing my first pair of Rothy’s for a few months now and love them! Wish I would have ordered a half size up as they do fit a little snug on the back of my heel.

    Here is $20 off!

    https:www.talkable.com/x/kFdSsl

  398. I had never been so in love with a pair of shoes! they go well with any of my outfits and they feel like sneakers!

    Try them! Here’s a code for $20 off: https://www.talkable.com/x/PuMIsn
    if you don’t love them, returns are super easy and FREE 😉 !… I had to exchange my order for a full size up because of my wide feet – originally ordered only half a size up as that seems to be what works for most… I guess my feet are wider than most 😛

    1. And if you have wide feet, a whole size up may be even better.
      But returns are so easy (and shoes arrive so fast) that you can buy half size up and if it feels too tight, exchange for the whole size up.

      Here’s my code for $20 off 🙂 : https://www.talkable.com/x/lC4qkt

  405. I have VERY wide feet (If I can find it an E width is great). I bought my usual size, 10.5, and a size up, 11, in the point style (in cheetah print). The 11 was the better fit for me. I love the fabric and the rubber sole and they felt super comfy on my feet, length wise, however they were definitely pinching my toes width wise. I decided to return them and am going to try again with the Flat style which seems to fit a bit wider. The sad part is they don’t come in the cheetah print 🙁 I’m determined to make these work as they feel like wearing slippers and I LOVE that they are machine washable (a must when you have hyperhydrosis).

    If you would like to use my code for $20 off please use this link! https://www.talkable.com/x/YSsCyg

    1. Sorry for the double posting, I thought my explorer was not allowing me to post… turns out it was simply a bit slow in the morning…. and so was I 😛

  414. Obsessed!

    Update – I have gone from being hesitant to spend so much money on a pair of flats that I learned about from Instagram to owning 4 pairs in the span of a month. I bought the first two for a trip to Germany. Without ever breaking them in beforehand, I didn’t get a single blister. There was a lot of walking over the course of the trip but the shoes held up perfectly. I put them in the wash when I got home and now they look like new.

    I did notice different colors seem to fit slightly differently but an extra pair of insoles does the trick, if needed.

    Also, on a rainy day your feet will get soaked. Not a surprise as the material is almost like a thick mesh. The good news is they dry out pretty quickly once you have a chance to take them off and the insoles out.

    If you are hesitating buying a pair, do it. You won’t regret it.

    Paying it forward with the coupon code. Thanks to everyone for your reviews!
    https://www.talkable.com/x/48YoZh

  415. Here’s another link for $20 off: https://www.talkable.com/x/QdtXI7

    I took the plunge at bought two pairs, one round toe and one pointed and I love them both! I have clammy feet, so I love that these are washable. Sometimes I’ll kick them off at my desk for a few minutes and they dry out super quickly. So far I think they’re worth the money and I’m totally going to be buying more.

  416. Thanks for the reviews!! They were really useful in deciding whether to buy a pair, I know there are free returns, but it’s hard for me to make such an investment in shoes!!
    I got them just yesterday and they are truly a dream! I can bike with them without worrying about my shoes falling if I stop abruptly or lower my feet too quickly from the pedals!

    If you are unsure as I was, remember: if you don’t love them, you can return them… but most likely you will love them 🙂 so use one of the codes that these ladies have kindly posted for a $20 off 🙂 and here’s another one! https://www.talkable.com/x/Gckei9

  419. $20 OFF your first pair AND FREE shipping + returns.
    https://www.talkable.com/x/OiDCHr

    I’m not on my 3rd pair. I love them so much. I know the price tag is shocking (I was completely floored by the price) but I haven’t regretted a single cent. Completely worth it in my opinion. Plus, I washed them just to make sure they hold up to the claims and it worked great.

    Seriously, no regrets here. Take the plunge. You won’t regret it!
    https://www.talkable.com/x/OiDCHr

  423. I loved my first pair of Rothy’s (the Point in magenta heather), so I recently ordered my first pair of flats. The Points are perfect for work, but I like the Flats as an everyday shoe, especially for traveling. The real test will be to see how well my Rothy’s hold up on cobblestone streets during work travel abroad. Ordering in my regular size (8) for the Flat and sizing up .5 for the Point has worked for me.

    Here is a new code for $20 off your first order: https://www.talkable.com/x/OcH6Vm

  424. I had reviewed my Marigold points, and now have a second pair of Rothy’s. I’ve now been wearing my Rothy’s loafers for awhile and I have to say I love them more than the points. Obviously, the points are more fashionable and look better with dressy outfits, although I’ve gotten away with my loafers with dress pants and maxi skirts. This may not be the case for everyone, but I have a wide foot and the comfort level in the loafers that have much more toe room, makes them feel exactly like sneakers to me. The points are still comfortable, but I guess you have to give up that extra toe area for the look. I do have to say I can still wiggle my toes in my points, so they aren’t as restricting as traditional pointed toe shoes. I am about to order my 3rd pair, the flat. I have the feeling these will be more roomy in the toe as well. If you need a fresh $20 code, try this one: https://www.talkable.com/x/DXus7C

  427. I have a wider foot, and love my Rothys! I have the point in the leopard print. I ordered a full size up because #1 – Wide foot #2 – it’s a pointed shoe. I always order up a half size in a pointed shoe, and Rothys suggests a half size up if you have wide feet. At any rate, the full size up fits beautifully.

    My feet don’t look squeezed into the shoe, and they certainly don’t feel constricted. The shoe is fashionable and comfy. The bottom feels similar to a Tom or Tieks, but the remainder of the shoe is MUCH more comfy and soft.

    I’ve also enjoyed my newer “flat” Rothys. I ordered a 9.5, rather than my usual 9Wide. They are just as comfy, if not a bit more so! The pointed version is more dressy. The flat is more casual. If you want the flat to read more upscale, I suggest a print or pop color. The Heather or lighter colors look more casual.If you would like to try a pair for yourself, I offer my $20 discount code to you with hopes that you will be as pleased with them as I am! https://www.talkable.com/x/a0Mmeb

    1. Thanks for your suggestion Abby!!

      I ordered the point is slate metallic thinking I can return for free if I don’t love them, but I fell in love immediatly! I agree: the bottom is similar to a tom (haven’t tried tieks) but the rest wraps your foot more comfortably 🙂 … almost like a pair of sneakers.

      Thanks for sharing your codes, here’s another one for $200 off to keep spreading the joy: https://www.talkable.com/x/wU1ryL

    2. I agree! the bottom feels similar to a tom (haven’t tried tieks) but the rest is almost like a pair of sneakers! (I got the loafer)

      Thanks, everyone for sharing your codes, here’s another one to keep spreading the joy: https://www.talkable.com/x/wU1ryL

  434. I have a wider foot, and love my Rothys! I have the point in the leopard print point. I ordered a full size up because #1 – Wide foot #2 – it’s a pointed shoe. I always order up a half size in a pointed shoe, and Rothys suggests a half size up if you have wide feet. At any rate, the full size up fits beautifully. My feet don’t look squeezed into the shoe, and they certainly don’t feel constricted. The shoe is fashionable and comfy. The bottom feels similar to a Tom or Tieks, but the remainder of the shoe is MUCH more comfy and soft.I’ve also enjoyed my newer “flat” Rothys. I ordered a 9.5, rather than my usual 9Wide. They are just as comfy, if not a bit more so! The pointed version is more dressy. The flat is more casual. If you want the flat to read more upscale, I suggest a print or pop color. The Heather or lighter colors look more casual.If you would like to try a pair for yourself, I offer my $20 discount code to you with hopes that you will be as pleased with them as I am! https://www.talkable.com/x/a0Mmeb

  436. This review was really helpful!

    I wear a size 10 in every shoe I own and have annoyingly long toes. I took a long walk during lunch the first day I wore these and it did rub the top of my toes and sides of my ankles. However, I kept at it over the next few days and I’m pretty comfortable in them now. I did order a second pair and ordered both a 10 and a 10.5, and low and behold the 10.5s were just too long and felt looser in the back.

    I’m really happy with my two pairs. I got the black and beige pointy toe flats. I work in a very formal environment where business casual is worn on casual days. I definitely feel like I can wear these without being too casual.

    If you can forgive that my review is half duplicated below after accidently hitting submit when my dog jumped on me, here is my referral link for you to save $20 on your pair:

    https://www.talkable.com/x/IFHD00

  437. This review was really helpful.

    I wear a size 10 and have annoyingly long toes. I took a long walk during lunch the first day I wore these and it did rub the top of my toes and sides of my ankles. However, I kept at it over the next few days and I’m pretty comfortable in them now. I did order a second pair and ordered both a 10 and a 10.5 (I am a 10 in almost everything), and low and behold the 10.5s were just too long and felt looser in the back. I’m really happy

  440. I have a wider foot, and love my Rothys! I have the point in the leopard print point. I ordered a full size up because #1 – Wide foot #2 – it’s a pointed shoe. I always order up a half size in a pointed shoe, and Rothys suggests a half size up if you have wide feet. At any rate, the full size up fits beautifully. My feet don’t look squeezed into the shoe, and they certainly don’t feel constricted. The shoe is fashionable and comfy. The bottom feels similar to a Tom or Tieks, but the remainder of the shoe is MUCH more comfy and soft.

    I’ve also enjoyed my newer “flat” Rothys. I ordered a 9.5, rather than my usual 9Wide. They are just as comfy, if not a bit more so! The pointed version is more dressy. The flat is more casual. If you want the flat to read more upscale, I suggest a print or pop color. The Heather or lighter colors look more casual.

    If you would like to try a pair for yourself, I offer my $20 discount code to you with hopes that you will be as pleased with them as I am! https://www.talkable.com/x/a0Mmeb

  441. Thank you all for the reviews.

    I initially bought a point but then changed it to a flat. I like the point, but found the flat to be more comfortable. I bought the grey birdseye color. I like it that it is neutral with a little kick in the design. It neutral enough to wear to work and comfortable enough that I more than happy to wear them on the weekend.

    Here is fresh code for anyone who still need them
    https://www.talkable.com/x/xc0jjD

  447. updated review: I ordered a 7 in the marigold point and had to exchange them for 7.5 to make them more comfortable. But man, once I got the 7.5 ones, they were the best flats I’ve ever owned! They’re really soft, flexible, lightweight and look great. I wore them throughout my vacation in France and they held up great. We did tons of walking around cities AND I wore them to the beach. Yes, the beach! And they were great! The sand pours right out and since the insoles are removable, you can get ALL of the sand out. Not only that but they still looked great for nights out and I’ve also gotten so many compliments on them.

    I was apprehensive about buying Rothy’s because they’re quite expensive and I couldn’t try them on beforehand, but I’m so glad I did! They’re worth the investment.

    For $20 off, you can use code: https://www.talkable.com/x/AcuRvp

  448. I really like my Rothy’s and have two pairs of the pointed ones. They are my go-to shoes for both work and weekends.

    However, I want to caution people that the removable soles smell really bad after awhile. The rest of the shoe will be fine after a wash, but the soles will start to stink again after a couple days’ wear. I don’t have this problem with leather shoes that I routinely wear without socks, so I think it’s something about the materials used in the Rothy’s, maybe the rubber on the bottom of the sole. I bought some Dr. Scholl’s Odor-X inserts and plan to use them instead of the Rothy’s soles, so hopefully that will fix the problem.

    Here’s also a new code for anyone who needs it: https://www.talkable.com/x/UOyWCZ

  454. Mine just arrived and I’m in love! So super soft, and my wide feet fit into he point with no issue! I ordered a size up, as we should with any pointed toe shoe. Love the material, such a cozy alternative to my Tieks! Ok girls, $20 off if you need a link… https://www.talkable.com/x/B6Rb6r

  458. I got a size 10 and they felt ok when I tried them on, but then I wore them around and they HURT!!! I got three terrible blisters within an hour, and the back of the heel was like razorblades. I was walking on the heel before I even made it to the meeting I was supposed to go to.

    I can’t return them now that I’ve worn them which is a real bummer. They felt comfy at home but terrible out in the real world!

    1. I was on the fence for a long time. I read numerous reviews and was afraid to spend the money without seeing them in person. Today a friend of mine had them on in my size! I was able to try the pointed ones and they were much more flexible that I ever thought, and soft. If you are on the fence don’t be afraid to try them. Hope you found my comment helpful and use my code to get $20 off. Click on the link in the comment and then put in your email address and you will be given a code right then and there for $20.00 off! And, I get a coupon for $20 off. win/win https://www.talkable.com/x/KFmt4k

    1. I was on the fence for a long time. I read numerous reviews and was afraid to spend the money without seeing them in person. Today a friend of mine had them on in my size! I was able to try the pointed ones and they were much more flexible that I ever thought, and soft. If you are on the fence don’t be afraid to try them. Hope you found my comment helpful and use my code to get $20 off. Click on the link in the comment and then put in your email address and you will be given a code right then and there for $20.00 off! And, I get a coupon for $20 off. win/win https://www.talkable.com/x/KFmt4k

  465. Mine just arrived and I’m in love! So super soft, and my wide feet fit into he point with no issue! I ordered a size up, as we should with any pointed toe shoe. Love the material, such a cozy alternative to my Tieks! Ok girls, $20 off if you need a link… https://www.talkable.com/x/B6Rb6r

  482. Here’s a new discount code! https://www.talkable.com/x/LCygxc
    Thanks so your review, I’ve now just ordered my second pair! I love the loafers. To my surprise, they have not needed to be washed yet! I, too, can get smelly, sweaty feet but they hold up well. These are fantastic! i can’t wait for the new color to arrive!

  487. I really like my Rothys!!!!!
    BUT WARNING…
    I have the red chili point and the heel has become discolored on both my original pair purchased AND the replacement paid that customer service provided free of charge.
    When I reached out about the second pair they have issued a gift card for the full price of a new pair.

    CUSTOMER SERVICE A+++++
    Shoe washability – YES, but be ware!!!!! (Note that the red shoe has the black heel interior which is what I think is causing the issue.)

  488. My dog just ate my Lucky Brand Emmie flats and in a way, I wasn’t really upset. They weren’t as expensive at Rothy’s but they weren’t the cheapest flats out their either. They were never as comfortable as I wanted them to be. They were always rubbing somewhere and I had put a bunch of moleskin in them. I’m so in love with my Rothy’s, I’m glad I had a reason to buy them. My code is https://www.talkable.com/x/30SOpY if anyone needs a code.

  498. This thread is amazing. Thanks for keeping up the fresh codes everyone. Just got my first pair for my trip to Europe this summer. The port looks SO CHIC. Can’t wait!

    Here’s a new code in case someone needs it: https://www.talkable.com/x/DlOvFL

  503. I love my Rothy’s! I have wide, hard to fit feet and my Rothy’s fit like a glove out of the box. They really do feel like I’m wearing my favorite pair of slippers around all day and yet they look so cute. If you want a pair and need a $20 off coupon, here’s my link:
    https://www.talkable.com/x/AhkVmH

  504. Thanks for allowing us to do a referral chain! I just used one of the links and received $20 off for my very first pair! After doing some research, it seems like they run true to size, so I went with my normal size (9.5). I ordered the dark camo Point. Dark camo is so on trend, and I’m thinking the Point style will be dressy enough for my work casual office. If anyone else needs a $20 off link, here’s my new one: https://www.talkable.com/x/lcOKKc.

  505. Thanks for this review!! I ended up ordered one pair of each style… black solid in the flat; port in the point; and dark red in the loafer. My favorite for versatility are definitely the loafer style. Here’s my $20 code, if anyone’s still shopping:

    https://www.talkable.com/x/3TINYD

  507. Thanks for the review! That and everyone’s comments and the referral code someone posted got me to finally place an order.
    I got the leopard print pointy toe shoe. I am usually a size 9 and although I normally wear regular width shoes, sometimes I do get WW in flats or I size up in some shoes because I feel like my toe area is wider and I don’t like to feel squished in my shoes and I also like to accommodate any foot swelling by the end of the day.

    I ordered my Rothy’s in a 9.5 and on the first day or two I was worried that it was too tight on my toes and I should have gotten a 10, but then they have loosened up and are perfect now. And best part, they didn’t cut my feet and I wore them in the rain without any problems and they dried perfectly and the shape stayed the same.
    Also if it helps anyone with their purchase or sizing issues, I am a teacher and live in NYC so I am on my feet all day long teaching and then doing the typical NYC commute of walking to and from train stations and I have had zero discomfort from these shoes and I waited a month before writing this, just to make sure I still felt the same way lol.

    Here is a new link in case anyone needs the $20 off:
    https://www.talkable.com/x/jrCDqm

  513. I have to be honest, my Rothy’s were rubbing my Achilles heel. I had to size up because I have a wide foot but the larger size slipped enough to make it hurt on the heel. So I went to Amazon and ordered these heel protectors https://tinyurl.com/y9jyqp4f and I’m happy to report, they work perfectly. The nice thing about these is that they give the added bonus of adding some cushioning to the bottom of the heel which is perfect for a heavy heel striker like me. While some people may not want to add something like this into a pair of shoes that cost $145, I’m OK with it, they feel absolutely amazing now and I wish I could wear them everywhere.

    Here’s my code so you can feel the love with Rothy’s

    https://www.talkable.com/x/30SOpY

  515. I just ordered my first pair and love them! I have bunions in my feet and because these shoes have a little stretch to them, my bunions don’t hurt after a day of wearing them. They are also super cute and I’ve had many people compliment them and ask me where I got them. Here’s a link to get $20 off your first pair…it also gives me $20 so I can buy my second pair! win win for everyone. https://www.talkable.com/x/VRwUXM

  517. I’m on to my 3rd pair of Rothy’s and I’m not looking back! These shoes are so comfortable and super cute! I’m trying to find an insole that works with the thinness of the point sole but haven’t had any luck yet. Because while these shoes are cute, they’re not quite supportive enough for long treks across the city. Going to try dr. Schools and will update once I’ve tried them out.

    Here’s my code for $20 off! Happy shopping! https://www.talkable.com/x/dDtus6

  520. These are most comfortable flats I’ve ever worn. The soles are very cushiony, I make a point of wearing them on days when I know I will be on my feet a lot at work.

    Here’s my code for $20 off your first pair: https://www.talkable.com/x/m4amtS

  521. I am normally a 7. I ordered a 7.5 in the point which I thought was too big at first but it was actually just right. I read somewhere that sizing up isn’t always needed in the flat, that was wrong for me – had to send the 7s back. The loafer uses the same sole as the flat, so I’d follow Rothy’s advice and half size up on all 3 styles. Just ordered some loafers!

    Here is a $20 off code: https://www.talkable.com/x/PFPGml

  522. I love how stylish and comfy these are! Ordered the point in size 11 (I normally wear a 10.5) and they fit well. No blisters and very comfortable. I have incredibly sweaty feet, and my feet definitely sweat in these. I don’t think they’re quite as breathable as my old Frye leather flats but being able to wash them makes that a fair trade. I’ve washed them twice already and they came out great.

    I think I’m going to buy another pair. Oh, and here’s a code to pay it forward: https://www.talkable.com/x/XMZA5Z

  523. “A man who could afford fifty dollars had a pair of boots that’d still be keeping his feet dry in ten years’ time, while the poor man who could only afford cheap boots would have spent a hundred dollars on boots in the same time and would still have wet feet.”

    Girl just get these and stop buying flats over and over again when they get sticky! Use my code (https://www.talkable.com/x/ZDLALa); it never expires, so should be good whenever you see this. (:

  525. Got my loafers and I am loving them! I bought powerstep inserts to put in them to give some arch support and so far it’s been working great! I did have to trim them down quite a bit though.

    Here’s my code for $20 off! https://www.talkable.com/x/51KnyO

  526. I have always been a Tieks girl, but I was introduced to Rothy’s 2 months ago. I am obsessed! Seriously, the most comfortable shoes right out of the box. No breaking in required. I started with a pair of The Points. Now I have The Flat, The Loafer, and another pair of The Points.
    If you’re interested, here’s a code for $20 off your first pair.
    https://www.talkable.com/x/LESGbD

  528. I received my round toe flats but had to return for a half size bigger since I have a wide foot. I would say that it if you have a wide foot, order the size you would normally get in heels. My point toes in Chilie will be here today and I’m so excited. I have them for R.E.D. (remember everyone deployed) Friday. This means the world to me since my daughter is in the Navy and is scheduled to deploy in October. It’s good to have a bright spot in the day. Here’s my code so others can feel the love with Rothy’s

    https://www.talkable.com/x/30SOpY

    1. For first time users, the code will give you $20 off your first pair. Click the link and then add your shoes to your cart. You won’t see the discount until you click into your cart to checkout. Once you are at that step, you will see the discount.

  529. 20 Off + Free Shipping and Returns
    https://www.talkable.com/x/TfkxOS

    ***Update: Received my Rothy’s (Dove Grey with that gorgeous bright orange sole) and they are SO COMFORTABLE! I couldn’t believe it. No break-in period needed whatsoever. I have wide-ish feet and I didn’t need to size up, so I think they run true to size. I’ve never taken a pair of flats out of the box and had zero discomfort.

    I’m going to buy another pair (the point this time) as soon as I choose a color (the most difficult part).

    Happy Shopping!

    1. I’ve had the black point for about a month or 2 and love them! So comfortable and so many compliments. I have narrow feet and got a 9.5 and they fit perfectly. Like them so much that I just got another pair! Here’s a $20 code: https://www.talkable.com/x/njIE6E

  533. Love my Rothy’s. I have slightly wider feet but can wear normal sizes. The rounded toe flat fits perfectly in a size 9. My points are a size 9.5 I love the shape of the point but prefer the feel of the round as my foot doesn’t seem to slide around the shoe as much. A size 9 point was too tight. https://www.talkable.com/x/deEvv9

  534. Just ordered the loafers! I’ll leave an updated review after I’ve tried them out. I’m also going to attempt to put arch support insoles in them so I’ll review that as well.
    I have the point in Marigold and I LOVE THEM. I will say that wearing them sockless has started to irritate the tops of my toes a teensy bit so I may go back to wearing socks, but they’re still the most comfortable flats I own. Definitely worth it!

    Here’s a code for $20 off! https://www.talkable.com/x/51KnyO

    1. I ordered my normal size in the loafer, I sized up in the point. I found the loafer to be wider in the toe area (obviously), and felt great in my normal size.

  539. The loafers are back in stock! I repeat, the loafers are back in stock!
    https://www.talkable.com/x/ImocGR fresh $20 off code!

    I bought the olive camo loafers when they were announced last month, and I’m telling you, I wear them absolutely all the time. So comfortable – loafers usually have a pinch point for me on a swap due to my wide feet and bunion – not these!!

    1. I just used your code for my first pair! Hardest part after getting over the sticker shock was picking a color! Thank you!!

  540. $20 Off Plus Free Shipping AND Free Returns
    https://www.talkable.com/x/gwInCm

    I know it’s a high price tag but they’ve been totally worth it for me! Just being able to wash them makes them invaluable. I’ve been through sooo many pairs that inevitably smell awful by the time the summer is over. With $20 off and free shipping AND returns, what do you have to lose? I’m going in for my second pair.

  541. UPDATE ON REVIEW:

    I just had to add something that happened yesterday related to my Rothy’s Point in Marigold. We’ve been having an extreme amount of rain here in South Florida lately, and yesterday I wanted to wear my Marigold Rothy’s to church. I wore them with an olive color maxi skirt and they really popped! The problem was I had to park on the grass, and the ground was saturated. When I got inside I noticed a spot of dirt on the tip of my left shoe. I stupidly tried to rub it off, and only succeeded in spreading a big dark streak of dirt on the whole top of the shoe. I went in the ladies room and tried to use some liquid soap and water on a paper towel, and was able to get some of it off, but it was still a stain. I was so upset. When I got home, rather than fully washing them, I first decided to try spot cleaning. I took some laundry detergent on a washcloth and worked on the spot and then rinsed just the tip of the shoe under cold water. And the stain appeared to be gone! But the real test was after they dried. Wow, was I happy to see that the stains were completely gone. I have the feeling if these had been any other fabric flat, the stain would have been permanent, or rubbing would have caused damage to the shoe. I’m so happy with Rothy’s! I don’t know if my previous code is good anymore because they are limited, so here is a new one for $20 off if you want to give the a try. Free shipping both ways so no risk to try! https://www.talkable.com/x/6pErNx

  542. Fresh $20 off code: https://www.talkable.com/x/YC9PeZ

    Update on my review: I have VERY wide feet and had two foot surgeries when I was younger, so comfortable shoes are a must for me regardless of price. I love my Tieks (classic only) as they are great with my wide feet. I decided to try Rothy’s because I heard great things. I ordered a Point in a half size larger than my normal size (I’m usually a 7 and I ordered a 7.5). I thought at first they were too big and I was going to send them back, but I kept wearing them and decided the 7.5 are probably perfect (7 would be too snug in the toe). I ordered a second pair now that has a round toe in my normal 7. I’ll report back if that sizing is correct. I am loving my points though. I wore them to work today and I have no blisters or discomfort! YAY!

  544. Link to $20 off: https://www.talkable.com/x/jODCfI
    I received my pair of chili red points this past Thursday and wore them through the weekend without a blister in sight. I ordered a half a size up, which was perfect for my relatively narrow feet. I wore them to work and then later to social events during the weekend, and I’ve never received so many compliments on a shoe before! Walked and biked in them in complete comfort, they’re like leggings for your feet. Everyone should have a pair!

  548. I wanted to share my Rothy’s experience. I had seen Rothy’s posted on Pinterest and Facebook and Youtube and decided to give them a try. I have a lot of trouble finding comfortable shoes. I have a combo problem with knee and hip issues which make wearing heals painful, and ingrown nail issues that make some flats painful as well. But I thought since Rothy’s offered free shipping both ways they were worth a try. I first ordered the Birdseye Flax Point style in two sizes 7 1/2 and 8. I normally wear a 7 1/2 wide. After reading other reviews I found people saying if you have a wide foot, that you should go up a size in the point style. The 7 1/2 was very tight but the 8 fit pretty well when I first put it on. After walking back and forth a bit I did feel that the toe area was still slightly snug. I thought it might stretch a bit, but decided to try an 8 1/2. Unfortunately, the 8 1/2 was too long and the heel slipped a little causing discomfort, and the toe didn’t feel much roomier if at all. So it was back to order an 8. The flax 8 was now out of stock, but the great customer service department was able to do an exchange to the Marigold in 8 that was in stock without me having to do a whole new order. I do have to say that the wait time to reach customer service was ridiculous (12 minutes on hold only to have the call cut off, then another 10 before they answered), but once they finally answered they were very helpful and nice. So after putting on the 8 Marigold, I found them to be very comfortable after a bit of wear. They almost seem to mold to your foot. There is the slightest discomfort if I walk too long against the side of my big toe on my right foot, but that is because of the nail issue and I’d have that in any shoe that isn’t boxy. All in all I am very happy with these and would like to get another color.

    3. I’m glad you mentioned that your size wasn’t available for exchange. I received my size 9 Birdseye Flax in the mail yesterday (super fast shipping) and they were too tight in the heel. I went in just now to process the exchange and saw that sizes were limited but they did have the 9 1/2. I hope they aren’t so tight in the heel but not sloppy big either. The marigold ones are beautiful.

  550. $20 Off Plus Free Shipping
    https://www.talkable.com/x/G1kBp3

    I’ve been hemming and hawing over ordering these because of the price but I just bit the bullet and bought a pair of the new Dove Grey Flats (that bright orange sole got me)! I’m super excited!!! I have wide-ish feet but I still ordered my regular size. I hope it works out! *fingers crossed*

  554. I wear between a 6.5-7 shoe size and I tried both the 6.5 and 7 in the point. 6.5 was too small and 7 was a teeeensy bit roomier than I expected, but I think that’s because I’m used to flats being really snug. The 7 is still really comfortable and fits well! I’m definitely buying a second pair!

    Here’s my code for $20 off! https://www.talkable.com/x/GJZzfK

  556. Here is a fresh $20 off code: https://www.talkable.com/x/YC9PeZ

    I got my first pair yesterday. I got Marigold point in a half size larger than I normally wear because I have super wide duck feet, lol! But, I think my normal 7 would have been fine. I’m debating to keep them or exchange for a half size smaller. I already want to order an additional pair – maybe the ash grey camo flat!

    1. Here is a fresh $20 off code: https://www.talkable.com/x/YC9PeZ

      I got my first pair yesterday. I got Marigold point in a half size larger than I normally wear because I have super wide duck feet, lol! But, I think my normal 7 would have been fine. I’m debating to keep them or exchange for a half size smaller. I already want to order an additional pair – maybe the ash grey camo flat!

  559. Thank you for the review. My dog just ate my Lucky Brand Emmie flats and in a way, I wasn’t really upset. They weren’t as expensive at Rothy’s but they weren’t the cheapest flats out their either. They were never as comfortable as I wanted them to be. They were always rubbing somewhere and I had put a bunch of moleskin in them. I’m hoping these will be a more comfortable shoe. I already have my sights on the red ones but I got the Birdseed Flax to start. My code is https://www.talkable.com/x/30SOpY if anyone needs a code.

  560. I just ordered my first pair and love them! I have bunions in both my feet and because these shoes have a little stretch to them, my bunions don’t hurt after a day of wearing them. Here’s a new link to get $20 off your first pair…it also gives me $20 so I can buy my second pair! https://www.talkable.com/x/VRwUXM

    1. Thank you for the review.

      Thanks, Michelle for the current code. I just used it now. 🙂 I have a few pairs of Tieks, and been eyeing the Rothy’s pointy flats for a while. So finally giving it a try.

      Sharing my discount code for whoever might be tempted or interested in trying these flats. Can’t wait for my first pair. I ordered The Point Chili Red .

      https://www.talkable.com/x/m5VptX

      1. Update on my Point Red Chili order. It came with packaged nicely. The shoes are gorgeous. I normally wear a size 8 except in sandals when i wear a 7.5. I ordered the size 8. The length seems perfect except I do have wider feet and it just didn’t look right towards the point. I may see if I can exchange it for size 8.5 but am afraid that the 8.5 might be too long. I did order a 2nd pair in the ballet flat, size 8, so will see if that fits and looks better on my feet. 🙂 My feet do look nice and not wide at all in Tieks, which made me like Tieks. So will see if the Rothy’s flat does the same for my feet.

        Here’s a fresh $20 code for those who might be interested in trying Rothy’s.

        https://www.talkable.com/x/UnlG6g

  563. I have 3 pairs now! I find the flats to be the most comfortable and the point to be the cutest. The loafers are comfy, but definitely snug, as advertised. I have the flat and loafer in my normal size, and the point a half size up.

    If anyone needs a code for $20 (which also gives me $20), here you go: https://www.talkable.com/x/VFPeYK

  566. This blog post convinced me to try the Point in red camo, and I highly recommend them. I have always liked wearing pointed/almond toe flats for work, but it is difficult to find comfortable ones that don’t cause or worsen foot pain. Rothy’s to the rescue!
    Here is a new code for $20 off your first order: https://www.talkable.com/x/36FFXE

  569. I ordered the size 8 in Port. I’m usually between a 7.5 and an 8 with narrow feet, and after wearing the 8 around the house I’m trying a 7.5 as well. Since the shoe is so stretchy and I like a more snug fit, I’m wondering if the 7.5 will be better. The toe space felt good with an 8 but it felt like my heel could come out when I was really walking.

    I love the Port color, different than black but still goes with everything!

    Here’s a new code for $20 off! https://www.talkable.com/x/GMCp22

  571. These are seriously the best most versatile flat. Love them. If you are a small size there is really not that big of a difference in length/width, I went up to 6 to get more color selection with no problem at all.

    Fresh code for $20 off: https://www.talkable.com/x/UA0Vu1

  573. The most comfortable flats ever. I’ve tried so many brands and styles, including Tieks. No comparison. Try these first! They felt a little snug in my normal size but wearing them around the house loosened them up. No blisters after a day of shopping!
    https://www.talkable.com/x/Xcr9Ua

    1. I ended up wearing the 6s because I was too excited to wait and they felt fine after a couple hours. Received the 6.5 and there’s quite a bit of slippage, so my next pair will be a 6! Going to order an extra 6.5 insole to try to help the slipping in the 6.5. I want all the pairs!

  582. I wore my Rothy’s all weekend long at a music festival and my feet did not hurt at the end of the day. These shoes are comfy, practical and stylish. Here’s a brand new $20 code if someone needs it.

    https://www.talkable.com/x/7kNZgK

  584. In terms of comfort, its hit or miss. I purchased the point and the regular round flats in size 6 (my normal size). I found the round flat to be tight, esp in the toes, but the point flat is roomier on my toes and overall feels less tight. I do hope with wear they will loosen further. Also, a reminder that if you don’t have wide feet don’t go a half size up!

    $20 off code: https://www.talkable.com/x/BLoZt1

  588. I got the flats in Wine. They work well with my work outfits. They travel well too. And I appreciate the 10.5 size – it’s rare to find.

    I had some trouble with the code working and Rothy’s asked for the email of the referral in order to apply my discount – so in case you need it, the email is [email protected].
    https://www.talkable.com/x/lnDSwP

  590. The length difference for the Point is negligible between 5 and 5.5 if anyone is debating… maybe a quarter inch. So if you want the prints available in regular sizes you can probably do 6 with no problem. I’m typically a narrow 5 or 35, and stuart weitzmans fit me well (for reference). But with the Point I’m wearing the 6 easily.

    Fresh code, thanks everyone! https://www.talkable.com/x/1I9r3T

  593. I just ordered my first pair and am really excited to get them. Everyone I know who has them say they are great and really comfortable.

    I was able to use a code for $20 off my pair. Here is a code if you need one.

    https://www.talkable.com/x/5Mw85x

  594. I finally made the decision to purchase the point in merrygold. What a beautiful and fun color for spring. No break in required for me and I also did not order a size up and the fit is perfect. $20 off coupon below.

    https://www.talkable.com/x/ry0oix

  595. I have been thinking for a while of buying them. Finally did. Thank you for the review. I just got the slate metallic point. I might need to break in heel part, but otherwise the shoes feels comfy and stretchy. Here is my code if anyone needs them.

    https://www.talkable.com/x/Z8fhpI

  599. Even if you don’t have wide feet, it’s worth going up a half size for the Point. I like Dr. Scholls insoles layered on top of the Rothys insoles and that also helps with the fit. Usually I destroy the toes of my shoes but these are so easy to wear, and low-maintenance!

    Fresh code: https://www.talkable.com/x/1I9r3T

  602. Quick update! I originally ordered The Point – Marigold in a size up (6.5) but was worried if they stretched they would be too big. I ended up placing an order for The Point – Dark Camo in a size 6 to test the difference. Final verdict is that the 6 (my normal size) definitely feels too small. I will be exchanging those for a 6.5. I did however notice that if a double up the insoles the size 6.5 is now perfect. It also adds a little extra cushion. If you are like me and slightly between sizes, try that trick. Rothy’s sells extra insoles for $10.

    Thanks again to everyone for sharing their feedback. It has been super helpful and the $20 off links really do work!
    https://www.talkable.com/x/QW8rq6

  606. Thank you so much for this review! I’ve been on the fence for months, but this honest review was hugely helpful. I bought the pointed toe in Heather Taupe and love them. I have normal width feet, and wear between a 7.5 and an 8. I went with the 8 and they’re perfect. If anyone needs a $20 off referral code, you can use mine: https://www.talkable.com/x/d47NOm

  607. I have 3 pair now and everything about them is great. Delivered in like 3 days, easy returns (the box is ready for it), eco-friendly, and COMFY! Plus, washable. After teaching all day, they dry out overnight and are ready again the next day! Def worth the money.

    Fresh $20 off code here:
    https://www.talkable.com/x/CYRN1U

  626. I’d Echo Katie’s comment below. I ordered two pairs, one pointy and one round. I followed others’ advice and went up a half size up for the pointy flats. But now that I’m trying them both on I think the pointys are too big! I’d caveat the advice to go up a half size to only apply to people with wide feet. If you don’t have wide feet, don’t go up a half size!

    $20 off promo code: https://www.talkable.com/x/BLoZt1

  627. Quick update – my pair of The Point arrived and they feel comfortable but potentially a tad too big. I ordered a half a size up based on other reviews. I am placed an order for a size smaller to compare. Either way – they are so comfortable! I can already tell that I love them.

    Paying it forward with the $20 off coupon link:
    https://www.talkable.com/x/O1IZn0

  639. I’m in love with these shoes. Thanks ladies for the code Louise! Wanted to share a fresh code if anyone needs one. Rothy’s only allows you to use a code once now so I had to try a few to get a good one.

    2. Thanks for reviewing because I was on the fence. I have wide feet and most flats are too narrow. I usually wear an 8.5 but I ordered a 9 because the site says to order a size up for wider feet. Can’t wait to try them out!

      $20 off code: https://www.talkable.com/x/I6DvmT

  668. I got another pair or Rothys in the mail today! I have a problem…Anyhow, I have decided I like the subtle patterned ones better than the solid colors. The solids are the same price and the patterns just give a more upscale look and are more unique. Do you guys like the solid or patterns better? Any patterns to stay away from?

    Here’s a link for $20 OFF that works! Just tested today. https://www.talkable.com/x/GZRGtv

  671. I put my first pair to the test and wore them for the entire day. Lots of walking, client meetings and finishing with a gathering. Super comfortable! No blisters at all. I’m so impressed, I just ordered my second pair.

    Here is a current code for $20 off your first pair if you need one.
    https://www.talkable.com/x/FW3esk

  674. I just bought 3 pair for my upcoming trip to France. Now I can be stylish (and blend in while in Paris) but still have comfy feet! I will report back with more feedback after my vacation. I like the pointy ones best; they will go with almost anything and are super lightweight for packing.

    Here’s a current link for $20 off your first purchase: https://www.talkable.com/x/tcwPzJ

    1. Thank you all! I really appreciate everyone’s reviews and feedback. I have been thinking about buying a pair for ages. All the info here finally gave me the confidence to splurge on a pair. I ordered The Point in marigold. I will be sure to update the group once I receive my new shoes. They should be here in a week — can’t wait!

      https://www.talkable.com/x/LAAmrk

      1. I’ve just ordered The Point in Marigold too! The fabric is soo comfy, but I think maybe I need to order half a size up from my usual size, as it’s tight in the toes. Just curious if you noticed a similar issue?

  681. Thank you so much for your review! I have purchased 3 pairs now and love them all, I literally don’t wear much else. As a teacher comfort is so important, but no one wants to look like they are wearing old lady shoes. Stylish and comfortable, win win!!! I now have my own code and would love to share with others, you won’t regret this purchase: https://www.talkable.com/x/QliyVk

  682. I had to exchange my flats to tight on the toe but I run 51/2-6 in all shoes tried 51/2 because I didn’t want it to slide cant wait for my 6 to get here! I love them and want to wear them now! They fit great and sooo comfortable!

    Here is a new code if you need one!

    https://www.talkable.com/x/nKvhNy

  683. I now own two flats and one point. I find myself reaching for the rounds more often for comfort sake. When I am not wearing Rothy’s I wear minimalist/barefoot shoes (Lems, Merrell,VivoBarefoot) so I prefer shoes with a wide toe box. That’s a tall order with flats but Rothy’s do wonderfully in all the styles. However, if you are stuck between getting the point or flat go with the flat. They dress up nicely and are supremely comfortable! Here’s a $20 off nudge!

    https://www.talkable.com/x/1StpXv

  691. I’ve been looking at these for months, and after reading your blog decided to pull the trigger. Just ordered and don’t have them yet, but went with the pointed toe. Here is my coupon for someone else https://www.talkable.com/x/Z3Kinw.

    Exited to get them!

  692. My daughter bought a few pair of Rothy’s and after trying on her shoes and seeing how comfortable they are, I decided to buy my own. I love the new loafer style. I think they are even more comfortable than the pointed toe ones. Here’s a link where you can get $20 off your first purchase. I’m paying it forward.

    https://www.talkable.com/x/zbYk1q

  694. I’m generally an 8.5, with very few exceptions. In fact, I can’t think of any exceptions off the top of my head. So, I ordered a pair of The Point and a pair of The Loafer, both in an 8.5. The Loafer fit great, and feels amazing. (I’m wearing them with PJs right now to keep my feet warm.) The Point, meanwhile, felt way too narrow when I tried them on (even though I’ve never thought of my feet as particularly wide). So, they’re going back and I’m going to try the 9. Hope that does that trick!

    There should still be a few uses left on my code ($20 for you, and $20 for me) if you’d like it use it: https://www.talkable.com/x/Ul4JG7

  696. Recently got my first pair using a discount code from these comments (thanks everyone for sharing!) Bought The Flat in my regular size and it was a perfect fit. These are the most comfortable flats I have ever owned! They are definitely my new favorite! Here’s my code for anyone who might be interested:
    https://www.talkable.com/x/dSVSCs

  697. Here’s a code for $20 off: https://www.talkable.com/x/MYdMSk

    These are nice shoes, and versatile. Like some other reviews here, I found that my first pair (the flats) were a little small. I’m normally a size 9, but ended up having to return for a half size up. The return process was a bit slow and customer service had a delayed response when I asked for a tracking number, but I did receive my exchanged pair, and I really like the fit. Hopefully my review helps others to avoid the same hassle. Order a half size up!

  700. Thank you so much for your review! I have purchased 3 pairs now and love them all, I literally don’t wear much else. As a teacher comfort is so important, but no one wants to look like they are wearing old lady shoes. Stylish and comfortable, win win!!! I now have my own code and would love to share with others, you won’t regret this purchase: https://www.talkable.com/x/QliyVk

    1. I was hoping to find a teacher’s review! I have a pair of Tieks. They’re much more comfortable than any $30 flats I’ve found. Even though Rothy’s aren’t much cheaper, I cringe at spending $175 on flats, no matter how cute their box and flower-bow are!!

  701. I was a long time wearer of tieks (I have 10 pairs!). I loved them but hated breaking them in. I tried rothys on the advice of a friend and love them more than tieks. There is no break in period with rothys. They are comfortable right out of the box. I am able to wear an insole and/or arch supports with them unlike with tieks. I would argue they are cuter. I do appreciate the leather on tieks but can’t argue with the sustainability of the rothys.

    Please feel free to use my code 🙂 https://www.talkable.com/x/VVCiRK

  702. I am sharing yet another discount code. I bought my first pair of pointed toe Rothys after reading this review. I have severe foot issues as I have rheumatoid arthritis, and usually resort to orthotic shoes with built-up arch support. I’m happy to say that these flats are so flexible that they don’t irritate my many bumps-and-lumps in the joints of my toe and alongside my foot, which usually require me to wear shoes that appear to have been designed by Frankenstein. I do insert a small arch support, but the weave of the shoe do not loosen up too much, and yields just enough to allow me to walk in comfort. SO: here’s another code from my last purchase: https://www.talkable.com/x/2CL9JI

  703. I just got my first pair of Rothy’s and I love how comfortable they are! The material really confirms to the shape of your foot instead of having to conform you foot to the shape of the shoe. I usually have trouble with pointy toe shoes, but there is enough give in the fabric for it to remain comfortable. Plus, they are machine washable! HELLO AWESOME! Here’s a code to get $20 off:
    https://www.talkable.com/x/7Ssp1G

  704. I’m trying some! Thanks for the discount code. Here is another discount code: FRIEND-X5BMU3.

  705. I don’t buy into the hype very often but after all the good reviews and a desperate need for flats that won’t give me blisters wearing them sockless in the summer, mine are on the way.

    Here’s my code for anyone that needs it: https://www.talkable.com/x/7yn2Vb

  706. I just got my first pair (and found a new favorite blogger, thanks Allie!). The shoes are great. I go between an 8 and an 8.5 depending on the brand and I’m definitely an 8.5 in these. Thanks to everyone for the discount code. Here’s another one!

    https://www.talkable.com/x/7yn2Vb

  707. My shoe loving hair dresser was the first one to tell me about Rothy flats. To be honest before I even looked into them I was sold at “machine washable”. I ordered my usual 8.5 in black and am so pleased. I can’t wait to get another pair. Thanks for the code! Here’s another one for you fine ladies! https://www.talkable.com/x/JCU4vI

  708. I received my first pair of Rothy’s (pointed toe, Marigold) and it’s a perfect fit! The packaging is compact and entirely recyclable. I LOVE this company! And because I shared a discount code, I received enough responses that I could afford to buy a second pair (Chili Red.) Here’s a discount code for you to use – please share and spread the joy! https://www.talkable.com/x/N7u0Qh

  715. I am in love with my black points. I ordered a half size up, which I normally need to do for points, and they fit great. I usually get hot spots on the heel and need inserts, but not with these. They hit at a good point in the heel so I don’t need the extra lift.

    Sharing the love so others can enjoy https://www.talkable.com/x/CAyA5n

  720. I ordered sz 8 (my usual size) loafers for my gnarly, arthritic, hard to fit feet. I usually need a roomy toe box for shoes to have a chance of being wearable. These are great! After removing the Rothy’s sole insert, there’s plenty of room for my full length orthotic insert. The heel doesn’t slip, nor does it come up so high that it rubs. I’ve worn the loafers without socks and with little no-show socks. I’m ordering another pair.

    Here’s a $20 discount code. https://www.talkable.com/x/SpBOEo

    1. I received the loafers I ordered. They are interesting. I generally have issues with ballet flats or any shoe without at least a small lift in the heel so I’ll need to see if these will work for me. I may try to put an insert in to see if that works. They also hit a little high on the back of the heel but I haven’t worn them enough to see if that’ll be an issue.

      https://www.talkable.com/x/I8IKuv

  731. Update: I had to exchange my Point Rothy’s for a smaller size. The heel kept rubbing from them being too loose. The exchange process online was super easy and they give you a return label right away. Can’t wait to get them back. The style is super cute!

    You can get $20 off your first order here: https://www.talkable.com/x/iRGbsr

    1. I just got my Rothy’s pointy toe. True to size with a narrow foot. They are nice and comfortable. It reminds of jeans that have a nice stretch fabric. I would size up if you have a wider foot for the pointy toe style. Use my code if you want to get a discount: https://www.talkable.com/x/g45hsI

  736. They are so comfortable. I returned the first pair…not a fan of all the toe cleavage. I ordered the loafers. I love the material! Thank you so much again for your review! Paying it forward with a discount code for $20 off! https://www.talkable.com/x/ysUe9g

  740. Here’s a code for $20 off for anyone needing it: https://www.talkable.com/x/H6CcQr

    Thank you for the helpful article! I’ve ordered the pointed flat in black, size 7.5. I have a wider foot, so once they arrive I’ll follow-up with a sizing review.

  748. Great review. You really helped me make a decision. I was a little worried ordering and the first pair had to be returned for a different size. I just received and they fit better. Looking forward to pairing them with my work attire. I just got 2 more pairs! For those looking to get $20 off their first purchase .. here is a new link: https://www.talkable.com/x/OGrH76 Sharing is always worth it!

  751. UPDATE: My size 8 emerald points arrived and even though I was worried (I have sweaty, weird feet that swell up, attractive, right?) but these made my feet look good. And even better – they feel good! I’ve been wearing them around the house to make sure none of those surprise pain points pop up and so far they are PERFECT! Here’s a link for $20 off your first pair: https://www.talkable.com/x/JeD02s

  759. Thanks for the $20 ladies!
    I got the flat in berry color block in an 8, my usual shoe size. Perfect! I had to go up a half size (8.5) in the point, the merigold is such a beautiful pop of color without being obnoxious! I’ve got regular width feet and don’t wear any insole.
    Sharing my code too!
    https://www.talkable.com/x/eOpy1s

  784. Hi Allie – how did the sole hold up to all the walking around? They seem thin to survive through constant walking trips like you describe. Would the sole hold up to similar trips around NYC every weekend? A picture would be super helpful if that’s possible.

  786. Here’s my code if someone else’s does not work so you can get $20 off! https://www.talkable.com/x/PzvZkA

    Thanks for the great review Allie. Your info helped me decide to try these shoes. While I love the soles of the Tieks better the heels on these fit perfectly with no pain from the elastic like on the Tieks. I had to wash mine once already and haven’t had any problems. I find myself only wearing clothes to work that I can match with my Rothy’s. I just wish they had a brown.

    1. Thanks for the link Ashley! I usually wear EEE width, but have a normal heel–so finding flats that fit the width without flopping off my heel is difficult. Fingers crossed that these work! Here’s a code for someone to use: https://www.talkable.com/x/M5JwZg

  792. Great review! I’ve been watching these for a while and would like to try them. I travel a lot and they seem perfect for that. Just can’t decide on a color!! I wear black 99% of the time so may start there. Do you have another code?

    1. Hi,
      I ordered a pair before finding a code. Can someone give me a code and the email associated with that code. Just service needs both of that info

      2. Found your site by accident, glad I did. I was researching Rothy’s shoes and you gave a great review.
        I would love to take advantage of the the discount code if still available. Thanks!

  796. Hello! Thank you for the review. I was just about to purchase these and I’m happy I found your review! If you happen to have a referral code, if so I would love it thanks

  798. Great review. How would these shoes do over cobblestone surfaces like one finds in European cities. Are the soles thick enough to handle a person’s weight on the cobblestones?

    1. You may want a more solid shoe. These soles aren’t super thick, the thickest point is at the heel and it’s a little less than a half inch. At the arch and down it goes to about a quarter inch thickness.

  799. I’m interested in trying the shoes. I tried a few links but they’re not working for me. Thanks for any help.

  800. Hello! I was just about to purchase these and I’m happy I found your review! If you happen to have a referral code I would love it thanks!

  801. Hello!
    Thank you for this review! I have wide feet and usually wear 6.5 in wide when I can (or 7 when there’s no wide), so I will give the 6.5 a try because of the stretch.

    Is there a link/code that I may use from you? I know you had said they change often. Thank you again!

  803. Just ordered mine and immediately got this link to share for someone to get $20 off. Hope it works for someone. I love my pointed toes and now I’m going to try the rounded.

  805. I quickly read thru comments and didn’t see anyone address what pushed me over the edge to try Rothy’s. Unlike Tieks, you can successfully place orthotics into Rothy’s! What?! I received my rounds last week and after removing the insole, I placed my orthotics in them and they’re terrific! The test will be in two weeks when I wear them in Paris and London.

    FYI-yes, the referral codes are only for a limited time, because, hey…they want to make money too and not give away free shoes because 20 people have used one person’s referral code. There’s a great FB group for questions and independent swapping, ISO, and selling of gently worn Rothy’s.

    2. Hi Jill,

      Wondering how your Rothys held up in Paris and London? I’m thinking of purchasing a pair for my trip to Paris and London in a few weeks. Thanks.

    3. Thanks for the orthotics comments. Are your orthotics hard or flexible? Are the full length or 3/4?

  806. This link isn’t working for me! Do you have another? I tried all of the ones posted

  808. I’m wondering if any of your readers with super slim/narrow feet have tried them? I typically wear a 10 and own almost no shoes because I cant get a good fit. I fear that in a sizzle that large, they will just gap on top and slip. Any thoughts?

  809. I have been curious about these shoes so the comments are very helpful. I read a trick that helps with summer shoe “smell”. After washing, place the shoes in a sealed plastic bag and put them in the freezer overnight. The cold is supposed to kill the bacteria that causes the smell. It worked for me with a favorite paid of canvas shoes.

  810. I have a size 6 or 6.5 foot — depending on the shoe. I ordered both sizes in Rothys rounded toe shoes and was sooo disappointed. My big toe felt like it was really sticking out — to close to the end on the size 6 Wine colored shoe that I ordered so I ordered a 6.5 in the same color. The 6.5 felt like it was as 7.5 — it was at least an inch larger than the size 6.

    That being said they do seem to be more comfortable than Tieks — I have a size 6 in them. I cannont weat them all day. My foot is screaming because the shoe is so tight by the time I have gotten four-five hours into the day.H However, I paid a lot of money for the shoes so I will continue to wear them for short periods as long as they last.

  811. Thanks for the review! I’d love to use your referral link but don’t see one that works. Do you still have a link? I’ve found other referral links out there but would love to give the referral to you. 🙂

          1. Thank you so much for responding! That one worked and I placed my order! I have a pair of black Toms that need to be retired and I hope that the cherry ribbon stripe flat will be a good (and more polished) replacement.

  812. My Rothy’s SHRUNK when I washed them! I followed the care instructions and now my size 9.5 shoes fit like an 8 at best. I’m furious, their customer service has been non existant, and there’s no option to leave a review on their website. Sneaky! Now I’m $145 in the hole for a pair of unwearable shoes. BEWARE!

    1. Oh no that’s awful! Mine haven’t shrunk, I’m sad they haven’t responded. The only way I got a response was by contacting them through their Twitter DM, if you have Twitter try that. Good luck!

  813. I have been dying to try these. I have the same problems with flats. Now I have a good excuse to buy and s good review.

  814. Sizing question – from the reviews I’ve read, most people seem to be sizing up with their Rothys. I just got mine and they feel a little big. I’m a solid size 11, and wear 11.5-12 in running shoes (I never size down). I have wide toes and a narrow heal, so flats often slip off and/or squish my pinky toe. I’m debating whether to exchange for a 10.5 or just wear them a bit to see if they snug up. Anybody have any experience with this?

    On the friend codes, got a message today that they changed the system. Old codes won’t work. Here’s what they sent me: https://www.talkable.com/x/hnmEeg

    1. Update: after wearing the shoes for an evening I decided to stick with my original size 11 pair and not size down. They ship with tissue and a plastic rod in them, which I think stretched them out. After awhile they seemed to regain their shape and fit better.

      I wore them all day yesterday, including biking to work in them. No heel slip and no odor issues. So far, so good.

  815. Ok so I have medium sweaty feet, and they only smell with flats, HOWEVER, a good pair of flats will only get smelly after maybe a month of continuous wear, did these start smelling on the first day?? Love your honesty in the review by the way. I have been trying to find flats that don’t smell, Ross has a pair that I will buy no matter the color or style because they don’t smell!

    1. Hi there,

      Thanks so much for the code – it was the push I needed to try a pair! I’m looking forward to receiving my pair in a week – hooray for free shipping!

      Best,

      Meaghan

  817. Hi – My daughter is living in Taiwan for the next year. She walks a lot and I’m looking for a comfortable shoe for her that will also wear well in all of the rain they have. This sounds perfect. But, I want to make sure I’m ordering the right size for her since it wouldn’t be easy or even really possible for her to return them. She has a fairly narrow foot and normally wears a sz. 40 or a 9, but sometimes a 9.5. I’m looking at the round toe option. Would love your input / recommendation. Thanks!

    1. I would also consider the pointy style, but thought the round might be more comfortable? Thoughts?

    2. I’d likely go with the smaller size but I have wide feet and haven’t tried these on narrow feet so don’t consider what I write to be gospel.

  818. Hi! Thanks for this review! I’m trying to find an alternative to my current shoe-buying model (buy two pairs of $20-$30 flats once a year and then get frustrated when they get scuffed or stained and I can’t wash and wear them to work anymore because they look like garbage). I’m an elementary school teacher, so I spend A LOT of time on my feet and there are just a lot of ways that shoes can get stained. I’m wondering if you have continued to wear them a considerable amount and whether they’ve continued to wear and wash well. The price tag is too much for me if I’m just going to have the same experience I’ve been having with other shoes, but if they hold up well, it might be worth it.

    1. I have washed mine three times and they still look like new. The only issue I’ve found is washing seems to get the smell out until they heat up. I’ve read using vinegar and putting out in the sun but haven’t tried either yet. But dirt, mud, even paint have washed off these very easily!

  820. HELLO, IVE BEEN THINKING ABOUT TRYING THESE SHOES FOREVER AND YOUR REVIEW HAS ME CONVINCED! I AM TRYING TO USE YOUR PROMO CODE FOR $20 OFF BUT ITS NOT WORKING FOR ME…..DO YOU HAVE ANOTHER FRIEND CODE?

    1. Try this code and see if it works: THANKS-3W7SPMC my code in here worked earlier this week, I don’t know what happened, maybe they expire? Good luck!

  821. I spent $275 on Tieks and liked how cushy they were, but they did not hold up well. Since they don’t do half sizes and I normally wear a 6..5 or 7, I ordered the 7. So the heel kind of “broke down” and look terrible. When I told Tieks about it, the answer was, next time buy a 6.5. Really? No. Next time I will try the Rothy’s. Thanks for the review.

    1. So sorry to hear that about Tieks. I haven’t tried them, but do know Rothy’s is a completely different shape and design. Hope they work out for you!

  822. Allie, Thanks so much for this review! I’ve been on the fence for ~ a month and have been looking for solid reviews. Your sharing of your ‘friend’ code tipped the scales and I’m ordering two pairs today. Wish they would make the pointed loafer in black and add it to their permanent rotation! Thanks so much!

  823. Here’s a tip for those looking for a way to keep the sweat at bay…grab a pair of low cut, no-show athletic socks. Pull out the insole, and wrap it with the sock, elastic side down. You can cut back on the frequency of washing and not have to worry about no-show socks with your Rothy’s! No need for Geks–just unwrap the insole at the end of the day and repeat the process with a clean pair the next day.

  824. I just got the rounded toe flats in yesterday and I love them! I wore them all day today shopping and they were very comfortable. I actually first tried them on 2 months ago when I was visiting my sister. I have wide feet, and normally wear a size 10 (I can sometimes do a 9.5 if it’s wide enough). I ordered 10.5 and they fit great. My big toe is rubbing some on the sides, but even after wearing them one day they seem to be stretching to my feet.

    I want to try the pointed toes because they look so cute, but I’m super worried that they will crowd my toes being that I have wide feet. I’m not sure if I should try a 10.5 or an 11. I sometimes have to size up to 11 in regular width shoes but they tend to be to long and my feet slide around, which tends to hurt after awhile. So sizing up makes me a little nervous.

    I’m debating just ordering a 10.5 and an 11 and then returning whichever doesn’t fit, but that’d be almost $300 at once.

    Thoughts??

    1. I also have a wide foot with bunions and wondered if I would need a larger size for the pointef toe? Because of my bunions, I have moved up from a 6.5 to a 7 anyhow. Thought?

      1. I’m not sure, I find them super stretchy and no hot spots but I don’t have bunions. But I have extremely wide feet and didn’t size up for these because of the stretch.

    2. I have super wide feet (like Sam Edelman’s wides aren’t wide enough for me) and I went with jay regular size in the pointed and no issue. The shoes stretch a lot, so part of your foot may be wide than the sole, but your toes won’t be pinched.

  825. Pingback: What I Wore: Weekend Warrior - Wardrobe Oxygen

  826. Hello! I just got my Rothy’s this weekend and am excited to give them a go. Question… do you feel the insoles were rough on the bottoms of your feet at all? I am worried about getting hot spots.

    2. I have 4 pairs of tieks and LOVE them! They are very comfortable and I can wear them for HOURS!

      1. I bought a pair of Tieks after all the great reviews, but I was not impressed at all. I’m afraid these will be the same.

        1. I bought tieks and absolutely hated them. They were so uncomfortable to me. But I love my Rothys!! Just bought my first pair and it won’t be my last

  828. Love the honest review and the style options you propose. Would love a pair, but seems they don’t ship to Europe 🙁

  829. These look great on you, but I have to say they are the smelliest shoes I have ever encountered–something I’ve never had a problem with! The washable shoe is totally fine, but the INSOLES are a nightmare. I can’t seem to remove the stench. I am so sad because the shoes fit so well and were quite pricey.

  830. I’ve been eyeing these, and your unpaid opinion convinced me to give them a try. I got the red pointy and am excited to receive them and see if they work for my wonky feet. Used your code, so thank you for the $20 discount! I appreciate it!

      1. So helpful to see authentic reviews on comfortable (and presentable) shoes for wide feet. Thank you!

  831. So I bought a pair of Rothy’s last year for our big convention since I walk MILES every day. Love them and love that I can wash them because I get stinky feet. I do have high arches so I don’t need the extra support. My sisters bought me a pair of Tieks for my birthday, you may want to give those a try for more support. Just a suggestion.

      1. I had Tieks before Rothy’s and I feel like they ultimately have less support somehow. While the foldability is nice, I experienced more hot spots when doing a lot of walking with them.

        I also found I always felt frumpy in the Tieks. The Rothy points make even yoga pants look put together. I also have a limited edition pair of the loafers (green plaid round toe). Next on my list Marigold and Cherry.

  832. Pingback: What I Wore: Sequins - Wardrobe Oxygen

  834. Thank you for the thorough testing and review! I have seen so many ads for them, I love the sustainability factor.

  835. I’ve been waiting for this review & I’m so excited to read this! The shoes sound really great & now I’m wanting to order a pair of my own. That leopard pair is so tempting…Why did I just order some loafers from DSW the other day?? Those may be going back. Thanks for being honest with us about the shoes. Your reviews are always a great read but it’s just especially nice to know we’re getting the truth from you.

  836. I had never even considered these because of my wide feet – now I shall! My feet were killing me after 8 hours in normal flats yesterday. Stupid pinkie toe.

  837. I got myself a pair a few months ago and love them, however they have pretty much zero padding on the bottom. It is nearly like walking barefoot in terms of cushion. But they are really cute and comfortable otherwise.

  839. I recommend to size down if you aren’t sure or are between sizes, even if you’d size up in another brand in this style. I bought a round toe pair a couple of months ago. I have worn them A LOT. I usually wear an 8, or through the last few years an 8 1/2, which is what I got in these. I have an average width foot. Over the weekend I ended up ordering an 8. I don’t think they stretched, I think even the first time I tried them on I wondered if an 8 would be better. Every time I would wear them I would wish I had the smaller size but was “ok” in them anyway. So, i finally did it.If I need to let you know otherwise when they come in, I will update.

  840. I have bugged them to make them in a 12. I gather these fit as expected, rather than larger than expected, so an 11 is probably too small for me….darn it

      1. I recently got measured (Morton’s neuromas are nasty, and tight shoes the cause) and since they didn’t have the 12 Brooks in stock, they put me in a 10.5 men’s–with an orthotic, it’s basically the same. Since Rothy’s are orthotic friendly, how’s about a nice “fashion sneaker” oxford that both women and men with at least normal sized feet could both wear? Poor Karl, though…he has big feet, right? I would totally wear a Rothy’s sneaker

        2. Tell more about “orthotics friendly”. I have prescription orthotics in chunky leather shoes – looking for something that can take my orthotics and still look delicate.

  842. I’m so glad that you did this – I’ve been so tempted by these lately, but I’ve also been having horrid foot problems, so I was reluctant. I think I might take the plunge – I trust your assessment and judgment completely!
    big hugs,
    Janice

      1. I tried putting my own Smart Feet thin insoles in them and they took up too much space and fell off my feet. Same with another kind of insole. I’d love to know what brand/style does fit and still keeps the shoe on.

        1. On Facebook someone mentioned Dr. Scholl’s. I know I have a pair of gel ones from them that are super thin and only the arch has a bit of depth. I haven’t tried them in my Rothy’s, only slim boots. Curious to see how they work.

Comments are closed.