This article may contain affiliate links; if you click on a shopping link and make a purchase I may receive a commission. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Beauty products are fun. It’s always exciting to tear open your bag from CVS, Ulta, or that box from Sephora and play with your new stash of goodies. I have a drawer in my dressing table, and each morning when I open it, I feel as though I am looking at a toy chest. Will I do a smoky eye today? A flushed cheek? Maybe just a lip stain. The options are endless!
If you feel this way, you probably also encounter what I often do – buyer’s remorse. That metallic teal liner that you have never worn, a foundation that the folks on Makeup Alley say is near-Holy Grail but makes your skin look sallow, a moisturizer that made you break out, a curl defining cream that make you look as though you instead bought a Jheri Curl.
When I find an item that not only is used to completion but deserves to be re-purchased, it’s a time to celebrate. Below are items that I have either recently re-purchased, or purchased and love so much, I know I will be buying a replacement as soon as this one is empty!
Ole Henriksen Pure Perfection Night Crème
A couple months ago, I purchased some almond oil after reading online that it can help condition and strengthen lashes. I applied it at night, and one night I applied it all over my face in place of regular night cream. I went to bed with a greasy face, but woke up with soft, plump, happy skin. I decided to make a switch from my meh night cream (freebie blogger swag not worth mentioning) to almond oil.
As the weather got colder and dryer and more mean, the almond oil wasn’t cutting it. I was getting the dry irritated skin under my nose, waking up with a tight face, and my skin looked a bit haggard. Right when I was losing the almond oil love, I read this post on Capitol Hill Style. As soon as I finished the post, I ordered myself a tub of Ole Henriksen's Pure Perfection Night Crème. As that I ordered it on Amazon and have Prime, it arrived two days later.
I have been using this cream since Christmas Eve and have seen a marked improvement in my skin. When I wake my face doesn’t feel greasy, nor is it tight. The red, dry, irritated winter skin I get under my nose and around my mouth is history. My skin feels soft, and has a nice glow to it that is unusual to see during the coldest and darkest part of the year. No breakouts, no irritation, just happy comfortable skin that looks a bit more youthful.
The formula is thick, but not heavy. A little goes a long way, so I will have this orange tub in my medicine cabinet for many months before it needs a replacement. It is to be used on the entire face – even the eye area (recommends Ole Henriksen’s eye cream OVER it, five minutes after application of the night cream – I am using up the eye cream I currently have). So far, so good. This is my first time trying Ole Henriksen’s line but after this experience, it won’t be my last.
Roc Retinol Correxion Deep Wrinkle Daily Moisturizer – SPF 30
When I ordered the Ole Henriksen night cream, Amazon suggested I also try this moisturizer for daytime. I hate to admit this, but I have been living off trial-sized moisturizers that I have gotten as swag, samples with my Drugstore.com and Sephora orders, etc. I know Roc gets pretty good reviews for having a good concentration of retinol, and I loved that it was SPF 30. What the heck, I added it to my Amazon order.
I really like this cream. It’s thick, but it soaks in well if you take your time. A dab on the forehead spread around, a dab on each cheek, a dab on the chin, some for the neck and décolleté and blend in. After just a couple minutes, it is soaked in and you can apply your makeup without issues.
Since I started using the Roc moisturizer the day after starting the Ole Henriksen cream, I can’t really tell how much of an impact it is making. My skin feels more hydrated than it was with my other random moisturizers, yet my makeup doesn’t slide off my face. No breakouts, no irritation, no redness. I think my skin looks better than it did a couple weeks ago, but again not sure if it’s the night cream, this moisturizer, a combination of the two, the removal of holiday stress, or just using a new regimen. Even if the retinol isn’t helping with dark spots, dryness, and wrinkles, the moisturizer is a wonderful consistency and seems to agree with my face more than any other moisturizer I have used. It feels luxe, as though it would cost much more and not be a drugstore brand.
Almay Smart Shade Anti-aging Makeup SPF 15
I bought this in June on a whim. Loved it. You can read my original review here. When my tube ran out, I bought another. And last month, I purchased my third tube ( I wear Light/Medium year round).
This foundation really does change to match your skin perfectly. If you don’t blend well you may end up with weird little tan streaks, but I use very little and blend well and it completely disappears, evening out my skin better than any tinted moisturizer, but doesn’t give as heavy of coverage as a traditional foundation. It sits right between both types of products, doesn’t irritate my contacts-wearing eyes, wears well all day, doesn’t cause breakouts and I can practically apply it with my eyes closed and know it will look great.
Laura Mercier Secret Camouflage
This is my Holy Grail of concealer. Other brands need not apply. I tried Laura Mercier concealer for the first time when I bought her Flawless Face Kit. I loved everything in the kit, but OBSESSED over the amazing concealer. Before I even finished the travel sizes in the kit, I bought myself a full-sized version of the Secret Camouflage.
I wear SC2 – it is one shade a bit lighter than my complexion, one a bit darker and more yellow. I can mix them together for a custom color – I use the light around my eyes to cover dark circles and it blends great, doesn’t tug at my skin, doesn’t look ashy, and really helps hide most anything. The darker color is great for covering zits, redness around the nostrils and these weird little stretch mark-like thingies at the edges of my lips. I use my ring finger so it warms the concealer and makes it easier to blend, but I have also used a small brush to tap a little concealer on a blemish and make it hide well under foundation. When I have time and it’s a special event, I will use my Laura Mercier concealer brush to lightly apply and layer the Secret Camouflage and this will give really amazing coverage without looking obvious.
I am almost finished with my second compact of Secret Camouflage (first one purchased early on in pregnancy with Emerson – a compact lasts over a year) and am tempted to buy another already so that I can have one in my purse for post-work touchups. When people comment on how rested or young or fresh I look, I always tell them it’s thanks to Laura Mercier!
I have tried Maybelline Great Lash and don’t get the hype – it separates and doesn’t clump but it hardly makes any impact. Lancome Defincils isn’t bad, but it’s nothing to write home about. Benefit Bad Gal is meh. Tried tubing my lashes with Blinc Kiss Me and wasn’t a fan. Tried Lash Blast, Voluminous, 2000 Calorie, Falsies and found them good, but not great.
I want lashes that stand out. I want them thick, lush, dark, long, luscious. Even for day, I want my lashes to make some impact.
I buy the newest “sooo amazing, like false lashes!” mascara… and then I go back to DiorShow. DiorShow is expensive, and I can’t just pick it up my next time to the grocery store or Target. A tube of DiorShow doesn’t last as long as other brands – it seems to dry up faster. It has a pretty strong rose scent – not an awful scent, but I prefer my makeup to smell like a whole lot of nothing.
However it goes on great – no flaking, no clumping, no irritating my allergy-prone and contacts-wearing eyes. It’s thick, coats each lash, makes them really thick and gorgeous while separating and elongating. It wears all day and gives me the look I crave.
DiorShow is worth it. I do balance it out by using a drugstore brand for day (currently using Maybelline Falsies) and saving it for more special occasions, but I can’t find anything to replace or compare.
Revlon Colorstay 12 Hour Eyeshadow Quad in Neutral Khakis
This isn’t my second time buying this, or even my third. I am currently on my FIFTH palette in this exact color story. It really is THAT good.
The ivory shade is matte and makes the perfect highlighter. I apply it with my ring finger to my brow bone and inner eyes to make me look awake. The khaki has a gold sheen that is still very wearable during the day. It is an excellent basic lid color to be worn on its own or as a base for other colors. Wet it and it’s a brassy shade that is really fun for evening. The olive is extremely wearable and I have often done an olive smoky eye with this shadow. Again, wet it and it makes a more intense color (and can easily replace liner). The brown is a lovely chocolate with very little shimmer to it. When I lost my brow color on the Metro, I have been using this and think it’s a perfect fit. It also is a great color for contour and when wet, can replace a liner.
My standard day eye is with this palette. I apply the ivory with my finger to brow bone and inner eyes. I then use my Trish McEvoy Brush 45 to have a soft wash of the khaki over my lid. Trish McEvoy Brush 29 dips into the chocolate and I swish it back and forth into the crease of my lid and in the outer corner of my eye. Finally I take my Trish McEvoy Brush 41 and swipe the chocolate lightly along the lash lines. And then as mentioned, I also use Trish McEvoy Brush 32 to feather the chocolate into my brows to fill in the sparse parts.
The khaki color seems to crumble very easily and it is usually gone before any other color. However the rest of the palette is near-perfect, lasts until you hit metal, and the compact is well made and can handle being toted around in a bag without cracking or popping open. And finally, it really DOES last for 12 hours, even if you are like me and constantly rubbing and fiddling with your eyes. Major major win.
Trish McEvoy Brushes
I almost didn’t mention these because I have only purchased them once. But the sign of a quality makeup brush is that you DO only need to purchase it once, and you never lack for a different brush.
In 1998 I treated myself to a makeover at the Trish McEvoy counter in Nordstrom and went a bit buck-wild. I left with a ton of brushes. To this day, I still use every single brush they sold me. The brow brush is perfect – not too stiff, not too soft, fills in brows without leaving obvious lines. Brushes 45 and 29 are my LIFE – they will make cheap shadows look expensive and give the perfect wash of color (brush 29 seems custom made for the crease in my lid, though I have talked it up to friends who have also purchased it and feel it was actually custom made for THEIR eyes). The M20 Face Blender is a perfect blush brush that captures the apples of my cheeks without making me look like a Dolly Dingle Doll. Brush 11 is a great way to take a dark shadow and make it a liner – it really is able to wiggle into the lash line for a very clean, precise look.
The brushes are well shaped, feel good in the hand. The bristles are animal hair, and tightly clamped to the handle and never shed. I wash them with baby shampoo and let them air dry and 13 years later are still like new. Trish McEvoy makeup brushes aren’t cheap, but if you don’t need to purchase another brush for over a decade – it’s money well spent.
Frederic Fekkai Luscious Curls Cream
I am on my third tube, and that says a lot. Those of you with hair like mine probably have had medicine cabinets like mine overflowing with creams, pomades, sprays, gels, balms and lotions all claiming to be able to take limp wavy hair and make it into soft, shiny spirals. Many work… for a while. Most fail, making hair greasy and heavy, or crispy.
Frederic Fekkai’s Luscious Curls Cream succeeds IF I let me hair air dry. If I wash and condition my hair, apply a marble-sized dollop to my hair, scrunch and leave it alone, I end up with beachy waves and pretty spirals. The wave and curl lasts all day and often looks even better after a good night’s sleep. No heavy smell, no greasy locks, and surely no crunchy crispy ramen noodle locks.
However if I try to speed up the process with my hair dryer (even with diffuser and on low heat) I end up with really awful hair. It’s greasy, limp, frizzy, and looks as though I am Jon Bon Jovi circa 1984.
Neutrogena Body Oil
I am addicted to this stuff. I used it in high school, but soon switched for various creams and lotions and potions from popular college stores like The Body Shop and Bath and Body Works. When I graduated from scented lotions to actual perfumes, I switched to very general lotions from the drugstore (hello Lubriderm).
I believe pregnancy brought me back to Neutrogena Body Oil. My nose was extremely sensitive, and I had PUPPS causing me to seek ANYTHING that would stop the incessant itching. Neutrogena Body Oil has a very light fragrance (believe it is sesame but smells like honeysuckle to me) that doesn’t compete with my Burberry London, but still seems to calm me and make me feel fresh and feminine. The oil seeps into my skin beautifully and I get a bit of a Mandy Moore-like sheen. I glop it on and put on my terry robe and give it time to soak in and my skin is forever thankful.
Once I decided to try out the CVS brand. Ew. The fragrance is NOT the same. If I could get linen spray and candles in the scent of Neutrogena Body Oil, I would. It feels and acts and smells more luxe than you would expect from Neutrogena. The body says it is, “A sensual experience” and I would have to agree.
Dove Ultimate Beauty Care, Original Clean Deodorant and CertainDri
I don’t want to smell like a baby, a cucumber, a grapefruit. I don’t want to smell like someone else’s idea of energy or spirit. I also don’t want to smell like sweat. I sweat very easily, and need a product that will not only deodorize, but also slow down sweat production. I have so many brands of deodorants and antiperspirants – too many to count. I have found many work… for about two weeks and then stop. Many more irritate my skin. Almost all, once I get a bit warm start smelling so strong I get nauseous and it overpowers my perfume.
I finally found the perfect combination. Most nights (when I remember and am not too exhausted) I apply CertainDri. Then I use the classic Dove Deodorant in the morning. With this combination, I don’t smell, I don’t get red and bumpy (don’t use CertainDri after shaving), and I don’t smell like fruit, flowers, chemicals, or teen spirit.
Dove DOES have a smell, but it sort of reminds me of the scent of Neutrogena Body Oil – very light, fresh, feminine, subtle. I prefer it over the unscented version which I don’t think works as well and has a weird unscented sort of chemical smell.
As for CertainDri, it is the only thing I have found that really helps with sweat production. It doesn’t stop it all together, but it keeps me from having wet blouses and helps with odor. Sometimes it will sting a bit when applied, but that’s usually because I put it on too soon after shaving or showering, or it’s the end of the bottle and uber-concentrated. I have used it off and on for years without any issues, and especially find it a Godsend during humid sticky DC summers!
What products have you used and used and used again? Do you have any Holy Grail products that you just can’t live without?
Allie at Wardrobe Oxygen says
I have really liked L’Oreal True Match in the past – great quality, good coverage, tons of colors to choose from (I’m a C3)
We’re fairly isolated. Large geographic area with small population. What concealer can you recommend that can be purchased in CVS, Walgreen’s or Costco? Those are my choices for buying skin care products. I could buy online, but since it is makeup, I think I’d rather see it in person. How do I match my skin color? I have rather dark circles under my eyes and darkening on the nose skin next to my eyes.
You’ve convinced me to try the Neutrogena body oil which I’ve been thinking about anyway. I absolutely adore the Neutrogena shower gel which I first tried on our honeymoon almost 30 years ago. We stayed at the Royal Orleans hotel in New Orleans and that’s what they provided instead of bars of soap. I fell in love with the scent and even though I’ve switched to mostly all-natural/organic products, I’m not willing to give up the luscious scent of Neutrogena. My skin is so dry and itchy in the winter and I’m hopeful the oil will work as well for me as it has for you. I may also have to try the Curl Cream as it appears that we have very similar hair. I can (if it’s not too humid), carefully blow-dry and straighten my hair to achieve a sleek look but if scrunched while drying or allowed to dry naturally it is wavy. Thanks for sharing what works for you. Oh, and here is my tip. Baking soda mixed in coconut oil makes the BEST deodorant. It’s not an antiperspirant but it prevents odor better than anything I’ve tried. Cheap and natural, too.
I’m going to try the Almay makeup and the Revelon eyeshadow – thanks!
A suggestion for mascara: L’Oreal Double Extend. My lashes have gotten so puny over the years and this stuff is incredible.
Great list 🙂
My constant use/5-star favorites include:
Facial Moisturizer for Day: Nuxe Creme Fraiche, which I have been using for about 2 years. Eliminated the dry patches all winter, but still light enough for summer.
Foundation: Lancome Renergie Lift, after a long search (alternate, Make Up For Ever foundation)
Powder: Make Up For Ever Microfinish Powder
Blush: also cannot wear Orgasm, and have no good alternatives. Suggestions?
Perfume: Vintage Gardenia by Jo Malone, again 2 years
Lip Gloss: Sally Hansen Lip Inflation in Sheer Mocha
I LOVE these posts! It’s so helpful to know what things are working for other women.
Allie at Wardrobe Oxygen says
LOVE Tarte! And my sister too can’t wear Orgasm. Not sure which Nars she wears but it is like neon pink in the compact and a lovely flush on her cheeks.
Oooh the Balm sounds pretty lovely!
Thanks for all these suggestions!
Allie at Wardrobe Oxygen says
It’s pretty near perfect. I have other quads from the line and they are just as good quality but I haven’t found them to be as versatile.
Allie at Wardrobe Oxygen says
Oooh, may have to try it out after your review of it! Thank you!
Allie at Wardrobe Oxygen says
It really does well. If I apply with my finger it may melt away on a sweaty day, but if I apply with a brush and set with powder it will last through most anything!
Allie at Wardrobe Oxygen says
The CertainDri doesn’t, the Dove does a bit but not as bad as other brands. I usually put on, let it soak in before I dress. If you rub the deodorant with old hose, a black washcloth or even itself (rub with another piece of the garment) the deodorant will come off your clothes.
I use CertainDri only a few times a week & though I am allergic to a lot of deodorants & antiperspirants, not this one. I do get some burning if I use too often or have shaved, that’s about it. 🙂
I’m definitely going to try the Almay foundation and the Laura Mercier concealer. I just got a whole bunch of Bobbi Brown eye shadows as an Xmas gift, so I’m good on that front. Regarding the Certain Dri, I used it over the winter last year and loved it, but I really started to break out in the summer. Maybe I was using too much (my dermatologist told me to only use it twice a week after I stopped sweating so much). I’m going to go back to using it though because it really helped. Speaking of armpits, I was going to “Ask Allie” about it because I have a hard time with sleeveless black stuff because I used the white antiperspirant and it always gets all over everything. Does this combination you use get on your clothes at all?
My coloring is just like yours, so it is nice to hear recommendations that I know would match my skintone. Concealer seems to vanish on my skin. Does the Laura Mercier cover-up stay put?
Your post is making me want to head out to Sephora… pronto! lol
Big fan of the curl cream!!! Loooove it and def can’t live without it. I’m going to try the Trish McEvoy brushes. Thanks for the tips!
Hyperlash Mascara by Smashbox!!! Finally, a mascara that lasts all day, doesn’t flake, doesn’t rub off, doesn’t irritate my contact-wearing eyes, makes my eyelashes look like they go on for days, water-resistant but not water-proof, doesn’t clump when you use the brush/comb it comes with. I love this mascara. It’s pricier than the pharmacy but lasts forever and is WELL worth it.
Allie, maybe you should try it. Just about the same price as your Dior (a little less), but doesn’t dry out and lasts forever.
Barb Bergman says
Thanks for commenting on scents. I’m sensitive/picky — often have to reject otherwise good product because it’s over-perfumed.
Glad to hear I’m not the only gal to need a little something extra for anti-perspirant. Dove clinical strength has been working for me, but have been hesitant to over-use in case it stops working like so many others.
Although I love L’Occitane for my hand cream, for body lotion I keep coming back to Nivea – esp the “creme” that comes in container rather than a bottle.
Just started following your blog. Thanks for the reasonable fashion advice, I have woman curves and your style posts really help! My fav mascara is Maybelline Full n Soft, soft black in color and Waterproof. I have tried others and always go back to it. I cant wait to get the color eyeshadow quad you recommended.
April D says
Oh! And for aluminum-free deodorant, Tom’s of Maine 24-hour in Beautiful Earth smells wonderful, but very light, and works better than anything else I’ve tried. For certain fabrics on hot summer days, however, I still whip out Certain Dri. 🙂
April D says
What a fun post! My award winners:
Bronzer: Tarte in Park Ave Princess. LOVE.
Tinted moisturizer with SPF: Tarte’s Secret Agent–Perfect for girls who can’t tolerate chemical SPFs but don’t want to use physical blocks that leave you looking like a whitish purple clown. I’ve tested every non-chemical tinted sunblock I could find–this is “the one.”
Blush: NARS in Sin. Am I the only one who doesn’t look good in Orgasm? Must be. It makes my skin look ruddy. But Sin goes on my light olive skin beautifully.
Highlighter: The Balm Mary-Lou Manizer. I put this on the inner corners of my eyes, on top of my cheek bones, and in the bow of my upper lip. A makeup artist asked me how I got my skin to “glow,” and this, blended in with some Bare Minerals Clear Radiance, is my trick.
Lips: Burts Bees in Pomegranate, or Fresh in Rose SPF15 if going outdoors.
Eyeliner: I’ve tested every liquid eyeliner claiming to last and not smudge, but the only one that delivers for me is L’Oreal Lineur Intense. I also use a little on an angle brush, diluted to watercolor consistency, to fill in brows.
Hair: For my curly hair, I love Paul Mitchell’s Awapuhi Ginger line, esp. the shampoo, conditioner, and hair oil. Also use Paul Mitchell Round Trip (my hair takes forever to dry–this speeds it up). To conceal split ends I like Organix Nourishing Coconut Milk Split Ends Mender. Sometimes I just use it to make my hair smell like coconut–real coconut, too, like fresh coconut milk.
Lotion: Burts Bees Milk and Honey Body Lotion
Eye Cream: SUPER by Perricone Bright Eyed with Melon
Exfoliant: Fresh Soy Face Exfoliant
Ooh, I love recommendations! I am looking for a hair product to make my hair more bearable as I go through the last stages of growing it from pixie short to a chin length bob. And I will definitely give the Certain Dri a try when my current clinical strength stuff runs out.