To Skinny Jean or Not to Skinny Jean

A reader asked:

Skinny jeans seem to be EVERYWHERE!  Should I get myself a pair for my wardrobe?  Will I look dated if I stay with my bootleg denim?

I don’t believe in adhering to all trends. Trends are usually flashes in the pan – a suede fringe purse, a cabbage rose-printed sheath, a day-glo vinyl clutch – items that seem fun but end up collecting dust in your closet before the season has even completed.

Jeans are a wardrobe staple that constantly changes. Each season there is a new trend – embellishment, distressing, high waist, low waist, boyfriend cut, stovepipe cut, sailor cut. Nine times out of ten, that trend will be passé by the time the next issue of Vogue hits the newsstands. However the skinny jean has been sticking around for quite a while.

So should one go skinny?

In my wardrobe staples I mention jeans – the original list mentions a slight bootcut for the most universally flattering style. Well I must admit that my boocut jeans are getting less wear these days and I am preferring my straight leg jeans. Nothing tapered, nothing tight, but a straight leg that works better with the shoe silhouettes that are currently in style. Does this mean I am heading in the skinny jean direction?

For some, the skinny jean is a great addition to a wardrobe, keeping in mind that it IS a trend. I highly doubt that the skinny jean will prevail and five years from now not a single soul will be wearing a different cut of denim. However a skinny jean right now can be quite versatile and flattering on many women (and not just the tall lean ones modeling the skinny jeans in all your magazines).

Skinny Jean with Heels
This is a very hot look right now, as seen by On the Street looks of celebs and any contestant on American Idol. Pair skinny jeans (slightly long so they can gather a bit at the ankle) with a pump, strappy heeled shoe or even a sleek high-heeled bootie. On top, a popular choice is a floaty camisole with a boyfriend blazer or a slouchy knit top or sweater.

This is a look that can look very fresh, can elongate a woman’s leg and be very slimming. However it MUST be done properly or else it will look trampy or have the wearer look like a lollypop. A dark, even color and denim with some Lycra will give the best crisp look. Keep the shoes dark to have a continuous long line. Don’t have the top too short or it can look very top-heavy (and have your crotch be the focus of the whole look). The shoe needs to be on-trend as well. You can’t replace a platform pump with a black leather pump you wore to your job interview five years ago, or a funky open-toed bootie with a granny boot with low heel.

If you are curvy, this look can work for you, but make sure that the top you wear isn’t too bulky. This can easily go the way of the 1980s where women wore oversized sweater tunics, leggings and hi-top sneakers and looked half-naked and not attractive. A top of a jersey or silk knit or a well-cut blazer with lightweight tank can look great on a woman with curves. You just need to be very aware of proportion and fit to have it look flattering and stylish.

Skinny Jean with Flats
This is a look I associate with college students and recent grads. A skinny jean, a little flat in a fun color, a weathered tee advertising a band, and maybe a boyfriend cardigan. It’s a really cute look… on the young and the slim.

If you are not straight and slim, this look is not going to be flattering.  I hate to be the bearer of bad news, but it's true.  I see so many women of varying ages and sizes wearing this look and it rarely ever looks flattering or even trendy.

The flat shoe and the slim leg combination will shorten any figure, will make anyone look top-heavy, and again will give that horrible 1980s leggings/sweater tunic combo look if not done properly.

If you are straight and slim but not fresh out of undergrad, this look can work with a not-so-skinny jean (see below).

Skinny Jean with Tall Boots
This is the best way for most women to be able to carry off the skinny jean. In this look, the skinny jean works like leggings, but in a less naked/more stylish manner.

I see women wearing skinny jeans with almost any type of boot – from Uggs to sleek glossy black pointy heels to lace-up goth inspired boots to cowboy boots. The most flattering style is to lean towards a riding boot – something with a thicker heel, not too tight, not too sleek, a bit casual. A slouchy boot can also look pretty smart. The shorter the boot, the longer and leaner your legs need to be – a calf or ankle-height boot will cut off the line of the figure, making your body look shorter and wider. A boot that is near the knee will give the leanest and longest look. It doesn’t matter the color, though a light or bright colored boot will also cut the line and make you look shorter.

This look can work on most any figure, again depending on what you put on top. Too much weight and you can look top heavy, too lightweight of a top and you can look bottom heavy. Great options are a drapey cardigan with tank, a boatneck sweater (the wider neckline balances out the boots below), a trim blazer with camisole, a slouchy knit top with great drape.

Pretty much any other look with skinny jeans should be reserved to True Fashionistas and ‘tweens. Skinny jeans can easily look tartish or tacky. Keep them dark, keep them crisp, and keep the rest of your look balanced.

The Less-than Skinny Jean
For those (like me) who are still wary of the skinny jean, that doesn’t mean that you are stuck with bootcuts for all eternity. The new crop of straight jeans that are really flattering and give a similar concept to the skinny jean without being so… skinny. You can still get that lean, modern look without the worry of looking like a lollypop.

Pretty much any style mentioned above can be sported with a straight-leg jean. If the jean has a good amount of Lycra, it should even be able to be tucked into tall boots without looking like a swashbuckler by lunchtime (tip – tuck your pant legs into trouser or knee socks before putting on tall boots – this will keep the jeans from bunching at the knee as much).

Want to rock flats with jeans? A straight-leg jean is your best choice. A bootcut will make your feet look weirdly small and have your figure unbalanced; a skinny jean can make you look top heavy. A straight jean will give you a balanced look and still let you be comfy and cute in your flats.

As with the jeans in my original staples list, keep your jeans dark, crisp, well cut. Spend the money to have them altered to the right length, and baby them when laundering to keep the fabric and wash rich. Forego embellishments and fancy washes – these will go out of style much faster than whichever denim silhouette you choose.

11 Comments

  1. Michigan Patriot
    January 10, 2015 / 12:47 am

    Why do females as transvestites , have more fashion freedom options in historical menswear such as this equestrian style of slender pants tucked into tall boots ? Very sexist. Women wouldn’t put up with this situation if males were socially accepted as transvestites and had more fashion freedom within historical feminine women’s wear !

  2. Gobi Obi
    April 5, 2013 / 7:04 pm

    they look stupid on me, making me look like Henry 8th!!! I’m a goblet/upside down triangle shape with thin, long legs and flat bum, you need curves and a well proportioned body for these things, they look awful if your thighs and bum are big and awful if like me your big on top with skinny legs, I hate anything that shows how knobbly and bony my knees are and havn’t fallen into this trend yet nor will I. I wore them in the late 80s but I was thin all over them and we wore them with big T shirts and over sized men’s cardys.

  3. Anonymous
    April 2, 2010 / 5:37 am

    Thanks for the great post! I’ve always thought that skinny jeans with flats looks somehow “off” on most people, and your explanation about proportions really makes sense. Any suggestions for mid-level retailers for finding non-embellished, dark wash straight-leg jeans?

  4. March 8, 2010 / 2:19 am

    I personally will not be doing the skinny jean.

    1) I’m 34 and I am not trying to look 18 anymore

    2) I wear a size 20. I would look like a moron.

    I just bought my first pair of Svoboda trouser jeans and it was almost orgasmic! I have to hem them of course, but I’m in luuuuurve with them.

  5. March 1, 2010 / 12:51 am

    Great post — I too have been on the fence for a while.

    I really like Claire’s suggestion that you do a post about accessories. It really polishes a look, but I’m really unsure where to start.

  6. Anonymous
    February 28, 2010 / 10:35 am

    Hi Allie
    Here in the UK skinnies have been worn here for the last 5 or 6 years. I only wear them with long boots and tunics as am aware of the low rise waist. My stick thin 13 year old wears them with flats, ankle boots, or hi top converse. Always worn with t-shirts and boyfriend cardigans and scarfs.

  7. February 26, 2010 / 7:17 pm

    Hi Allie,
    recently i bought a pair of AE Slouchy Boots in black (i wanted brown ones but they were sold out in my size). i plan to wear the boots with dresses when the weather warms up. any suggestion what kind of dresses would look good with a pair of black suede slouchy boots?? if i were to wear it with my skinny jeans, what kind of top would look cute with it? (p/s: i’m in my 30s). thx. -evie-

  8. Claire
    February 26, 2010 / 10:21 am

    Oh, and Allie, it would be awesome if you could do a post on accessories- scarves, jewelery, bags, shoes, and how to choose them….(Please pretty please don’t recommend $3000 bags!)

  9. Claire
    February 26, 2010 / 10:16 am

    Love this post! I’m petite with athletic legs…so I’ll definitely pass on skinny jeans. Can’t stand the chicken leg effect on my legs. I don’t think Beyonce looks particularly good in the picture either. Why????? When there are a ways to make her body look fabulous??

    Like you, I do find myself going for narrower straight legs though.

  10. February 26, 2010 / 2:50 am

    This is such a helpful post!! Thanks so much — I have been on the fence with the skinny jean trend..but I might be convinced to get straight leg jeans.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.