Self-Tanning for Lazy Klutzes

Self-tanning for lazy klutzes - tips and products for a streak free and simple glow this summer

I may be a fashion blogger but that doesn’t mean I have my act together. I always have coffee spilled on my blouse, regularly end up with lipstick on my teeth, and my bruised legs tell the tale of how I am constantly walking into or tripping over things. I have tried so many self-tanners but I don’t have the patience to stand like a starfish waiting for it to dry, the control to get it on without streaks and orange feet, or the desire to spend the majority of my weekend perfecting a beauty routine. That being said, I like the look of being tan. For one, it helps hide all those bruises from being a klutz. I also like that I can get away with less makeup. No one needs to be tan, embracing your paleness is chic. You do you. But if you’re like me and would like a little color without spending your whole life on it and without getting orange and streaky, read on.

how to get a natural looking self tan at home

Heading to the pool a previous summer with a tan completely from a bottle

How to Get an Easy and Natural Self-Tan at Home

My process won’t make you look as though you spent your whole summer at the beach. It will give you a natural glow that lets you get away without blush and makes you feel more comfortable in shorts and skirts with bare legs. And it’s a process you want to start sooner rather than later. The key to a natural looking self-tan is to start light and gradually increase the intensity.

First Step: Exfoliate

You want a smooth canvas (your bod) for self-tanning. If not, dry spots will absorb more self-tanner, causing the tan to look uneven. And then those dry spots flake off leaving white skin underneath making you look even more uneven.

Sites will recommend all kinds of body scrubs or even offer recipes to make your own at home. I have no time or interest in anything that complex. Get yourself a skin towel. It’s like a giant washcloth but woven from the threads of a body pouf in a way that makes it super scratchy (scratchier than those exfoliating gloves). It’s big enough that you can grab each end and scrub your back. Use it in place of a body pouf or washcloth. This is the exact one I own. Squirt on some body wash and scrub the heck out of your skin, exfoliating while you’re washing without getting the bottom of the shower slippery from a sugar or salt scrub. Do this every shower; it not only will create a smoother canvas for streak-free tanning, it will make your skin glow and feel super soft.

I also recommend dry brushing. Do this in addition to the skin towel, not as an alternative. I’ve previously written about the benefits of dry brushing. I have this brush, it’s like $12. It’s a few minutes each morning to help exfoliate, increase circulation, reduce cellulite, and feel more awake. You’re welcome.

Second Step: Start Subtle

If you try to go St. Tropez in one weekend, you either need a lot of patience and control, or you’ll end up with dirty looking feet and streaky triceps. If you start now several weeks before Memorial Day weekend, you can build a fake tan that looks like the real thing.

I’ve been using Jergens Natural Glow for several years and find it to be the nicest for price, smell, and result. Also, there's no difference between the regular and the firming in regard to color.  I don't know if the firming actually firms but I buy it just in case. I start with the lightest color – light to medium. I apply it every other day through the month of April and then go up to every day until I complete the tube. Once the tube is complete, I can then either stick with this subtle glow or switch to the medium to dark option.

While Jergens gives me a very natural looking glow, it doesn’t offer a ton of hydration. If I put another moisturizer on too soon after applying the Jergens, the Jergens doesn’t seem to work as well. So every other shower, I instead add a few drops of Clarins tanning drops for body to my favorite body moisturizer. This, you need to be careful as it will streak. I add 3-4 drops to enough moisturizer for each limb. I then apply with my hands (no fancy mitt, I’m too lazy for that) but I make sure to spread it all over the leg or arm and then work on rubbing it in. I usually do a drop less for the arm than the leg because it’s easier to rub it in on the leg since you can see it and use both hands. Then another glop of moisturizer with only two drops for the rest of body, focusing on the chest and belly. Then immediately wash your hands; orange palms are not chic.  I then stay in an old towel or a dark-colored bathrobe as I brush my teeth, get ready otherwise and it's absorbed in time to put on clothes and head out.

I have tried these Clarins drops with a lotion and with an oil; I have not tried it with a cream or butter because I like to mix the two products together in my hand before applying and that just seems like a mess (and too much time on my hands, making it more likely to have terracotta palms).

I haven’t tried other tanning drops; I bought this one because a friend used it and swore by it and all the cheaper drops were sold out everywhere I went. I don’t know if all tanning drops are created equal, but Clarins gives me a nice tan, not orange shade. I only streaked once and it was a bit on my ankle/top of foot and it was my second use and I was being especially lazy about the whole process. I also got an orange spot on the palm of my hand that time; I learned to be super diligent about the hand washing after that.  FYI, if you're lazy and don't read the instructions, the way to get drops out is to press the bottom of the bottle. It's not like I did that myself, totally hypothetical, I always read all instructions from cover to cover. Yep.

Third Optional Step: Amp it Up

After about a month, you will not only have a base tan but have gotten the hang of these products and then you can intensify the process. I know some who use both products daily. I never would (I’m lazy, remember?) but I plan come May 1 to up the number of tanning drops at least for my legs to get them a bit browner.

Do know you don’t HAVE to do this every day. What’s great about these faux tan products is they fade super gradually. If you decide you want to go pale, if you forget the product on a weekend getaway, you decide for a week you don’t have the time or patience to rub in this stuff, no worries. It will fade away subtly like a normal tan.

Shop My Picks for Self-Tanning:

late-summer glow thanks to self-tanner and a swipe of this shimmery bronzer from e.l.f.

Tips for Faux Tanning the Face

The face is a completely different thing when it comes to self-tanner. I do know of people who use body self-tanner on their face… I am not one of those people. I will never forget when in middle school my friend Heather used Coppertone QT and walked into homeroom looking like a streaking Oompa Loompa. It scared me straight for decades since. If you go slow with tanning your bod, go even slower with your face. You can cover a streaky ankle with socks or ankle booties, a streaky face is another story.

I never used self-tanner on my face until 2014 and it was purely by accident. I received a sample of a Dr. Dennis Gross Glow Pad with a beauty order. I took it on vacation, thinking I’d try it out. I figured it was some sort of chemical exfoliator that would make my skin glow. I wiped my face with the cloth, added night cream, woke up the next morning looking as though I spent the day at the beach. Woah, when they said glow they meant sun glow? But I was surprised; no streaks, no orange skin, no visible point where I stopped using it. That day I placed an order for more of these pads and I must be on my 5th order of them. Every February when I look at my face in the mirror and wonder why I look so tired and gray I order a box and within a week am happier with my reflection. I order 1-2 boxes a year and only use it from February to October.

I only use these 2-3 times a week max because of the price. At night after cleansing, I use one pad. I wipe over each closed eye, then under each eye to be sure to get into the fine lines underneath. Then I wipe down my whole face like I am painting it, then I go again around the curves of my nose, wiping out towards my hairline and ears, I get the ears, I paint stripes from my jaw down to my chest filling in the space bordered by the bra, all the way from the front to behind the ears. I then sort of wipe all over after that so I don’t end up with possible stripes on my neck. A quick swipe or two from fingernails up each arm and then when the cloth is almost completely dry, I do another swipe near the hairline and neck just to be sure it’s all blended. It dries quickly and you can immediately after put on your creams, lotions, serums, and potions. I don’t recommend putting on any other chemical exfoliant or treatment (vitamin C, retinol, lactic acid, glycolic acid, etc.). Wash hands immediately (this has never given me straight up orange palms or streaks but it has given my hands a… warm glow).

Please buy these pads from a reputable seller such as Sephora.  I found a bigger box on Amazon for a great price. Half the box was fine, the other half they didn't work at all.  I ordered again, all the pads were dried out.  I get trying to save money, but this is a product where it's best to buy what you know to be the real deal and not expired. 

Doing this a couple of times a week will give you a subtle glow. If you want to go darker, I again recommend Clarins tanning drops, but the ones specifically made for the face. In the morning, I will add 2-4 drops to my daily moisturizer and apply as usual, being sure to get my neck and décolleté. Wash hands afterward. Two drops will provide the effect of the Dr. Dennis Gross pads, four drops will actually make you look as though you spent the day at the pool but without the pink cheeks and sun damage. I haven’t seen any streaking with the Clarins drops for face; I’ve added it to moisturizers from Colleen Rothschild, Paula’s Choice, and Neutrogena without issue. I have only added to lotion, not an oil or serum and am not sure how that would do.  I recommend getting this from somewhere like Nordstrom or Sephora so if you don't like the results you can return it. However, I find it to look very natural.

As an FYI, I didn’t like the Dr. Dennis Gross pads for the body; I got streaks. They may be great for some, but I think they require a lot of patience, a well-lit room, and a careful method to cover all skin evenly. I’ll stick to my lazy klutz solutions for self-tanner!

What to Do if You Get Self-Tanner Streaks

If you’re a lazy klutz like me, there’s a good chance even if you go slow and gradual, you’ll end up with streaks. I’ve found the best solution is to take a bath or a long hot shower so you skin is all soft and porous and warm and then scrub the heck out of it. Use your skin towel, use that St. Ives you know you shouldn’t use on your face but is still in the back of your linen closet, use kosher salt or sugar in some coconut oil and get to town. This is the best and the easiest, since you can do it right in your tub and shower.

If you still have streaks, I’ve used nail polish remover (acetone works better than without, but both will have some effect) and I’ve tried a half lemon with a bit of salt on it (hey it works for cleaning pans). This is best for a small specific spot (say the place where your foot meets your ankle that is on display and turned to the color of rust) as these options can cause irritation.

Do I Need Self-Tanner?

Again, I must reiterate that no one needs a tan to look and feel great. While a tan seemed like a beauty must a couple decades ago, these days pale skin is seen as beautiful and many celebs and fashionistas of all ages are sporting their natural pale skin with style. However, if you want a bit of a tan, I hope these tips will help you achieve it without too much trouble, time or streaks!

Shop the Post:

23 Comments

  1. RoseAG
    April 29, 2019 / 6:55 am

    I think the best reason to use a self-tanner is that it makes you feel more comfortable walking out the door in a swim suit or summer outfit.
    Jergens works well for me and it’s not $30 a tube.
    I’ve got a relaxed workplace with no strict code about stockings for women and May 1 I’m done with them. I will probably wait a few more weeks before breaking out the sandals, but I’m slathering the stuff on today to get ready for the bare leg switch over.

  2. April 28, 2019 / 7:09 pm

    You are an inspiration! Safe tanning is a must living in Fl and I’ll give it a go again. It is easy to be lazy!

  3. Fran Keeling
    April 27, 2019 / 10:10 pm

    Have you tried Isle of Paradise? It’s pretty easy.

    • May 1, 2019 / 10:38 am

      I haven’t! I was going to try their drops but they were sold out everywhere so I went with Clarins. I like Clarins, if I run out I may try Isle of Paradise next.

  4. Giuditta Reppi
    April 27, 2019 / 8:39 am

    Alison, I haven’t even read the article yet, but you look STUPDENDOUS! All your hard work is certainly showing results — good on you, dear!

  5. Jessica
    April 27, 2019 / 7:20 am

    I also like the look of a tan but have had some problems with self tanner in the past. 1–transfer onto clothes, especially inner pants seams, on hot/sweaty days. And 2– using self tanner on my face reeeeeally emphasized my darker patches/pigmentation and they stayed that way for years afterwards. Eek!

    Any suggestions or solutions for how to prevent self tanner stains inside clothes on a hot day?

    • RoseAG
      April 29, 2019 / 7:01 am

      Unless I”m heading to the shore I mostly just apply to my lower legs so I haven’t noticed it rubbing off onto inseams. If I”m going to wear shorts I got a little higher. When I know I’ll be in a bathing suit I mostly apply to my outer thighs with just a glaze on the inner. I let it dry, sometimes with the help of a hairdryer, and then get dressed. I’ve noticed that when I shower after applying tanner earlier in the day that something lotiony comes off, so you might apply at night, wear jammies to bed then do a washcloth wipe down the next morning over your thighs to get any residual off.

      • Jessica
        April 30, 2019 / 2:52 am

        Great solutions!

  6. Rose
    April 26, 2019 / 11:51 pm

    Hi Alison—I’m going to have to try your suggestions. I’ve used Jergens in the past and I apply my normal body cream after a shower and allow it to absorb. Then I apply Jergens Natural Glow and that seems to work well in that order.
    If you’re using the skin towel daily doesn’t that remove the faux tan or only some of it? Just wondering how the tan would build if you’re always removing it daily in the shower? Do you ever get to a point where you need to remove all the faux tan and start over?

    • May 1, 2019 / 12:14 pm

      I haven’t noticed me rubbing it all off. I bet it takes some off but it still seems to build, maybe more gradually than if I didn’t use the skin towel. I’ve never found I had to wear it off and start over, it really is gradual and builds evenly.

  7. Melissa
    April 26, 2019 / 2:53 pm

    Oh, how I wish, wish, wish I could use self tanner . High end, low end, organic, hypoallergenic, you name the brand, I have tried it, and each and every one makes me break out in an angry red raised itchy as all get out rash by the second day. Sigh. Oh, I’ve embraced my paleness (I have no choice!‍♀️) but if I am ever reincarnated, I want to come back as a bronzed goddess!

    • May 1, 2019 / 12:15 pm

      I’m so sorry! But really, paleness is super chic and the most current look. Rock it Melissa!

    • Christine
      May 6, 2019 / 7:26 pm

      You might also consider a bronzing powder compact and a BIG makeup brush — I use this on my legs to take the bright white edge off!

  8. Ruth Slavid
    April 26, 2019 / 11:28 am

    I read your intro and thought, oh yes, that’s me, the lazy klutz. Never tried self tanning – OK never really tried any tanning – maybe I should give it a go. But your definition of lazy and mine are just not the same. This sounds like far far too much work. I’ll stay white thanks. But filled with admiration for your effort.

    • May 1, 2019 / 12:16 pm

      LOL we all have different levels of what we’re willing to do in different areas and none of us are wrong!

  9. April 26, 2019 / 11:11 am

    Lazy klutz? Yeah that’s me. haha I’m very pale and now that the weather is warming up I’m starting to not only wear clothes that show more skin, I’m also taking pictures wearing said clothes for my blog and the result isn’t nice. I look so pale and no matter how much people try to tell me to embrace my colour I just can’t help but feel like if I was tanned, I’d look better. Not to mention that as soon as I get my legs out I get comments like “where did you get that bruise?” to which I simply shrug because I have no clue. So I think this spring I’m gonna try a fake tanner and I’ve gathered a few blog posts on how to do it but none had catered to my lazy personality so thank you for that, I’m gonna try it your way.

    • May 1, 2019 / 12:17 pm

      LOL I could have written the same thing about bruises!

  10. Barb
    April 26, 2019 / 10:00 am

    I have fair skin with cool undertones and have used the Jergens in fair-medium for years. I’m not a fan of the scent, but it does dissipate fairly quickly. I’ve been meaning to try the medium to dark version but wondered if it would look more fake. If it works for you, it should work for me! For those who share my age spots that darken with self-tanner, I’ve read to rub them with a Q-tip dipped in moisturizer after applying the self-tanner.

    • Jessica
      April 30, 2019 / 2:55 am

      Barb you are so smart! Thx for the q-tip idea

    • May 1, 2019 / 12:20 pm

      I can’t go straight into it, I do need to use a whole tube of the pale first. I tried going in first and it did feel fake but also I could see streaks.

  11. Amy
    April 26, 2019 / 8:23 am

    Fellow klutz here! Great post! I have very light skin with pink undertones which often makes it hard to find self tanners that don’t go orange on me. Or is too intense. Or both. The Tan-Luxe Gradual Tanning Illuminating lotion is the best I’ve ever used. Ulta and Sephora both carry it (though it’s cheaper at Ulta, for some reason) and it’s the easiest thing I’ve ever used to get nice natural color. Not sure how it would work on darker skin tones – but for me, I can rub it on using a mitt right out of the shower. No streaks (I have no idea how – I just kind of rub it on) and just extremely natural color. You can build it up – but I use it every 2-3 days and it just maintains a lovely golden glow.

    I’m definitely going to grab some of those Dr. Dennis Gross pads during the upcoming Sephora sale – thanks for the tip!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

powered by chloédigital